Ordered the Stromboli, hubby ordered the Steak 🥩 and cheese 🧀 sandwich. The Stromboli was really delicious 🤤 but the sandwich 🥪 just average. Needed more meat 🥩 and pepper 🫑 and onion 🧅. The Stromboli is huge, enough for a double meal 🥘. Place is super clean 🧼 and prices 💵💰just average. Wait person was real nice 👍
Parking: This is the new location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli
Chami Winningham
The Alfredo tasted like it had too much flour and not even parmesan. But the pizza is good and the servers were kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Melissa Morris
Cute little place in Starke I like how it's set up The food is delicious But the portion size for the lasagna is really tiny for the price of $13 doesn't come with a salad or anything just a really tiny piece of bread. And also should mention on your kids menu that the cheese quesadilla is made with mozzarella most people expect like a cheddar or American cheese are yellow cheese of some kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Lenora Griffin
We had pasta. Everything was right temp, appealing and tasty. Shrimp Frangelico and stuffed salmon. Yum!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salads
wayne denucci
Great Food , Great Prices , Staff very friendly , Resturant very clean, I little parking problem ,Stop by and order some pizza you'll be glad you did !!! I hope this review helped have a great day !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristie Kent
We ordered stuffed garlic knots, chicken parmesean. Everything was tasty but the knots were a bit doughy and the entree could have been a bit hotter. Our waitress was very friendly and the atmosphere was welcoming.
I ordered the Meat Lovers Calzone and the Grilled Chicken Wrap with a side salad and to go tea and mountain blast Powerade. Everything was fabulous and the ladies were amazing. I highly recommend. I always have a wonderful experience with them no matter when I go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Salad, Chicken Wrap
Amy W
Changed locations and looks like changed owners. Double check menus photos.
Food: 3
Service: 4
78JNW78
I was very disappointed in the service I received while attending my mother's 75th Bday at Tony's. So I specifically in the very beginning asked if she could get my calzone supreme started first because it would take longer than everybody else's meal to get ready. She said no problem. So everybody's meal hit the table except for mine so I waited for about 20 minutes and still no calzone. The table adjacent from us got their complete order in and he had a calzone all be it though not a supreme but a calzone nonetheless and he received his before. I even got mine and we were there almost 45 minutes to an hour before that group. We started off with our appetizers which were great. Everything up to that point was good, but when my dinner did not show up during my mother's birthday party I was rather dismayed. So after waiting a good 25 minutes I finally got up and asked the waitress of our table. What happened to my calzone and she apologized and said I forgot to ring it in. I don't see how that's possible being the fact that it was the first thing requested. I think Tony's has great food and this was probably not the first time this has happened but probably doesn't happen that much. When we inquired about getting some kind of discount off of the calzone that never showed until after my entire party was almost done eating, she only gave us 10% off which was honestly a slap in the face. Usually when this happens at restaurants it either gets comped completely 100% free or bare minimum 50% off. It is safe to say I will not be visiting Tony's nor will I be recommending Tony's to anyone I come across in my day to day travels. We did not want to seem like disgruntled customers so we paid our bill. Gave a decent $25 tip on $114 meal and we left with our to-go boxes and the completely uneaten calzone which had come completely last after everybody was done eating.
Side Note; Tony's Doesn't Serve any Beer or Wine.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Lori
This restaurant is not at this location anymore. They are Tony's Italian Restaurant and are at 117 S. Thompson St, which is diagonal to the old location. The old location is a Caribbean place now.
I got the lasagna pizza, and it was great. I got the small but needed a takeout box. My server was great as well. I will be back even though I live over 10 miles away.
Service was exceptional, kind and hospitable, but the food was so bland. We ordered garlic knots (hard/nearly flavorless), ravioli with chicken (there was no flavor/seasoning at all. The cheese inside the ravioli was powder. The chicken was not seasoned at all. So bland :( The chicken Alfredo was nearly the same, with Alfredo pasta and no seasoning/flavor. Very bland. And Alfredo is a favorite of all of ours, but we could hardly eat it, even after we added salt and sprinkle cheese to it. The Lasagna was also nearly flavorless. We were really excited to try several things from the menu, as the reviews had us looking forward to adding a new restaurant in our stops. Service was exceptional. Sweet waitresses working on staff. Food wasn't worth the drive or price.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Renada Walters
The gluten free pizza was amazing and so was everything else we ordered. Service was amazing!
B Miller
Okay pizza place, a little over priced though.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Andrée Brisson
Excellent food at an excellent price!!! Will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reid Mulholland
Awesome place highly recommend food is very good found this place about a month ago and been here easily 2-3 times a week. Only complaint is Tuesday evening it's much louder then normal with the in house entertainment.
Parking: Friendly service and great food. This has slowly become a favorite spot.
Ordered the Stromboli, hubby ordered the Steak 🥩 and cheese 🧀 sandwich. The Stromboli was really delicious 🤤 but the sandwich 🥪 just average. Needed more meat 🥩 and pepper 🫑 and onion 🧅.
The Stromboli is huge, enough for a double meal 🥘.
Place is super clean 🧼 and prices 💵💰just average. Wait person was real nice 👍
Parking: This is the new location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli
The Alfredo tasted like it had too much flour and not even parmesan. But the pizza is good and the servers were kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Cute little place in Starke
I like how it's set up
The food is delicious
But the portion size for the lasagna is really tiny for the price of $13 doesn't come with a salad or anything just a really tiny piece of bread.
And also should mention on your kids menu that the cheese quesadilla is made with mozzarella most people expect like a cheddar or American cheese are yellow cheese of some kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
We had pasta. Everything was right temp, appealing and tasty. Shrimp Frangelico and stuffed salmon. Yum!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salads
Great Food , Great Prices , Staff very friendly , Resturant very clean, I little parking problem ,Stop by and order some pizza you'll be glad you did !!! I hope this review helped have a great day !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered stuffed garlic knots, chicken parmesean. Everything was tasty but the knots were a bit doughy and the entree could have been a bit hotter. Our waitress was very friendly and the atmosphere was welcoming.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Garlic Knots, Chicken Parmesan
I ordered the Meat Lovers Calzone and the Grilled Chicken Wrap with a side salad and to go tea and mountain blast Powerade. Everything was fabulous and the ladies were amazing. I highly recommend. I always have a wonderful experience with them no matter when I go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Salad, Chicken Wrap
Changed locations and looks like changed owners. Double check menus photos.
Food: 3
Service: 4
I was very disappointed in the service I received while attending my mother's 75th Bday at Tony's.
So I specifically in the very beginning asked if she could get my calzone supreme started first because it would take longer than everybody else's meal to get ready. She said no problem. So everybody's meal hit the table except for mine so I waited for about 20 minutes and still no calzone. The table adjacent from us got their complete order in and he had a calzone all be it though not a supreme but a calzone nonetheless and he received his before. I even got mine and we were there almost 45 minutes to an hour before that group. We started off with our appetizers which were great. Everything up to that point was good, but when my dinner did not show up during my mother's birthday party I was rather dismayed. So after waiting a good 25 minutes I finally got up and asked the waitress of our table. What happened to my calzone and she apologized and said I forgot to ring it in. I don't see how that's possible being the fact that it was the first thing requested. I think Tony's has great food and this was probably not the first time this has happened but probably doesn't happen that much. When we inquired about getting some kind of discount off of the calzone that never showed until after my entire party was almost done eating, she only gave us 10% off which was honestly a slap in the face. Usually when this happens at restaurants it either gets comped completely 100% free or bare minimum 50% off. It is safe to say I will not be visiting Tony's nor will I be recommending Tony's to anyone I come across in my day to day travels. We did not want to seem like disgruntled customers so we paid our bill. Gave a decent $25 tip on $114 meal and we left with our to-go boxes and the completely uneaten calzone which had come completely last after everybody was done eating.
Side Note;
Tony's Doesn't Serve any Beer or Wine.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
This restaurant is not at this location anymore. They are Tony's Italian Restaurant and are at 117 S. Thompson St, which is diagonal to the old location. The old location is a Caribbean place now. I got the lasagna pizza, and it was great. I got the small but needed a takeout box. My server was great as well. I will be back even though I live over 10 miles away.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was exceptional, kind and hospitable, but the food was so bland. We ordered garlic knots (hard/nearly flavorless), ravioli with chicken (there was no flavor/seasoning at all. The cheese inside the ravioli was powder. The chicken was not seasoned at all. So bland :( The chicken Alfredo was nearly the same, with Alfredo pasta and no seasoning/flavor. Very bland. And Alfredo is a favorite of all of ours, but we could hardly eat it, even after we added salt and sprinkle cheese to it. The Lasagna was also nearly flavorless.
We were really excited to try several things from the menu, as the reviews had us looking forward to adding a new restaurant in our stops.
Service was exceptional. Sweet waitresses working on staff. Food wasn't worth the drive or price.
Food: 1
Service: 5
The gluten free pizza was amazing and so was everything else we ordered. Service was amazing!
Okay pizza place, a little over priced though.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Excellent food at an excellent price!!! Will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome place highly recommend food is very good found this place about a month ago and been here easily 2-3 times a week. Only complaint is Tuesday evening it's much louder then normal with the in house entertainment.
Parking: Friendly service and great food. This has slowly become a favorite spot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...