Great pizza definitely are go to Great service too
Michelle Colasuonno
This is the best pie I've had in FL in 20 yrs of living in Tampa and being from NJ. I'm not kidding and I've lived in s Tampa , Seminole heights and now new Tampa. Who would think I'd find the best and closest to real pizza here ? Not me but Amen! š!
Lew-Anne Gordon
I have been a happy customer of yours as long as I lived in Wesley chapel. I have since moved and suggested a friend of mine from my new neighborhood go and get your delicious pizza this past Sunday. I was very disappointed with her review! She told me the pizza was like cardboard and not able to be eaten. She even offered it to her friends in case it was her, but they couldnāt eat it either and it was thrown away. Iāve had your pizza many times whenever I visited Wesley Chapel and it seemed fine. Did you have a different person cooking on Sunday?
Ruth Clarke
Great food and plenty of it.
James Moten
Always great
D Osborne
My family had a wonderful time dining at your establishment yesterday Saturday around 6pm. From the moment that we walked in, the owner/manager greeted my family and me including the children. The waitress was prompt, polite, and very patient serving my mother and father in-law, my wife and I and our four children whose ages are all under 9 years old. I rarely believe in eating out, but my father in-law insisted on us coming here based on his past experience eating here.
We ordered a medium size Veggie pizza, a medium size Meat Lover pizza, a medium size Cheese pizza, and mozzarella sticks. Everything tasted great. The children ate all of their food without any objections... I will definitely return to your establishment the next time I am visiting the New Tampa/Wesley Chapel area. Thank you again for the great service and food. Happy Mother's Day to all impactful wonderful women in your life. May 11, 2025.
Tatiana Nicoli
A typical New York style old-school pizzeria with Giovanni at the helm! The pizza and food are the best Italian in the area. NY born and raised, I can account for the pizza authenticity. It's better to sit in then get delivery so go say hi and enjoy!
Cristina Cruz
This place is above and beyond with the food and the service. Gianna was truly attentive about everything and I would love to go here again!
Hanna VanBuren
First time coming in, est pizza place in town! Iāll come here from now on and Iām driving from Zephyrhills
Adam Anderson
In my opinion the best pizza in Wesley Chapel hands down. Wasn't a huge fan of their wings but I don't normally get those and pizza is my main concern
Pizza mania has the most authentic tasting food and amazing service. Everyone has a smile on their face and so much amazing energy contributing to an amazing experience. My waitress was blonde and had beautiful blue eyes she made sure everything came out fast as well as give excellent service. Will be back soon!!
Alyssa Carmona
I called the store at 3:30 pm to place an order for pick up by 4:10/15. There was a miscommunication and for some reason my food was set to be picked up at 4:40š³ The 2 girls at the front wouldnāt really take accountability for making the mistake on my ticket. Ernesto stepped in and apologized for the mistake, said they would make my food ASAP, and offered me a free slice and drink while i waited. He was very kind and attentive to a customers needs. He made what I thought would be a negative experience into a positive. Iāve been coming to pizza mania since i was a little kid at the older, smaller location next door. Now being 25 with my own family, I was happy when I received the same family friendly service that I know the company for.
Wrestle Reaction
The best pizza place in Wesley Chapel! The white pizza is some of the best weāve had anywhere. Delicious regular cheese and pepperoni pizza. Great calzones and garlic knots! Most importantly: CONSISTENT! Itās our weekly stop for months and nails the NY/NJ flavor.
Susana Ostolaza
The pizza is delicious and the owner and staff are really nice and friendly
Kymberly Boswell - Realtor
Pizza Mania never disappoints! Their food is always delicious, and the service is top-notch. The pizza is hands down the best, and the Chicken Francese is absolutely amazing!! On top of that, they truly care about the community, proudly supporting the Wesley Chapel High School baseball team. Canāt say enough great things about this place!
Great pizza definitely are go to Great service too
This is the best pie I've had in FL in 20 yrs of living in Tampa and being from NJ. I'm not kidding and I've lived in s Tampa , Seminole heights and now new Tampa. Who would think I'd find the best and closest to real pizza here ? Not me but Amen! š!
I have been a happy customer of yours as long as I lived in Wesley chapel. I have since moved and suggested a friend of mine from my new neighborhood go and get your delicious pizza this past Sunday. I was very disappointed with her review! She told me the pizza was like cardboard and not able to be eaten. She even offered it to her friends in case it was her, but they couldnāt eat it either and it was thrown away. Iāve had your pizza many times whenever I visited Wesley Chapel and it seemed fine. Did you have a different person cooking on Sunday?
Great food and plenty of it.
Always great
My family had a wonderful time dining at your establishment yesterday Saturday around 6pm. From the moment that we walked in, the owner/manager greeted my family and me including the children. The waitress was prompt, polite, and very patient serving my mother and father in-law, my wife and I and our four children whose ages are all under 9 years old. I rarely believe in eating out, but my father in-law insisted on us coming here based on his past experience eating here.
We ordered a medium size Veggie pizza, a medium size Meat Lover pizza, a medium size Cheese pizza, and mozzarella sticks. Everything tasted great. The children ate all of their food without any objections... I will definitely return to your establishment the next time I am visiting the New Tampa/Wesley Chapel area.
Thank you again for the great service and food. Happy Mother's Day to all impactful wonderful women in your life. May 11, 2025.
A typical New York style old-school pizzeria with Giovanni at the helm! The pizza and food are the best Italian in the area. NY born and raised, I can account for the pizza authenticity. It's better to sit in then get delivery so go say hi and enjoy!
This place is above and beyond with the food and the service. Gianna was truly attentive about everything and I would love to go here again!
First time coming in, est pizza place in town! Iāll come here from now on and Iām driving from Zephyrhills
In my opinion the best pizza in Wesley Chapel hands down. Wasn't a huge fan of their wings but I don't normally get those and pizza is my main concern
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza mania has the most authentic tasting food and amazing service. Everyone has a smile on their face and so much amazing energy contributing to an amazing experience. My waitress was blonde and had beautiful blue eyes she made sure everything came out fast as well as give excellent service. Will be back soon!!
I called the store at 3:30 pm to place an order for pick up by 4:10/15. There was a miscommunication and for some reason my food was set to be picked up at 4:40š³ The 2 girls at the front wouldnāt really take accountability for making the mistake on my ticket. Ernesto stepped in and apologized for the mistake, said they would make my food ASAP, and offered me a free slice and drink while i waited. He was very kind and attentive to a customers needs. He made what I thought would be a negative experience into a positive. Iāve been coming to pizza mania since i was a little kid at the older, smaller location next door. Now being 25 with my own family, I was happy when I received the same family friendly service that I know the company for.
The best pizza place in Wesley Chapel! The white pizza is some of the best weāve had anywhere. Delicious regular cheese and pepperoni pizza. Great calzones and garlic knots! Most importantly: CONSISTENT! Itās our weekly stop for months and nails the NY/NJ flavor.
The pizza is delicious and the owner and staff are really nice and friendly
Pizza Mania never disappoints! Their food is always delicious, and the service is top-notch. The pizza is hands down the best, and the Chicken Francese is absolutely amazing!! On top of that, they truly care about the community, proudly supporting the Wesley Chapel High School baseball team. Canāt say enough great things about this place!
Loading...