Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge

Holy cow you will forget where you are and how sunburnt you are and be transported into some sort of food coma in the Greek islands. Get the garlic bread and shrimp marinara

The prime rib was amazing! The views are stunning. Our waitress was great!

Shasta was an unbelievable server! She went above and beyond to make sure our friend with Celiac was taken care. Her kindness and upbeat demeanor was infectious!! I highly recommend this place! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.
Awesome happy hour unitil 7pm

Caters to drunks and the bar. If you want 2 get drunk at an expensive place with few people go ahead. I live right beside it. Never going there again dude! Lol

Food was excellent, best prime rib I’ve had. Filet mignon was also amazing. But most importantly Michelle was an absolute gem and made our experience so much better. She provided impeccable service.

Good drinks, good pizza, escargot sucks

Best Expresso Martinis in town !

We were staying with some friends in Tavernier for the weekend and after a long day in the sun, our naptime extended a little later than expected! Was searching the Google for pizza nearby for a quick dinner and found this charming place just minutes away. Called and placed an order for pick up and was ready within 20 minutes. The pizza was absolutely delicious, but what i was most impressed with was the attentiveness and friendliness of the staff! Was waiting all of 3 minutes to cash out and pick up the items ordered and was approached by 4 different staff members to check on me and make sure i was being helped. They definitely have customer service down! Looking forward to visiting our friends again soon and being able to dine in next time.

Caesar salad was good, a little plain however. Food lacked presentation but made up for it in taste. We got the Chicken and Shrimp Al Mare ($28) and the shrimp scampi ($28) and two drinks ($6). The dishes were quite delicious! It has a nice older and dim atmosphere and good variation of items on their menu 🕯️

Specials, steaks, salads are very good. Tonight was the exception— very busy, service was very slow and food was barely warm. Had shrimp/scallop special and was lukewarm at best. Shrimp was dried and tough. Like itd been under a warming lamp too warm

Lovely Valentines dinner on patio. Even without a reservation they were super sweet. Add this place to your stops. Totally worth it💗

We eat here every year when visiting the keys. Had the worst experience ever. Tables seated after us were waited on before us. Took over an hour to get our food, my husband ordered a filet medium and it came out so well done he could not cute it with a steak knife. Our server and the manager were very flippant when we brought it to their attention. Not sure if we will patronize again.

Had dinner at The Old Tavernier recently, and it wasn’t great. Our server, Bree, however, was friendly and personable, but the food was meh at best.
My spouse (DF/GF) had grilled shrimp on GF pasta. She wasn’t sick after the meal which is always a positive when dining out, but the shrimp was waaay overcooked.
I had a Caesar salad, which was OK, and calamari, which was gross! The breading was like sandpaper grit - very dry and gritty, and so clumped on the tentacles that they were balls of grit instead of tender goodness.
Considering some positive reviews and their own hype on their web page, it was a very underwhelming and overpriced meal.
Almost forgot - I had their Old Fashioned, and it was an insult to the name; it was sweetened and had a crushed maraschino cherry (the fruitcake variety) - yuck!

Food and. Service are phenomenal. We had a great experience

Been going here for almost 20 years.....everything is delicious and prepared to perfection. Our consistently #1!