I don’t know why I keep giving this place a chance. Tonight we picked up a pizza, a salad, and 6 hot buffalo wings. Our total was $70! The wings were barely edible and naked! The pizza was okay but super expensive. The Enrico’s salad was a very small portion size and the red wine vinaigrette was just red wine vinegar. The pickup service was so awkward. I asked multiple times (on the phone and at the counter) for an extra side of ranch. The young man at the cash register could not comprehend what I was asking. After consuming the food we instantly had stomach pain and multiple trips to the bathroom. Overall, not worth the money!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dallas Knighton
Fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily B
We were hesitant to eat here due to some of the reviews, but I am so glad we decided to stop in. Bonus points for having a cauliflower crust option! 🙂 Great service, great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yosvany Garcia Ruiz
Used to be a nice place to visit, sit down with family and enjoy the food. However, the drunken locals are habitually coming in, enjoying the liquor and slouching back on their chairs while smothering the women visitors coming in through the door of this restaurant. This is very uncomfortable and rude. As if they’re hawking a victim and stripping the women naked with their eyes (lusting). Not worth the visit if you ask me. I don’t recommend this Pizzeria to anyone with kids or mature daughters. Tourists and visitors beware of these older locals going into this pizzeria just to order beer, lay back watching the women and kids going about. The owner should be made aware of this and have stricter rules. Customers don’t appreciate someone sitting next to them lusting your wife, daughters and kids!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 2
Kalanai Jandrin
DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! We placed an order online through THEIR website, got confirmation to our email and they charged our card. Said delivery was going to take 1 hour, we called about 1.15 to see if food was close. The first guy said oh our online system doesn’t work, we say there was no note on their website and THEY sent us a confirmation he says oh it’s something with our management, he says he will remake it for us and I ask for a free pizza he says ok let me ask my manager, then just proceeds to hang up. We call back again a RUDE woman answers and immediately says call back???!! Then she just hangs up on us!? We call back again and get the same lady and she says again you can call back later and hangs up again! We call back multiple times and we say we need a refund because you charged us and now haven’t even made our pizza and will not make our pizza because the place closes in 15. Then again after multiple calls we try to confirm a refund because this is now fraud and the rude lady says you might get it tomorrow? Please do not order online please do not even try to call and please do not give this place your money because they will take it and not give you anything you paid for and will be of no help! NO NO NO
Service was great, food was hot and fresh. We got there a little late at 8:40pm but were not rushed. The truffle fries were amazing! This place does not disappoint!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Omar Baaj
Honestly might’ve been the best bite I’ve ever grabbed on the road, the service was impeccable! Thank you for making my day :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gustavo Torres (Dirtycrack)
Great food, a little pricey but its in the Keys so I was expecting it, was atleast worth the price tho
So much flavor best pizza I’ve tasted my whole life , the workers are very kind and they make me feel like it’s worth being there . The music and everything just gives the best experience. Overall 10/10 it’s worth eating here !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gualberto jr garza
Enrico's pizza was pretty good, better than I thought it would be for it being in the keys. The pizza was cooked well done as asked for. The pizza was cheesy, and there were plenty of ingredients on the pizza just like we asked for. The crust on it was delicious and crunchy and very addictive. We also ordered enricos salad, and it too was delicious, very well served, and hearty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
john rawson
Order was for a hot Steak & cheese sub w/ caramelized onions. It was more like a raw onion sub w/ small chunks of overcooked beef. Menu said thinly sliced beef with caramelized onions. Bread was hard and stale. The salad we ordered was okay though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Sam Knepper
Great New York style pizza in the Florida keys. Ordered take out and order was ready when promised. Garlic rolls were amaaaaaaazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abigail Anne
Whoever’s answering the phones on Friday night has no idea what they’re doing, pizza is good gets the job done
I don’t know why I keep giving this place a chance. Tonight we picked up a pizza, a salad, and 6 hot buffalo wings. Our total was $70! The wings were barely edible and naked! The pizza was okay but super expensive. The Enrico’s salad was a very small portion size and the red wine vinaigrette was just red wine vinegar. The pickup service was so awkward. I asked multiple times (on the phone and at the counter) for an extra side of ranch. The young man at the cash register could not comprehend what I was asking. After consuming the food we instantly had stomach pain and multiple trips to the bathroom. Overall, not worth the money!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were hesitant to eat here due to some of the reviews, but I am so glad we decided to stop in. Bonus points for having a cauliflower crust option! 🙂 Great service, great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Used to be a nice place to visit, sit down with family and enjoy the food. However, the drunken locals are habitually coming in, enjoying the liquor and slouching back on their chairs while smothering the women visitors coming in through the door of this restaurant. This is very uncomfortable and rude. As if they’re hawking a victim and stripping the women naked with their eyes (lusting). Not worth the visit if you ask me. I don’t recommend this Pizzeria to anyone with kids or mature daughters. Tourists and visitors beware of these older locals going into this pizzeria just to order beer, lay back watching the women and kids going about.
The owner should be made aware of this and have stricter rules. Customers don’t appreciate someone sitting next to them lusting your wife, daughters and kids!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 2
DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! We placed an order online through THEIR website, got confirmation to our email and they charged our card. Said delivery was going to take 1 hour, we called about 1.15 to see if food was close. The first guy said oh our online system doesn’t work, we say there was no note on their website and THEY sent us a confirmation he says oh it’s something with our management, he says he will remake it for us and I ask for a free pizza he says ok let me ask my manager, then just proceeds to hang up. We call back again a RUDE woman answers and immediately says call back???!! Then she just hangs up on us!? We call back again and get the same lady and she says again you can call back later and hangs up again! We call back multiple times and we say we need a refund because you charged us and now haven’t even made our pizza and will not make our pizza because the place closes in 15. Then again after multiple calls we try to confirm a refund because this is now fraud and the rude lady says you might get it tomorrow? Please do not order online please do not even try to call and please do not give this place your money because they will take it and not give you anything you paid for and will be of no help! NO NO NO
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pretty good food, but great staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, 10 Kids Cheese Pizza
Service was great, food was hot and fresh. We got there a little late at 8:40pm but were not rushed. The truffle fries were amazing! This place does not disappoint!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Honestly might’ve been the best bite I’ve ever grabbed on the road, the service was impeccable! Thank you for making my day :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, a little pricey but its in the Keys so I was expecting it, was atleast worth the price tho
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
So much flavor best pizza I’ve tasted my whole life , the workers are very kind and they make me feel like it’s worth being there . The music and everything just gives the best experience. Overall 10/10 it’s worth eating here !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Enrico's pizza was pretty good, better than I thought it would be for it being in the keys. The pizza was cooked well done as asked for. The pizza was cheesy, and there were plenty of ingredients on the pizza just like we asked for. The crust on it was delicious and crunchy and very addictive. We also ordered enricos salad, and it too was delicious, very well served, and hearty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Order was for a hot Steak & cheese sub w/ caramelized onions. It was more like a raw onion sub w/ small chunks of overcooked beef. Menu said thinly sliced beef with caramelized onions. Bread was hard and stale. The salad we ordered was okay though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great New York style pizza in the Florida keys. Ordered take out and order was ready when promised. Garlic rolls were amaaaaaaazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Whoever’s answering the phones on Friday night has no idea what they’re doing, pizza is good gets the job done
Loading...