Your Pie Palencia
CLOSED$ •
389 Paseo Reyes Dr Suite 205, St. Augustine
About Your Pie
Your Pie Reviews
We loved it! My kids enjoyed getting to see their pizzas being made and said that it was the best part of our trip to St. Augustine. The butterfinger gelato was delicious, too. Great service & will definitely stop in the next time we’re in town. 2 very enthusiastic thumbs up!
Well we tried Your Pie pizza for the first time today (by Palencia). I try to give restaurants a little slack but this time was just not good. My boyfriend and I bought two pizzas with side salads. Got our drinks, sat down, ate our salads. Waited twenty minutes and still no pizzas. After 30 minutes the lady brings out mine and asks if we wanted plates, at which point we said “um no…we got two pizzas.” And she looks quite confused. My pizza is cold. Like not even warm. She...read full review
The pizza is always good and their customer service is outstanding!!
Ratings
Menu
People in St. Augustine Also Viewed
Your Pie Palencia is a neighborhood gem where fresh pizzas are made to order. Guests can watch their pizzas being crafted at the counter before being popped into the oven. The 10-inch pizzas are plenty for a satisfying meal. The pizzas are piping hot when served, so caution is advised when taking the first bites. With great service and a welcoming atmosphere, Your Pie Palencia is a great spot for a quick lunch or dinner. The staff is attentive to special dietary needs, with one customer noting how Elliot carefully explained allergen information for the crusts and ensured their gluten-free pizza was perfect. Many guests find the pizza to be outstanding, with some calling it the best they have ever tasted. Popular choices include the hot honey, peach, and cheese steak pizzas, all praised for their flavor. The manager Kim and her team are known for their kindness and helpfulness, making customers feel welcomed. Overall, Your Pie Palencia offers a friendly environment where guests can enjoy freshly made, delicious pizza in a cozy setting.