Unless you're flying to Naples, Italy, this is going to be the closest thing. I was watching the entire process from start to finish and even having some great banter with the owner while he was making us 6 margherita pizzas on the fly. The way he folded the dough and stretched it was exactly how the process is taught and done in real Napolitano style. The dough was on point, sauce was authentic (approved by my rather large family who have just flown in from Naples, Italy) and I knew this was something else when my aunt exclaimed, "Wow, finally someone who does not put oregano in pizza sauce!" The trademark charred crust was beautifully adorned on each pizza and each bite took me back to my youth when we spent summers in Naples with family, where the pizzas just simply melt in your mouth 😋 Well done, Real Peel, well done. You have managed to satisfy 6 authetic, native, and extremely strict Napolitano Italians who were not going to let cut corners slide. 👏👏👏
Highly recommend, and definitely coming back. I'm glad to have finally found the only real pizza in St Augustine!!
Bryan Walter
When Slugs closed down I was heart broken.....This has somewhat filled the void! Great craft beer rotation, even getting companies like Magnanimous out of Tampa. Also, has the cheap offerings like Busch Light, and PBR.
Zach where ever he has worked has always been good. He needs a documentary done on his life. What a bunch of great stories I have heard from him !
Cant go wrong at this place! Brilliant decor and uniqueness!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cartier Lammert
True neighborhood bar, walked in then out. Just not my kind of place.
Atmosphere: 3
Alyssa S
I give this place 10/10 every time UNTIL homegirl with the tats comes up. She's great at first but there's always a change. She's double charged me in the past, refused to serve me but serve my husband. Today, I got a face in mine because I was "worrying and sketchy" over taking leaves that were in the dirt in hopes of propagating them. The two other bartenders were gracious and expressed my same concern of "let's create more". Except we were met with this woman and some other guy THROWING an entire plant at my husband's FACE. When he told her that was assault, she said, "yeah."
Part of this staff is teaching my young boys certain games, chatting with them as if they're just another patron, giving lessons, it's all so wonderful. Everyone has their days, but a plant/dirt in the face is FAR too much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Palmour's Coffee
Fun neighborhood bar, a great place to go have a drink and hang out with friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Whitney Doty
Great atmosphere and local feel. Good place to go if you are strange.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Holly Wheeler
Love this little bar!! I wish it was in my hood!! Cool outdoor patio!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 4
Norbert Joseph John Tuseo
Pizza truck on site with excellent whole pizzas(no slices) Otherwise hot dogs only Funky decor Outside seating Typically younger patrons Parking available across the street Norbert tuseo
Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza available
Parking: Located across the street
Wheelchair accessibility: Outdoor seating
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Osburn
Awesome staff and super cool laid back 80s vibe. Definitely going back. The five stars on food was for the Real Peel pizza truck outside serving the best high quality ingredient pizzas. Perfect night watching 1st round of 2024 NFL draft ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Gregory
Staff is rude and obnoxious. Don't waste your $. Money spent better elsewhere. Seems to be a bunch of youngsters trying to do a grown-ups job. Need training in hospitality and professionalism.
Unless you're flying to Naples, Italy, this is going to be the closest thing. I was watching the entire process from start to finish and even having some great banter with the owner while he was making us 6 margherita pizzas on the fly. The way he folded the dough and stretched it was exactly how the process is taught and done in real Napolitano style. The dough was on point, sauce was authentic (approved by my rather large family who have just flown in from Naples, Italy) and I knew this was something else when my aunt exclaimed, "Wow, finally someone who does not put oregano in pizza sauce!" The trademark charred crust was beautifully adorned on each pizza and each bite took me back to my youth when we spent summers in Naples with family, where the pizzas just simply melt in your mouth 😋 Well done, Real Peel, well done. You have managed to satisfy 6 authetic, native, and extremely strict Napolitano Italians who were not going to let cut corners slide. 👏👏👏 Highly recommend, and definitely coming back. I'm glad to have finally found the only real pizza in St Augustine!!
When Slugs closed down I was heart broken.....This has somewhat filled the void! Great craft beer rotation, even getting companies like Magnanimous out of Tampa. Also, has the cheap offerings like Busch Light, and PBR.
Zach where ever he has worked has always been good. He needs a documentary done on his life. What a bunch of great stories I have heard from him !
Cant go wrong at this place! Brilliant decor and uniqueness!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
True neighborhood bar, walked in then out. Just not my kind of place.
Atmosphere: 3
I give this place 10/10 every time UNTIL homegirl with the tats comes up. She's great at first but there's always a change. She's double charged me in the past, refused to serve me but serve my husband. Today, I got a face in mine because I was "worrying and sketchy" over taking leaves that were in the dirt in hopes of propagating them. The two other bartenders were gracious and expressed my same concern of "let's create more". Except we were met with this woman and some other guy THROWING an entire plant at my husband's FACE. When he told her that was assault, she said, "yeah."
Part of this staff is teaching my young boys certain games, chatting with them as if they're just another patron, giving lessons, it's all so wonderful. Everyone has their days, but a plant/dirt in the face is FAR too much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fun neighborhood bar, a great place to go have a drink and hang out with friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great atmosphere and local feel. Good place to go if you are strange.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Love this little bar!! I wish it was in my hood!! Cool outdoor patio!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 4
Pizza truck on site with excellent whole pizzas(no slices)
Otherwise hot dogs only
Funky decor
Outside seating
Typically younger patrons
Parking available across the street
Norbert tuseo
Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza available
Parking: Located across the street
Wheelchair accessibility: Outdoor seating
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome staff and super cool laid back 80s vibe. Definitely going back. The five stars on food was for the Real Peel pizza truck outside serving the best high quality ingredient pizzas. Perfect night watching 1st round of 2024 NFL draft ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Staff is rude and obnoxious. Don't waste your $. Money spent better elsewhere. Seems to be a bunch of youngsters trying to do a grown-ups job. Need training in hospitality and professionalism.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Fabulous pizza… some of the best I have ever had! Can’t wait to go back!! Truck was parked at Muggsy's.
Great atmosphere, love that people bring their dogs. Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A cool retro bar vibe. They don't have food but there is a pizza food truck on the property.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Love this little place. ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Bartender told us to go else ware. Been in the town for 25
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...