Stromboli's New York Pizzeria
13518 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere
(407) 654-5291
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Food was decent but some of it was overcooked. The penne, however, was cooked perfectly. Red sauce was meh. Not flavorful, but definitely tomato-y. I would go back to try the pizza and some other things.
Awesome pizza and penne vodka. Will definitely make this a regular stop.
First off let me start by saying this place’s pizza is delicious. With that being said every time I come here it’s usually closed. Just went there at 8.52 and sign said closes at 9 and doors already locked. This is the type of attitude that usually puts people out of business. Worst ownership ever just like dominos. Saturday night and u close by 9? lol. Guess I will stop coming in as much as I use to again
Placed order through door dash and it took a really long time to deliver. It's not the store's fault but the pizza was barely warm. It also didn't taste good because the store adds too much black pepper. Never had peppery pizza before and I would not order again. We paid $5 for extra cheese and they barely added extra cheese. We ordered garlic knots and although they were good, it didn't include marinara sauce. It's all about the sauce! They could have done a better NY style pizza. Definitely disappointed with the overall quality.
We had this delivered, I ordered a XLRG cheese pizza w/ Xtra cheese and a SML pepperoni. Both had extra or regular pepper. I've never had pizza with that much pepper it's ridiculous. When it came it was cold as well. We ordered garlic knots but normally I'm used to it having at least marinara sauce and this one didn't. I ended up ordering PieZoni's instaed.
Delicious Stromboli with quick delivery
All good and hot
Hands down the best local pizza!!! 10 out of 10!!!!
By far, our favorite pizza!
Honestly it really tasted like that one spot i ate at in manhattan. This is proper nyc pizza. Amaizng 10/10. Customer service is awesome. bless up stromboli’s
Restaurantji Recommends
Good pizza. Like up North. Not Like a franchise pizza place.
Little to no toppings on the pizza
Just received raw chicken! Absolutely unacceptable! Disgusting and dangerous. It’s one thing to be slow as can be with service, it’s another to serve undercooked poultry. Should be ashamed of yourselves! Do better!
Always great.
Always good as expected
Loading...