A Slice of Paradise

24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key
(305) 744-9718

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ms. E

The first time we got a pizza, it was undercooked. But it was really good. So when I went back, I simply asked them to make it "well done" and I got a pizza cooked to perfection.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything Pizza

Mason Kolling

The service was slow but it was also spring break(on March 8th) so that might have done something. The pizza was good but the next day I was so sick and was throwing it all up. I got the sausage pepperoni, would not recommend if weak stomach, mine hurt almost instantly after eating it. Will not try pizza ever again not.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Shane Mellin

Just received our food after waiting over an hour and half - the pizza is cold. not a little cold but cold. very disappointing.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Tammy Brown

Just ordered a large pizza a garden salad, boneless wings and garlic nots. $80 of the worst food I’ve ever eaten. Pizza was soggy. The garden salad consist of Romain lettuce a hint of spinach most of it was yellow a bad tomato soft croutons and 2 pieces of onion. The boneless wings were just horrible, burnt and tasted like they had been cooked hours ago. Garlic nots dry and no garlic taste and the marinara was gross as well! Again $80 and didn’t even eat it! Never again. 🤢🤢 scale of 1-5…..0

Shanon Girod

I used the slice app to order 2 burgers and fries. It took 2hours to get our food. It was cold but to add insult to injury I bit into my burger half way through and found a hair. I could remove the bu with the hair 🤦‍♀️

Food: 1

Julia Spangler

I placed an order for delivery and was told the wait was going to be around an hour, an hour passed, and still no food after almost an hour and a half I called and they said that the delivery person was leaving with my food now, about 30 minutes passed and I finally got my food. This place is about 10 minutes from where I live i only ordered a salad, fries, and cinnamon knots and it took about 2 hours to get my food cold and soggy. I Will not eat here again nor will I recommend it.

Becky MacFarland

Absolutely disgusting. Cold pizza and my chicken was burnt. Don’t waste your time

Travis W

Little over cooked but had good flavor.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Cheese Pizza

kal nightengale

So I literally ordered a hawiian pizza and asked for garlic and jalapeños to be added to it and all the did was send me a regular hawiian pizza with none of the stuff I wanted them to add and worse part is that they had me wait an hour for an unfinished pizza! I’m livid and all they could say was that they were sorry like how is your apology going to fix my freaking order! They clearly don’t pay attention to details!

Food: 1

Q4067UVmaxm

Delicious pizza, desserts, and sandwiches. My experience was wonderful. Very family friendly and wonderful atmosphere.

bruce baxter

Great pizza for Florida, sorry, Im from Jersey. This is the spot for local pizza when Im in the neighborhood. Right on rt 1. Quick service. friendly people

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Everything Pizza

Frankie Corbelli

I don’t normally do this but every single time I order food from you guys, I get food poisoning the next day. I love the staff and atmosphere. Everything is normally great but the food..Just not sure what’s been going on. Not cooked long enough maybe? Please just take this into consideration and possibly speak to the cook. I understand you guys get really busy but health is very important and don’t want y’all to get sued. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Rich

Worst Buffalo wings ever, they had no sauce, and still pink in the middle. Pizza very bland reminded me of a school lunch pizza. Ended up throwing it all out. Not edible

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

D C

Ordered pizza and they never came then we saw they closed. Like tell us no. What a waste of time.

Travis Ragsdale

Good pizza

Loading...