Tedi's Olde Tyme Ice Cream

65 St George St, St. Augustine
(904) 825-1730

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dawnita Snyder

Great staff and great milkshake--I got the espresso and the portion was so generous, I shared with my hubby who doesn't even like coffee--but he sure drank more than his fair share😜 5-stars for Tedi's!!!

Cody DiCicco

Large portions and great selection. We got an ice cream cone black cherry which was really good. We also got a cup which was huge! The staff were very sweet and prompt given the time and line. The establishment is very clean.

Don Davenport

A cute little shop with many great ice-cream flavors.

Hayleigh Bowen

The ice cream and latte (caramel) were beyond delicious. But what was even more amazing about this place were the truly wonderful staff. When we were there, a huge pop-up rainstorm sent a lot of people from the surrounding streets running into all the shops on St. George for cover, including Tedi’s, and the three women working there at the time could not have been kinder and more welcoming to everyone. They took it upon themselves to keep the floor dry, updated us about the storm’s movements, and did everything they could to keep everyone there comfortable and safe, whether they were buying product or not. I have so much admiration for the genuine kindness these people showed to strangers, and so much appreciation for how delicious the ice cream and coffee were. We will return every time we’re in the area.

Kellie Eppa

EDIT!!!!
This owner stepped up to me being overcharged and refunded me a credit. That is very good customer

The ice cream was very creamy and yummy. They offered samples if you wanted. The star rating was for the inconsistent price. I had one scoop in a cup and my husband had 2, the price was $5 more than the menu price, when I glanced up puzzled, the girl said the prices changed a few weeks ago, she said she’s mentioned it a few times since the menu doesn’t reflect that but she only works here so $21.50!!!!

I messaged you on Facebook messenger because I couldn’t figure out how to respond to you. So my Apple wallet shows my receipt for Saturday night at 9:30 for $20.77. She was a small young, white girl. Single scoop $6.50 in a cup and $9.95 for a double. Thank you for your concern

Will Gentner

Get the cookie butter crunch milkshake it was so good! Staff was great

Alan Ray

The customer service was amazing! It is so rare to find that anymore. We were trying to avoid food dye and they were so helpful and went above and beyond to help us find out which flavors were suitable.

Thank you!!

Joy Skaggs

The ice cream was delicious, and the staff were delightful! Definitely a good place for a sweet treat.

Ryan Rambo Wilde Sr.

Crap service and attitude. Rude girl behind the counter. No gloves used when scooping or holding cones. Go to Kilwin's or anywhere else honestly.

Sarah Penrod

Very yummy ice cream. They le you split a single scoop between 2 flavors and the serving size for a single scoop is very generous. We all enjoyed the flavors. There was a good mix of traditional flavors and special flavors.

Annie Cacciatore

Great ice cream, lattes and waffle cones

AJ Y

We normally have a nice experience, but today was so weird. We came in with friends and one of our party wanted one scoop in a waffle bowl. The older blonde lady proceeded to tell my friend the waffle cone with two scoops was a better “situation”, even though my friend had told her she wanted to eat her ice cream out of a bowl and only one scoop. But the blonde wouldn’t have it. If we hadn’t already ordered two ice creams I would have left. Just rude service. We live in town, so we aren’t just one-time tourists. We won’t be coming back. Too many friendlier service options with just as good or better ice cream.

Maddie Shepherd

birthday cake ice cream was so good!! the ladies were the sweetest

Charles Caldwell

Kahlua chip ice cream was the best!

Vesela Docheva

Very good ice cream. Very large servings! Nice staff :)

Loading...