Dinner with client. Excellent wine selection. Only thing that kept me from rating higher was the mark up on their wines.
Bruce
It was my wife's birthday, which was noted when I made the reservation. When we sat down there was a card with personal birthday wishes from the restaurant management The food was excellent. The waiter was very attentive. The piano player/singer added to the romantic atmosphere.. I recommend Michael's.
Debra
Incredible place on all levels..we are “foodies” from NY that moved to Saint Augustine about 6 months ago. We went to Michael's for our anniversary and were blown away by the quality of the food, the service(shout out to Amy!), and the ambiance. We will return as often as possible!
Tonya
The food was delicious however the new location is quite loud. To make matters worse there was a piano player that added to the noise. Instead of hearing nice piano music it added to the noise and amplified it. Our server was awesome. She was very attentive and took great care of us. If they can take the noise down and did some sound deadening around the place it would be a 5 star experience.
LaTarsha
My family and I had a wonderful dinner with exceptional service and good drinks. This was our first time at the restaurant and it didn't disappoint.
Roger
We had a wonderful meal: Shrimp skillet and beet salad appetizers were both excellent. We both had Beef Wellington which is superb. If you order this, you can "split" and order and it will be plenty for two people. The Key Lime "Pie" dessert was more the consistency of cheesecake and was the only disappointment. Waiter was great. $30 corkage fee is the highest we have paid in St. Augustine except for Le Nouvelle which is owned by the same people. Noise level was pretty high and impeded conversation.
Lauren
We had and amazing night and Jason was fantastic! Michael's will definitely be a special spot we frequent with our family! Thank you so much!!
Galina
I had high expectations coming in, but unfortunately, this restaurant did not live up to the price point. Wine list was too much. The live music was especially disappointing — the performer was dull and lacked energy, which made the atmosphere feel more lifeless than luxurious. It's hard to enjoy a meal when the background music feels like a chore to listen to. The servers were wearing sneakers, which might be fine in a casual spot, but not in a place positioning itself as a top-tier dining experience. Attention to detail matters!
McKayla
Boyfriend chose this as his birthday dinner- it was STELLAR! get the wellington it's amazing
Amanda
Ashley was one of the best servers I have ever had! Thank you for making our night so special. Also the food is excellent!
had gone to the old location and came to the new. the new is even better - so gorgeous, OUTSTANDING service, fabulous food, great ambience. the total package. love this place. great drinks and food.
Kris
The food was amazing. The wine selection was also amazing. The service and som were equally fantastic. The prices were a tad bit high, but nothing too crazy.
Felipe
Never disappointed. Always just a great experience with amazing wine that pairs so well with the food.
Alex
From start to finish it was a great experience. From appetizers to dessert, you will be wowed. Also the cocktails and mocktails were nothing short of amazing. The waiter staff was attentive and explained all the different options and made personal recommendations as well. We will be back for sure!
Stephan
Have been in St. Augustine several times, always eating out. However, Michael‘s was by far the best experience so far, both regarding food, the excellent wine and the general atmosphere.
Dinner with client. Excellent wine selection. Only thing that kept me from rating higher was the mark up on their wines.
It was my wife's birthday, which was noted when I made the reservation. When we sat down there was a card with personal birthday wishes from the restaurant management The food was excellent. The waiter was very attentive. The piano player/singer added to the romantic atmosphere.. I recommend Michael's.
Incredible place on all levels..we are “foodies” from NY that moved to Saint Augustine about 6 months ago. We went to Michael's for our anniversary and were blown away by the quality of the food, the service(shout out to Amy!), and the ambiance. We will return as often as possible!
The food was delicious however the new location is quite loud. To make matters worse there was a piano player that added to the noise. Instead of hearing nice piano music it added to the noise and amplified it. Our server was awesome. She was very attentive and took great care of us. If they can take the noise down and did some sound deadening around the place it would be a 5 star experience.
My family and I had a wonderful dinner with exceptional service and good drinks. This was our first time at the restaurant and it didn't disappoint.
We had a wonderful meal: Shrimp skillet and beet salad appetizers were both excellent. We both had Beef Wellington which is superb. If you order this, you can "split" and order and it will be plenty for two people. The Key Lime "Pie" dessert was more the consistency of cheesecake and was the only disappointment. Waiter was great. $30 corkage fee is the highest we have paid in St. Augustine except for Le Nouvelle which is owned by the same people. Noise level was pretty high and impeded conversation.
We had and amazing night and Jason was fantastic! Michael's will definitely be a special spot we frequent with our family! Thank you so much!!
I had high expectations coming in, but unfortunately, this restaurant did not live up to the price point. Wine list was too much. The live music was especially disappointing — the performer was dull and lacked energy, which made the atmosphere feel more lifeless than luxurious. It's hard to enjoy a meal when the background music feels like a chore to listen to. The servers were wearing sneakers, which might be fine in a casual spot, but not in a place positioning itself as a top-tier dining experience. Attention to detail matters!
Boyfriend chose this as his birthday dinner- it was STELLAR! get the wellington it's amazing
Ashley was one of the best servers I have ever had! Thank you for making our night so special. Also the food is excellent!
Restaurantji Recommends
had gone to the old location and came to the new. the new is even better - so gorgeous, OUTSTANDING service, fabulous food, great ambience. the total package. love this place. great drinks and food.
The food was amazing. The wine selection was also amazing. The service and som were equally fantastic. The prices were a tad bit high, but nothing too crazy.
Never disappointed. Always just a great experience with amazing wine that pairs so well with the food.
From start to finish it was a great experience. From appetizers to dessert, you will be wowed. Also the cocktails and mocktails were nothing short of amazing. The waiter staff was attentive and explained all the different options and made personal recommendations as well. We will be back for sure!
Have been in St. Augustine several times, always eating out. However, Michael‘s was by far the best experience so far, both regarding food, the excellent wine and the general atmosphere.
Loading...