Tony's Pizza New York Style
6975 A1A S #2, St. Augustine
(904) 471-9027
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza & Cheese Pizza
Sausage Parmigiana Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Sicilian Pizza
Pineapple Pizza
Stuffed Shells
Green Olives
Garlic Knots
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We have enjoyed the pineapple and ham pizza at Tony’s. Can get busy but I have always gone for take out. Despite being busy, our normal time gets us in and out within 25 minutes. They do have a few places to sit down inside but they’ll most likely be occupied, however there are beach and river access next door. There’s a good park with plenty of parking across the street where I have just sat at a park bench and enjoyed the evening. Location has easy on and off island access...
This is definitely is not true Italian/ New York style pizza so I’m not sure why some people equate this as such. They use a TON of sauce and the crust is thicker and chewier than real New York style. Staff was super friendly and pizza was ok but the expectations were set pretty high and this is just mediocre pizza.
I love Tony's! They make the best white pizza I've ever had, and I try not to miss an opportunity to order one. I also enjoy their antipasto salad, a big portion of yummy goodness! Today, I ordered my pizza from the car, and when Tony says 20 minutes, he means it. I pulled up, and he pulled out my pizza. A match made in heaven!
You May Also Like
Island Ice Cream Cafe - 6975 A1A S
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Coffee & Tea, Ice Cream
Elkhouse Eatery - 6357 A1A S
![]()
Seafood, American, Wine Bar, New American