Schmagel's Bagels

They don't serve city water 👍🏻😃

We left before ordering. HAVING A HEAT WAVE AT 10 AM, asked for ice and water and was snipped at that they don’t have city water 🥵🥵🥵😡😡😡😡😡😡. I WOULD NOT BUY MY DOG FOOD HERE

Wish I could give this place more stars!!! Make sure you get there early, they sell out fast! Which isn’t surprising because the bagels are to die for. Service is top notch and everyone is so sweet! First time visiting St. Augustine and I will be back just to go to this place!

Great bagels and great atmosphere. Ordered two egg and bagel sandwiches. Serving of pork roll on bagel was surprising in a very positive way. Will definitely be a regular stop on our travels through town

Food & vibe is amazing. Only comment is that every time we order a latte, the staff says that they don't serve lattes, but it is on their board, and it's just espresso with milk - which they do serve. Just be prepared to deconstruct your drink, but as a bagel shop - they should familiarize themselves with the lingo. Otherwise, we love it here.

I was looking for a small little brunch place as I was exploring downtown St Augustine, and I wandered into this little gem. I ordered a garlic bagel with hummus as I can’t have dairy (even though I really wanted to have some of their homemade cream cheese!)
They also offer homemade hummus so I got that instead and it was fabulous! I sat on the cozy patio under a live oak tree and had a wonderful solo lunch.

Very good and soft bagels. It was nice to sit outside with my dog and have breakfast.

What a gem this place is! I had the Mediterranean on a Tuscan bagel, and it was amazing!

Before the pandemic, my sister and I found this bagel shop and thought why not give it a try. We were amazed!! We ordered bagels to take home because they were the best bagels we ever had. A few years went by, my fiance and I took a short trip to St Augustine and I told her we HAVE to go here for breakfast. The first morning there, I walked to get bagels and bring them back to the Airbnb. My fiance literally was speechless and was blown by the flavor of the bagel and cream cheese. Being a chef herself and specializing in breakfast sandwiches, she was curious of how their sandwiches tasted. We went back the next day and just as she thought, better than the day before. The outside seating is absolutely adorable and the staff is a gem. I refer EVERYONE to go here and try their bagels and cream cheese to start or to jump right in and get one of their amazing sandwiches. We look forward to visiting again.

They sell out pretty quick, two days in a row sold out by 1030.. delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We are locals here and Schmagel’s Bagels is our favorite way to start the day . The owners are amazing people, the atmosphere is great and everything on menu is delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwiches, Cheddar-Jack Bagel, Bagel with Homemade Cream Cheese, Sandwiches

Perfect fall crispy day, amazing bagels, and coffee ☕️ If there was an option for more than 5 stars, I'd do it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Plain Bagel, Breakfast Sandwiches, Sandwiches

The best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwiches, Everything Bagel, Sandwiches

Delicious bagel sandwiches! This is a great, quick option for breakfast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Choose a Bagel Meat Cheese and Vegetables, Breakfast Sandwiches

Schmagel's Bagels is easily one of the best food establishments I've been to maybe ever. Started going in the mornings every so often before classes at Flagler, and now I regularly go to get bagels. I'm always incredibly happy with how awesome the food and staff are, and I highly, highly suggest that you try this place if you haven't yet. You won't be disappointed!

Super friendly atmosphere, amazing food, and in a great spot if you wanted to walk to other spots in the city. It's a fantastic place to visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5