Rufino's Pizza
2700 FL-16, St. Augustine
(904) 819-5399
Customers' Favorites
The Supreme Big Slice xx Large
Spinach & Broccoli Pinwheel
16 Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese XXL Slice
Pepperoni Rolls
The Special -18
Garlic Knots 6
Cheese Pizza
Square Pizza
White Pizza
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This place is such a hidden gem, hands down the best and most authentic NY style pizza in FL. The location is weird for the quality I’ll admit, but don’t sleep on this place! Dave from one bite pizza reviews would love this place, but I don’t want to deal with a line!
On trial: Rufino’s Pizza
Food: The pizza was good with a nice crisp thin crust. Flavor was decent. Nothing overly exciting. On the greasier side.
Service: The make was about 25mins for a fresh pizza. They have pre-made pizzas you can buy by the slice which might be the better way to go. It was fairly pricey at $32 for a 3 topping 18in pizza
Atmosphere: This is the big downfall as the location is in a food court. It was...
Food: The pizza was good with a nice crisp thin crust. Flavor was decent. Nothing overly exciting. On the greasier side.
Service: The make was about 25mins for a fresh pizza. They have pre-made pizzas you can buy by the slice which might be the better way to go. It was fairly pricey at $32 for a 3 topping 18in pizza
Atmosphere: This is the big downfall as the location is in a food court. It was...
Amazing NY‑style pizza in a food court! Crisp, flavorful slices with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Plus, they offer a great combo deal—pizza slice with a drink—for about $6–$7. Friendly staff and lightning-fast service. A must‑try if you’re shopping at the outlets!
You May Also Like
Auntie Anne's - 2700 FL-16 Space #106A
![]()
Pretzel Store, Bakery, Pretzels, Fast Food
Blue Wave Nutrition, LLC - 2730 FL-16 #116
![]()
Health Food, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Jin Sushi Hibachi Thai - 2730 FL-16
![]()
Thai, Teppanyaki, Sushi Bar