Worse pizza I ever had. Just ordered 2 pizzas and it came out like warm. They placed it into the oven for 5 secs. I asked for crushed pepper, cheese, or pepper and they said they don’t have it. And on the busiest night of the year, Halloween. Both bathrooms were out of service. This place doesn’t know customer service. It will probably go out of business quickly or suffer a slow death. Won’t recommend to anyone!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Chabelly Cespedes
Definitely a NYC pizza!! Amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Henderson
I've known Nick and his dad for many many years the food is awesome the atmosphere is awesome makes you just want to come back again and again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Graciano DeVivo
They charge way too much for pizza.
Theodore Grivoldi
Overpriced, cashier seems to rip you off, I will not be going back. Sad I used to like it.😞
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Erik Shaffer
Do not go here they charged us $52.99 for a large pepperoni pizza on pride. It was not hot just like warm. They price gauge and we should not support a place that takes advantage of our community
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Andres Donoso
No cheese on any slices that were not a cheese slice.
Pepperoni slice was crust, sauce, pepperoni.
Asked the guy (Nick) why there isn't any cheese he said it's on the bottom. I asked him to explain (because you can see crust sauce pepperoni with absolutely no cheese) and he just said, you don't have to buy it leave.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Michael Regalbuto
Overpriced and overrated ! $6 for a skinny slice of cheese? Seriously?!?!?
We need better options than expensive pizza that take advantage of the neighborhood’s patrons.
Marco Kyris
the worst greasy pizza ever. $6. a slice for sleaze slice. and arrogance from the kunt saying covid inflated the price. Cash kunt grab and capitalizing on the gay crowd. Never again. Waste of $$ of time. nyc is cheaper.!
Mike H
They charged me $17 for a Stromboli. The menu says $6.25. You’ll get taken advantage of, that’s how I felt. Super cold pizza too. Bad experience unfortunately. :(
The pizza was great! Service was great! And the atmosphere was excellent. I enjoyed great food and great conversations. Try a slice of cake
Brendon
What kind of pizza place doesn’t let you order a large pizza at 5pm? Even the busiest places in Boston, New York, or anywhere else I’ve been can do this, but Nick’s is only by the slice. That would be fine if the per slice price was reasonable, but at $6/slice that means a large is $48… insanely expensive for just average pizza. You really need to reconsider your prices, they’re way out of line. Lost my business.
Jonathan Cabrera
We went there on 03/07/2025, this place is a disaster with drunk women all over the floor starting fights with people needing to use the bathroom. They definitely need more management at nights. Police were called and no sign of life from the establishment.
Liz
The best thing about this place is the sweet lady making the pizza. I ordered one slice to taste it and it wasn't half bad. I can't believe when I tried to order pies to go, I was told NO bc they were doing pizza by the slice ONLY. I was about to place a large order. Lost my business and won't be going back.
Worse pizza I ever had. Just ordered 2 pizzas and it came out like warm. They placed it into the oven for 5 secs. I asked for crushed pepper, cheese, or pepper and they said they don’t have it. And on the busiest night of the year, Halloween. Both bathrooms were out of service. This place doesn’t know customer service. It will probably go out of business quickly or suffer a slow death. Won’t recommend to anyone!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Definitely a NYC pizza!! Amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've known Nick and his dad for many many years the food is awesome the atmosphere is awesome makes you just want to come back again and again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They charge way too much for pizza.
Overpriced, cashier seems to rip you off, I will not be going back. Sad I used to like it.😞
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Do not go here they charged us $52.99 for a large pepperoni pizza on pride. It was not hot just like warm. They price gauge and we should not support a place that takes advantage of our community
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
No cheese on any slices that were not a cheese slice.
Pepperoni slice was crust, sauce, pepperoni.
Asked the guy (Nick) why there isn't any cheese he said it's on the bottom. I asked him to explain (because you can see crust sauce pepperoni with absolutely no cheese) and he just said, you don't have to buy it leave.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Overpriced and overrated !
$6 for a skinny slice of cheese? Seriously?!?!?
We need better options than expensive pizza that take advantage of the neighborhood’s patrons.
the worst greasy pizza ever. $6. a slice for sleaze slice. and arrogance from the kunt saying covid inflated the price. Cash kunt grab and capitalizing on the gay crowd. Never again. Waste of $$ of time. nyc is cheaper.!
They charged me $17 for a Stromboli. The menu says $6.25. You’ll get taken advantage of, that’s how I felt. Super cold pizza too. Bad experience unfortunately. :(
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza was great! Service was great! And the atmosphere was excellent. I enjoyed great food and great conversations. Try a slice of cake
What kind of pizza place doesn’t let you order a large pizza at 5pm? Even the busiest places in Boston, New York, or anywhere else I’ve been can do this, but Nick’s is only by the slice. That would be fine if the per slice price was reasonable, but at $6/slice that means a large is $48… insanely expensive for just average pizza. You really need to reconsider your prices, they’re way out of line. Lost my business.
We went there on 03/07/2025, this place is a disaster with drunk women all over the floor starting fights with people needing to use the bathroom. They definitely need more management at nights. Police were called and no sign of life from the establishment.
The best thing about this place is the sweet lady making the pizza. I ordered one slice to taste it and it wasn't half bad. I can't believe when I tried to order pies to go, I was told NO bc they were doing pizza by the slice ONLY. I was about to place a large order. Lost my business and won't be going back.
Eh not bad
Loading...