Reel Fish Coastal Kitchen and Bar

Our First visit to this seafood restaurant and the noise level hit us at the hostess stand just outside of the bar seating area. We sat at a 2 top next to the fresh fish counter. Although both of us and our waitress had a hard time hearing each other we managed drinks and an appetizer of BLT deviled eggs with a fried oyster on top. My gin martini was very good and the appetizer was delicious. I have never had cioppino and I am very happy with this dish at Reel Fish. I ordered a side of cheesy grits and recommend to ask for no pasta in the dish. The broth and cheese grits were wonderful together and as lunch the next day also. My wife had the shrimp po boy that she thought was a little too chewy. Fred comped it and we have a $25 gift card for the next visit. Service couldn't be better. Maybe we can find a cozy corner with less volume on our next visit. Definitely try this seafood restaurant.

Our waitress, Cassidy, was great. We had a large family next to us that was very loud. They gave us a terrible table even though I told them it was my husband's birthday. However, the food and the service were amazing and we will be back!

We were warmly greeted and quickly seated at a table with paper rose pedals. We ordered an appetizer (Firecracker Shrimp) which was delicious and a good portion to share. Main courses (Ribeye and Peel-and-Eat Shrimp) presented well and were very flavorful. Dessert (Key Lime Pie) was a shareable size and Lattes topped off our meal. My reservation specifications were exceeded!

Service was prompt and friendly. Food was very good. My friend had the grilled salmon which was cooked to perfection. I had the pecan crusted rainbow trout. Two nice size pieces and it was so good I wish I could eat more. The dishes came out of the kitchen promptly because the fish was still very hot. It's been almost a year since the last time I dined here. I think I have to come here more often.

This place was very clean and loved the ambiance. When you stepped inside, you were greeted by a friendly hostess and the owner greeted you as well. I had a reservation so I'm not sure how the waiting goes, but the food was good and the server Holly, was great too! A +++

Other than being extremely loud and in an old building, the experience (especially the food) was great!

Service and atmosphere were very good. Waiter was attentive without being obnoxious. Food was OK. Order Pecan Crusted Red Fish and it was overdone and dry.

We visited Reel Fish in Orlando for Magical Dining before heading to the Winter Park Playhouse, which had recommended the restaurant—and we're so glad they did! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the service made us feel right at home. We both had the ribeye with asparagus and baked potatoes, and it was cooked perfectly—tender, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. For dessert, we tried the carrot cake and coconut cake, both of which were a sweet finish to the meal. Overall, Reel Fish delivered excellent food and a great dining experience. Highly recommend!

Amazing. Just everything about it is amazing and beautiful. Delicious food and drinks. Really good service. We will keep coming back as we always do.

Carolyn was our server. She was knowledgeable about the food. She was attentive to our needs. Our only issue was the menu was not correct for magical dining. Key lime pie was listed as one of the desserts but that was last year. We did end up getting carrot cake and it was like no other. It is pricey without magical dining but after trying the food, we would budget and pay again.

First timer, great good and nice menu selection. Drinks were in point and we had a great server.

This was our first time trying Reel Fish. Everything was outstanding! My appetizer took awhile to come out but they were extremely busy that night so didn't bother me that much. Those grits had to be the best I have ever had. Will definitely be going back.

Always a terrific dining experience - great cocktails, fresh fish offerings and great desserts! Go!

Never disappoints! The magical dining menu is amazing and a great value. Service is always top notch

We visited Reel Fish Coastal Kitchen and Bar for Magical Dining. The host was friendly and apologized several times for not having our table ready right when we arrived for our reservation. But it's not her fault that people weren't leaving:-) Once tables freed up, we were seated and greeted by our server who was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. Gave us the overview about the restaurant, fresh made food, and where some of the seafood is sourced. He was very attentive. We also had a nice visit and chat from the owner, Fred. The food was delicious and definitely worth returning for. We had the ribeye, the red rainbow trout, seafood fritters, firecracker shrimp, gulf oysters, carrot cake, and brownie. All was delish!!