Always consistently good, but the Eggplant Joelle was exquisite 8/15/24 as was the Lasagne and Penne Broccoli Chicken. The Garlic Knots are always outstanding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ron Canty
Great food and great service
Jerry Anthony Casha
Always good… Great atmosphere friendly staff…. Wine selection 👌 ok
Doug B
I was disappointed in the entire experience. Prices were certainly no bargain. I asked what was on tap and the waiter recommended a German lager. It was good, so I got another. Then I got the bill ... $8 bucks each for a 12 oz beer. My wife had one beer. Kids had soft drinks. 2 of the earlybird specials, 1 "personal pizza," a side of pasta for the little one (they don't have a kids menu). We had a Calamari appetizer (very mediocre) and the total bill was over $100. Are you kidding me? Very disappointed with the cost for very average Italian food. The only bright spot was the waiter ... efficient, friendly.
karenwY9537UY
This place used to be great On our experience no one knew anything had to look up all menu items Staff not friendly, acted like they were ready to go home. Asked for certain dressing have gotten it a million times, didn’t know what it was. To bad maybe invest in new staff, more friendly More knowledgeable Won’t be back
243georgeg
We always enjoyed Carmella's for a glass of wine and slices (squares) of pizza. Maybe it's me, but it was average, not as flavorful as in the past. Leftover pizza slices can be dried out, etc., but for some reason they lacked flavor as in the past. Smaller also. But if you want a little atmosphere and slices with wine, why not!
TrailBlazer796796
Great food, great wine and beer selection and just good vibes. The broccolini sausage rigatoni is my go-to, so good and always have extra for leftover lunch.
Ariel0320
I ordered Chicken Parm and it tasted like it had been cooked the day before…this happened twice to me so I know it wasn’t a fluke experience. I understand that some meals are pre cooked and finished when ordered but this was so bad there was no effort to make it tasty.
jkneebfun
Nice little pizza place; good food and great service! We had pizza and garlic knots...both were very good...Caesar salad too!
Kim Annessi
MY FAV! I'm new to the area and have LOVED Carmela's for years! Picky about my Pizza and their Grandma's are the BEST! Wish I lived a bit closer as I live in Jensen Beach now but we used to drive from the Wellington area previously. Highly Recommend!
What in the world is non cash adjustment?Yes I was charged that and could get no one to explain what was this charged.Needless to say never going back.
Michelle Cappo
Great service from Wayne, great atmosphere, and excellent food! Wayne gives great recommendations especially on the famous tiramisu dessert.
Kay Clements
Food is great but when called ahead and tried to reserve high top for 6 told they didn't reserve it but when we arrived, it was empty but was reserved for someone. Very disappointed.
JCM
What is going on with the salt guys? are you guys salt happy? And the pizza was WAY over cooked. Honestly, we had to throw away the take out order. This place was semi-reliable.Forget it.Huge disappointment
Mandy Cass
Wayne is amazing and trivia on Wednesday’s is so much fun!!
Always consistently good, but the Eggplant Joelle was exquisite 8/15/24 as was the Lasagne and Penne Broccoli Chicken. The Garlic Knots are always outstanding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and great service
Always good… Great atmosphere friendly staff…. Wine selection 👌 ok
I was disappointed in the entire experience. Prices were certainly no bargain. I asked what was on tap and the waiter recommended a German lager. It was good, so I got another. Then I got the bill ... $8 bucks each for a 12 oz beer. My wife had one beer. Kids had soft drinks. 2 of the earlybird specials, 1 "personal pizza," a side of pasta for the little one (they don't have a kids menu). We had a Calamari appetizer (very mediocre) and the total bill was over $100. Are you kidding me? Very disappointed with the cost for very average Italian food. The only bright spot was the waiter ... efficient, friendly.
This place used to be great On our experience no one knew anything had to look up all menu items Staff not friendly, acted like they were ready to go home. Asked for certain dressing have gotten it a million times, didn’t know what it was. To bad maybe invest in new staff, more friendly More knowledgeable Won’t be back
We always enjoyed Carmella's for a glass of wine and slices (squares) of pizza. Maybe it's me, but it was average, not as flavorful as in the past. Leftover pizza slices can be dried out, etc., but for some reason they lacked flavor as in the past. Smaller also. But if you want a little atmosphere and slices with wine, why not!
Great food, great wine and beer selection and just good vibes. The broccolini sausage rigatoni is my go-to, so good and always have extra for leftover lunch.
I ordered Chicken Parm and it tasted like it had been cooked the day before…this happened twice to me so I know it wasn’t a fluke experience. I understand that some meals are pre cooked and finished when ordered but this was so bad there was no effort to make it tasty.
Nice little pizza place; good food and great service! We had pizza and garlic knots...both were very good...Caesar salad too!
MY FAV! I'm new to the area and have LOVED Carmela's for years! Picky about my Pizza and their Grandma's are the BEST! Wish I lived a bit closer as I live in Jensen Beach now but we used to drive from the Wellington area previously. Highly Recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
What in the world is non cash adjustment?Yes I was charged that and could get no one to explain what was this charged.Needless to say never going back.
Great service from Wayne, great atmosphere, and excellent food! Wayne gives great recommendations especially on the famous tiramisu dessert.
Food is great but when called ahead and tried to reserve high top for 6 told they didn't reserve it but when we arrived, it was empty but was reserved for someone. Very disappointed.
What is going on with the salt guys? are you guys salt happy? And the pizza was WAY over cooked. Honestly, we had to throw away the take out order. This place was semi-reliable.Forget it.Huge disappointment
Wayne is amazing and trivia on Wednesday’s is so much fun!!
Loading...