Michael's St. Augustine

In general one would not think a restaurant in a hotel would be worth a visit unless you are staying there, Michael’s is an exception to that assumption. It is fine dining in a beautiful spot.

The service was what you would except from a 5 restaurant. Their wine selection was incredible. My steak was prepared perfectly. And they had something I had never seen at a steak house. A vegetable medley with a potato dish. It was perfect for me as I was solo dinner and had everything you would want in a steak dinner. I wanted to try the desert but I was too stuffed (in a good way).

If you are in the area this is a great dinner and they validate the valet. I am sorry for not taking more photos but the presentation was amazing. Please come and enjoy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great meal and service from Ryan. Would go back/recommend 100%

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicki was a great server. Very personable and knowledgeable. She was eager to ensure our visit was fantastic and encouraged us to return! We definitely will!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sub par at best.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Wow, wow, wow. This was our first time at Michael’s restaurant my sister Yevgeniya has been raving about how amazing the food is and invited us to come. The atmosphere of the restaurant set the tone for the evening, relaxing, peaceful and calm. The food was exquisite and served with perfection. The runner did an amazing job presenting the food. The waiter was patient with us, sense we were a large group and the restaurant worked with us when we needed to add a few more spots. We had such a great time can’t wait to be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First, I’d like to start by sharing my gratitude to the wonderful team at Michael’s for making my family feel so special and going above and beyond in their welcoming and accommodating us in their private dining room. We just experienced a heavy loss in our family and they took such great care of us. Thank you to All involved. Yevgeniya was wonderful! David, our server went above and beyond to our every request and need. The food was just delicious and mouth watering. Such a great atmosphere and all the displays are beautiful! We will definitely be back to try more of their delicious menu offerings. Once again, thank you for the wonderful experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fantastic service and a great wine list make for a very enjoyable dining experience. Food was well prepared and mostly delicious. The staff genuinely cares that you have a great experience, and they bent over backwards to make it happen - highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

5 stars Michel’s - Vero Beach
Had an amazing dinner with friends at Michel’s—upscale yet relaxed, with perfect coastal vibes.
Our server Delaney was absolutely incredible: warm, attentive, spot-on with recommendations, and truly made the night special. Management, please give Delaney a raise—she deserves it!
Loved the fresh beet salad to start. Mains were outstanding:
• Swordfish: perfectly seared and flavorful
• Salmon: flaky and buttery
• Short ribs: tender and rich
• Steak: juicy, cooked just right
Everything was delicious and beautifully presented. We all left raving and planning our next visit. Highly recommend—ask for Delaney!

Hands down best restaurant in St. Augustine and its not even close.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oysters for an appetizer were tasteless. The horseradish was not fresh as it had no heat and the datyl sauce was bland. However the Branzino was excellent. If the chef was trying to sear the skin to a crust, he failed. The skin came off like a soggy wrapper. BUT, the Sea Bass was perfectly sauteed along with the artichokes, citrus and olives

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Delicious as always!! Everything was wonderful.... Service, food, ambiance, it was all top notch.

My first time to eat red meat in 5 years so I was looking forward to taking the personal challenge. We had the filet medallions and ordered them MR/M. Waiter said they would be definitely pink inside. There was no pink ANYWHERE and they were dry. Very disappointed but that will teach me to not eat those poor little cows! And stick with the seafood. Sorry, I have no sympathy for fish. We will still go back and give it another shot. We enjoy the ambience and the staff.

An elegant restaurant for date night, special occasions, or dinner with friends. The food was delicious and the staff were knowledgeable and exceptional at pairing from the wine selection. We will definitely be returning.

Everything about our experience was amazing—from the dinner and wine service to the ambience. The food was exceptional, the atmosphere was inviting, and the entire evening felt special. A heartfelt thank you to our wonderful server, Christian, who truly made the night memorable with attentive, thoughtful, and impeccable service. We can't wait to return!

We've lived in the area for nearly twelve years and enjoy fine dining as a couple for nearly forty years worldwide. Since Michaels opened this was our sixth visit and we are, very impressed! In fact, this is now our favorite steak/seafood restaurant in the St Augustine and South Ponte Vedra Beach area. Starting with the complimentary valet parking at the Hyatt, to the lobby bar, to dinner in the restaurant, we now know that Michael has his signature restaurant extremely well-tuned to take the lead in fine dining in the area. Specifically, from the wine list to the dozen raw oysters, and the stone crab appetizer, to the Waldorf salad, and the perfectly cooked large perfectly cooked, tender filet...absolutely awesome and priced right for these times! We will be back often since it's only ten minutes from where we live in North Beach!