Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

10730 State Rd 54, Trinity
(727) 376-1000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andi Ocean

Amazing cheese pizza, super fast, clean, cool vibes!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kyle

I'm hooked. My favorite place for the last 3 years
Pizza done right nt style.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

mark jones

This location is clean, and the staff us prompt and courteous. Food quality is consistently excellent. Always a great place to dine in or take out. Highly recommend.

Jay Lightning

The people here are phenomenal, the atmosphere is great, the service is quick and they are attentive to their customers. The pizza is good normally, and some days they get that crisp just right and its the best pizza you've ever had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

ds Ky

Really bad experience
First we ordered Buffalo chicken pizza very sagging too much sauce not baked enough even the guy who was serving us notice that
Second we ordered steak and cheese calzon with green pepper and onion and mozzarella cheese was special order and asked to make sure is mozzarella not ricotta cheese
Calzon came and yes absolutely it was ricotta cheese the guy was chocked he was like I told them make sure is mozzarella so he toke the calzon and have them remade it the new one was OK but sagging like the pizza
Told him make sure the owner knows about this he said he will till the owner
Btw it wasn't busy at the time was only us and one other table

Food: 1

Kris Rambo

Just love the friendly staff, the cleanliness and all food has always been great! They give a discount for Military!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Lindenschmidt

I love this place mine and my husband's first time and it's very clean quiet. And the service is amazing didn't have to wait at all

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

lauren bonner

Came with my son and got some pizza by the slice and it was the best pizza I have ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian McDonald

Puzza could be good but it's not. Really nice people working there and nice atmosphere but floppy crust and sauce is bland.

Veronica Rios

I have to say that everytime it doesn’t matter the day after I just want to est a nice pizza I think about this place, near home but everytime that I ordered for picked up or try to dinning 1 hour before they close I got a really bad attitude I do understand everybody is tired but I’m paying for a good pizza today the sauce was sour and pretty lightily. I’m thinking just to changed the location I’m tired of this

James Groom

Great pizza friendly service

Antony Francis

Great food if you go there, but don't order from their app or online, the order is more likely to get messes up than be right. Great food though. A Year later and majority of my delivery orders still get screwed up, now I'm bein g told the grub hub folks screw up when relaying my order. -1 more star Great food if/when they get it right. And another delivery tried and messed up 5/2025.

Fran

Nice atmosphere, large portions, friendly staff.

Jeannette Agramonte

Love the place. Nice customer services. Food was fantastic and better than good. BeardMeatsFood was right Good food.

Johnny Beardsley

One slice challenge
5.9
I hate leaving a bad review but I leave honest reviews because I take the side of the consumer. With that being said let’s get into it
This is very heavy pizza for being New York style. I will start off by saying the sauce was very good very zesty And flavorful But it was applied very thinly. I could not taste it only when getting close to the crust where It was thicker. The cheese was very heavily applied that overwhelmed the pizza and very bland. The crust was also very bland. once in a while, I could actually taste the sauce. Besides My score of the pizza, the restaurant is phenomenally Set up, a great atmosphere and a New York environment.
As far as the service it was very fast and the people working in there are very friendly. With all this in considering they are not the best in the area and certainly not the worst. They need to really set themselves apart from their competitors. There are local pizza places in the area that do not have the fancy restaurant and they create10x better pizza. But I always leave reviews on every pie shop I come across. My return to this location is highly unlikely.

Loading...

Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

10730 State Rd 54, Trinity, FL 34655
(727) 376-1000