Fantini's 'New Haven Style' Apizza Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar

We had the mozzarella and the calamari they were both out of this world. The honey pizza was amazing. I got the chicken Parm and it was a good portion and very. Good. Very pleased with this restaurant.

Had a great Italian meal here. They give generous portions that also taste great. We like the ricotta board to start along with the short rib, pasta and clams with linguine. The pizza is also fantastic. Give it a try if you’re in the area!

Excellent service. Pizza was spot on.

The food was delicious!

Pricy pizza , but well worth it. Coming from Connecticut, the New Haven pizza scene...Jimmy has nailed it... Live music was great, great apps and salads...

Update (6/12/25): Went here last night. Pizza was spectacular and on point as usual, but most importantly, Jimmy changed the music up. There was live jazz which was a classy touch. When the band was over, a little Frank Sinatra piped through the system. Yes, Frank is a bit cliché for an Italian restaurant, but you know what? It fits the ambiance. So, I take back my commentary about the music being weird. Five stars!

- - - -

So I’ve been here twice. The first time was a dine in experience where we spent well over $130 for a pizza, salad and bottle of wine. If you want to elevate your pizza experience, this is the place to do it. Professional service, weird but elegant music, linen table cloths, romantic ambience…Jimmy did a beautiful job setting this place up. If you have the disposable cash, I highly recommend it.

Now, if you want to order take out, keep in mind you are paying for all of Jimmy’s fancy decor. So your take out order is going to be pricier than other pizza joints. Is the pizza good? Hands down, it is some excellent pizza. However, if you are going the take out route, I find it is just as good as Carmella’s in town and Carmella’s take out will probably run you $10 to $15 cheaper.

So, my recommendation is that if you want to check out Fantini’s, go for the dine in experience. It’s definitely going to be a memorable one. Just expect to pay for it. Also, I recommend getting a salad while you are there. I normally hate ordering salads at a restaurant but Jimmy does something special to his. They are out of this world.

Super good pizza. Best of the best!

I’m unable to rate it because we got there for lunch and the restaurant was closed. It doesn’t open till 3:00 on weekdays.

As a CT native, I have to say I enjoyed myself here VERY MUCH.

The Espresso Martini, Limoncello Mojito and Tiramisu were INCREDIBLE.

Fiancé LOVED the Meatball appetizer and would probably say everything was 💯…

Out of state pizza will never 100% match New Haven Apizza, but it’s 90% there and it absolutely hit the spot on date night on New Years Eve!

Compliments to the chef and owner! I really look forward to returning to Fantini’s during my next Florida visit ♥️

Dietary restrictions: They kindly modified the pizza for me due to an allergy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu

Unfortunately I had a bad experience. Pizza was burnt and I didn’t get the extra cheese I paid for, I talked to the owner over the phone he was rude and told not to come back. I drove back to show him the pizza the hostess told me that he was not interested in talking to me. I refused to take the pizza with me because the pizza and the service were not acceptable. this used to be my favorite pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

We had Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, and now New Years Eve dinner. The turkey was the most moist and tender we ever had. Christmas it was the sea bass. Outstanding. Tonight the surf and turf. A cut with a fork filet and the best lobster tail we ever had. Thank you Jimmy, Chief Shawn, servers Chris and Abbey and the entire staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

New concept v. Old cozy family style pizzaria. Expanded bar seating but if you want table for more than an hour better tell them at time of reservation or they tell you how long it's yours. Not ideal when being seated. A bit noisy. Extensive winelist a plus. Nice but pricey.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Vincenzo’S Chocolate Cake with an Airy Light Sponge, Bucatini Carbonara, La Nonna Pizza

The food was incredibly delicious and the atmosphere was comfortable. The restaurant was not loud even with music in and packed full of people. I had the braised short rib lasagna which was the best I ever had. My husband had spaghetti and meatballs. We shared a burrata and tomato salad. Everything was so good. This is the best restaurant in Stuart.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baratta Salad

Decent food and service. Apparently, New Haven pizza is supposed to be burnt on the bottom, so we learned something. Probably wont be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 4

Excellent Itialian Food. The very best pizza in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5