Twisted Turtle Creamery LLC
425 W Town Pl suite 116, St. Augustine
(904) 460-2643
Customers' Favorites
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Banana Split Monkey Around
Strawberry Short Stuff
Allmond Bros Sundae
The Turtle Club
Butter Pecan
Trifle
Waffle
Menu
Photos
+2 photos
+1 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Finally found it! A specialty custard place with all natural flavors and creative sundaes made in house by our favorite mother daughter team! Just had the Pumpkin Twister that was absolutely delicious and not too sweet as it is made with real pumpkin puree! Will be back!
Just had a delicious old brownie Sunday. My son and I are a bit of snobs with “ice cream” since we actually prefer “custard”, lo and behold, this place makes custard and not traditional ice cream. Super delicious texture! It appears it’s a family owned business and all the service people were super sweet and helpful! Definitely coming back!
My new favorite frozen yogurt - it kinda needs its own category; it’s so good it’s like a different food. The homemade cheesecake bites (gf) are insane. Very friendly owner. We’ll be back!
You May Also Like
Pirate Pizza WGV - 425 W Town Pl #114
![]()
Pizza, Salad
Cafe Cairano - 425 W Town Pl UNIT 108
![]()
American, Italian