As new resident of Stuart my wife and I like to check out new places. We came across Nostalgia and decided to have a drink at the bar. Well we got to meet the best bartender in all of Stuart lucky us!! She recommended the drinks and some food items on the happy hr menu. Just Wow!! Everything she recommended was spot on!! Jenn the bartender could not have been better and always had a smile on her face even when she was busy being a Friday night. She made our evening that much more enjoyable by being so attentiveto us! Nostalgia you now have 2 new regular customers because of Jenn!!
Recommended dishes: Spanakopita
Travis Scott
Me and my son decided to eat out here about 3 nights ago and firstly the food is here is to die for and it is a very beautiful establishment and very clean yet i have one issue that needs to be dealt with. I specifically asked my server to have my drink in a wine glass and she kindly obliged and after a little bit of waiting another server came out with my drink in the wrong glass and was being totally rude and unprofessional then shortly after our server returned apologizing for the matter and stating that she didn’t mean for that to happen and even seemed to have a tear in her eye. later that night i found out that the lady that brought out my drink was picking on other staff members and being rude to customers and this beautiful restaurant doesn’t need those type of people working there and me and my son love dining here and plan on coming back as soon as this is dealt with.
Ron Dawes
Great food and wait staff. You won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M. LeCount
I’m visiting, and had dinner here… it was phenomenal! Jenn helped out us out and she was so incredibly patient with us and helpful and really made the whole experience incredible. I absolutely recommend dining here. Thank you so much Jenn!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DANIEL MURPHY
This place has really gone downhill in the past year. This used to be one of our favorite restaurants and recommended it many times to friends. Unfortunately the new ownership has had a negative effect on the food quality and the service. We gave it three additional shots to try to change our mind, but we will not be going back anytime soon. It's a shame as we need good restaurants in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Robert Kaye
The problem with Kyle G's policy of adding the gratuity to the bill, is that you are rewarding incompetence and poor service. The waitress that we had last night was the worst! We never received our appetizer, she got my friends order completely wrong, she filleted my fish and completely mutilated it, and they were never going to bring my side until I brought it up. The service was beyond poor and I never would have tipped her, even though I usually leave over 20%. Unfortunately, we have been to all of Kyle G's restaurants and have had more poor experiences, than good ones.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Diana C
We’ve been to nostalgia several times we are Greek so we usually like to order Greek food today we were going to order the pastitsio which is a main dish but it wasn’t done yet so we had to order something different. I got Broccoli rabe With chunks of sausage, but it came with ground sausage instead, we did order the fried zucchini with the skordalia which was good But the potatoes definitely need some more garlic in them, The pasta Fagioli was good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Little Skittles
Popular restaurant, so don't be surprised if you have to wait for a table. Food is delicious with a nice variety of menu items. I did find the restaurant loud/noisy, so it was difficult to have a conversation over dinner. Parking could be a challenge, as they share parking with other popular restaurants and bowling alley in the same plaza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Dolores Fanich
Very expensive as you would expect from Kyle G. I am a martini drinker at 5-star restaurants instead of making you spill half of your drink, they serve you the remainder of the shaker in a side glass. Just a suggestion.. Oh, they forgot my grandson's birthday cake also...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ann Brant
The staff are wonderfulFood ? delicious I personally found the garlic bread too strong for me but not my dinner friendsStaff brought me some plain
Made a reservation for indoors. They wanted to give us an outside patio table. There was an event in the parking lot with a band and music. NO ONE WAS SITTONG OUTSIDE. Ultimately, they put us in the bar. The service in the bar area is inconsistent. Also, food is often not hot. Not the best experience.
HelenC
Noisy & crowded for an in season Friday night but thats what to be expected when the food is so good! Had to wait for our reserved table but Diane the amazing bartender keep our glasses filled with happy hour libations. When we finally got to our table Edwardo was on the spot to make things perfect. Their menus boasted of Greek Italian selections, so much to try! We dove right in and enjoyed, fresh raw-bar, Spanakopitakia, Lamb Paidakia (perfectly prepared lamb chops) , salmon over Angel hair, assorted kabobs and Veal Saltimbocca Florentine. Everyone in our 4 top shared our generous portions fir a sumptuous taste test. A sweet shared dessert of Karidopita and 4 double expressos completed our fine dining experience.
JoelG
The restaurant was moderately crowded but we put in a small room away from the action of the restaurant which was disappointing. The food was either too garlicky or not spiced enough -also disappointing. The service was adequate but not what we expect in a Kyle G restaurant.
The service and food was great! Too bad everyone around us were dressed like slobs - such a shame. We expected it to be a nicer atmosphere and really turned out to be a T-shirt and jorts kinda place.
PaulG
The service was mediocre slow and non-attentive. We ordered veal saltambuca with angel hair pasta with the pasta arriving 5 minutes after the veal. I had to on many occasions I had to search for someone to refill my water glass. The room was noisy and not particularly appealing. We will not return.
As new resident of Stuart my wife and I like to check out new places. We came across Nostalgia and decided to have a drink at the bar. Well we got to meet the best bartender in all of Stuart lucky us!! She recommended the drinks and some food items on the happy hr menu. Just Wow!! Everything she recommended was spot on!! Jenn the bartender could not have been better and always had a smile on her face even when she was busy being a Friday night. She made our evening that much more enjoyable by being so attentiveto us! Nostalgia you now have 2 new regular customers because of Jenn!!
Recommended dishes: Spanakopita
Me and my son decided to eat out here about 3 nights ago and firstly the food is here is to die for and it is a very beautiful establishment and very clean yet i have one issue that needs to be dealt with. I specifically asked my server to have my drink in a wine glass and she kindly obliged and after a little bit of waiting another server came out with my drink in the wrong glass and was being totally rude and unprofessional then shortly after our server returned apologizing for the matter and stating that she didn’t mean for that to happen and even seemed to have a tear in her eye. later that night i found out that the lady that brought out my drink was picking on other staff members and being rude to customers and this beautiful restaurant doesn’t need those type of people working there and me and my son love dining here and plan on coming back as soon as this is dealt with.
Great food and wait staff. You won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m visiting, and had dinner here… it was phenomenal! Jenn helped out us out and she was so incredibly patient with us and helpful and really made the whole experience incredible. I absolutely recommend dining here. Thank you so much Jenn!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has really gone downhill in the past year. This used to be one of our favorite restaurants and recommended it many times to friends. Unfortunately the new ownership has had a negative effect on the food quality and the service. We gave it three additional shots to try to change our mind, but we will not be going back anytime soon. It's a shame as we need good restaurants in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
The problem with Kyle G's policy of adding the gratuity to the bill, is that you are rewarding incompetence and poor service. The waitress that we had last night was the worst! We never received our appetizer, she got my friends order completely wrong, she filleted my fish and completely mutilated it, and they were never going to bring my side until I brought it up. The service was beyond poor and I never would have tipped her, even though I usually leave over 20%. Unfortunately, we have been to all of Kyle G's restaurants and have had more poor experiences, than good ones.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
We’ve been to nostalgia several times we are Greek so we usually like to order Greek food today we were going to order the pastitsio which is a main dish but it wasn’t done yet so we had to order something different. I got Broccoli rabe With chunks of sausage, but it came with ground sausage instead, we did order the fried zucchini with the skordalia which was good But the potatoes definitely need some more garlic in them, The pasta Fagioli was good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Popular restaurant, so don't be surprised if you have to wait for a table. Food is delicious with a nice variety of menu items. I did find the restaurant loud/noisy, so it was difficult to have a conversation over dinner. Parking could be a challenge, as they share parking with other popular restaurants and bowling alley in the same plaza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Very expensive as you would expect from Kyle G. I am a martini drinker at 5-star restaurants instead of making you spill half of your drink, they serve you the remainder of the shaker in a side glass. Just a suggestion.. Oh, they forgot my grandson's birthday cake also...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The staff are wonderfulFood ? delicious I personally found the garlic bread too strong for me but not my dinner friendsStaff brought me some plain
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Made a reservation for indoors. They wanted to give us an outside patio table. There was an event in the parking lot with a band and music. NO ONE WAS SITTONG OUTSIDE. Ultimately, they put us in the bar. The service in the bar area is inconsistent. Also, food is often not hot. Not the best experience.
Noisy & crowded for an in season Friday night but thats what to be expected when the food is so good! Had to wait for our reserved table but Diane the amazing bartender keep our glasses filled with happy hour libations. When we finally got to our table Edwardo was on the spot to make things perfect. Their menus boasted of Greek Italian selections, so much to try! We dove right in and enjoyed, fresh raw-bar, Spanakopitakia, Lamb Paidakia (perfectly prepared lamb chops) , salmon over Angel hair, assorted kabobs and Veal Saltimbocca Florentine. Everyone in our 4 top shared our generous portions fir a sumptuous taste test. A sweet shared dessert of Karidopita and 4 double expressos completed our fine dining experience.
The restaurant was moderately crowded but we put in a small room away from the action of the restaurant which was disappointing. The food was either too garlicky or not spiced enough -also disappointing. The service was adequate but not what we expect in a Kyle G restaurant.
The service and food was great! Too bad everyone around us were dressed like slobs - such a shame. We expected it to be a nicer atmosphere and really turned out to be a T-shirt and jorts kinda place.
The service was mediocre slow and non-attentive. We ordered veal saltambuca with angel hair pasta with the pasta arriving 5 minutes after the veal. I had to on many occasions I had to search for someone to refill my water glass. The room was noisy and not particularly appealing. We will not return.