Pizzalley's on St. George

folks, we have been here two days in Saint Augustine, and this meal was by far the best. You cannot do wrong with this place.

The restaurant wasn't full, and the service was like they didn't want you there. The pizza of the month didn't have any flavor other than salty.

We go every time we're in St. Augustine. Sometimes we'll make the drive just for Pizzalley's. Best pizza in Florida.

4/5. Fish n Chips is overpriced for $28 just for the batter to still be a bit soggy, pizza however was amazing. The lavender cocktail they offer was really good too!!

This pizza place was awesome, a little hidden in a parking lot, you should've sign out toward the road. My boyfriend and I got the fig and pig overall great pizza wish I could taste MORE fig and bacon, the crust was nice crispy awesome. The staff was very nice as well. In the mood for pizza most definitely try it out.

Awesome place with great food. Alfredo sauce is amazing!

Great food - Dog friendly - Service by Casey was impeccable.

What a major disappointment. We paid $15 for some frozen mozzarella sticks. Maybe a quarter of a box. And the pizza was tombstone taste with some canned veggies on top. Not worth the $40 bill

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

The food was absolutely amazing! Our waitress Karen was fantastic and very personable. She recommended the Terrimasu Martini and it was to die for. Totally recommend and can't wait to go back. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wonderful Italian restaurant in the historic portion of St Augustine. The staff are very friendly and professional. The service is fast and friendly. Most important the food is affordable and extremely well prepared. Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Why 1 star, if I don't have any serious complaints about the food, servicez or atmosphere? Because they charge like it's a fine dining restaurant, but the dining experience is no better than Olive Garden. That's not a knock on Olive Garden I've eaten at Olive Gardon before, and I'll probably eat there again. The take away, if you're going to charge premium prices, I would expect at least something to be premium quality, but it's all very average at Pizzalley's.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Stopped in for a late lunch. Jeremy waited on us and was great. We couldn’t take our leftovers because we didn’t bring a cooler and were staying downtown for a couple more hours. Jeremy kept our take-home bag in the restaurant frig for us until we came back by. Talk about great extra service!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza, Garbage Can

Food was outstanding. Bar was out of a special ingredient for one of the drinks but was able to make something special for my wife anyway and she loved it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

My family and I used to live in Palm Coast and came here in between OB appointments ,loving it EVERY time. Fast forward 14 years, we moved to central Fl West. Our kids now born were told how great the pizza was so we went for a 97 mile drive to spend our day in St. Auggie with the intent of this pizza. We loved the new decor, the friendly host and then energetic server who said the "Farmer's Market" pizza we ordered was the one she named. The pizza did NOT disappoint. So worth a nostalgic visit with our kids. We're planning another drive back soon.

We enjoyed our food and service. Thank you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza