Scotchie's Custom Cakes

2020 W Fairbanks Ave #101, Winter Park
(407) 622-2410

Recent Reviews

Jeffri Riley

Stopped in and he made a fresh six pack of assorted cupcakes of my choice! Really beautiful & welcoming displays. ? Will be back! They seem like really sweet people!

Jason Froehlich

We contacted Scotchie's to create a cake for my son's Eagle Scout board of review celebration. The cake was exactly how we wanted it, it tasted great, everyone loved it and the service Scotchie's provided was perfect! I would highly recommend Scotchie's and will be definitely using them again. Thank you Scotchie's!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca

We were referred to Dan and the Scotchie’s Cake team by a friend who highly recommended him, and so glad she did! Dan was so easy to work with and nailed our vision completely! Not only was the cake beautiful, but more importantly DELICIOUS. We had many guests compliment the cake. So thankful for such an easy process from start to finish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Olson

We were referred to Dan and the Scotchie’s Cake team by a friend who highly recommended him, and so glad she did! Dan was so easy to work with and nailed our vision completely! Not only was the cake beautiful, but more importantly DELICIOUS. We had many guests compliment the cake. So thankful for such an easy process from start to finish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nancy Roman

Love it !! I have ordered 3 cakes from Scotchie's cakes and it is the only place I will get my cakes from now on. From their customer service to their delicious cakes, I recommend 100% to anyone looking for a wonderful cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Lito Rose

My husband and I had an absolutely wonderful time working with Scotchies on our wedding/anniversary cake! They put together both a beautiful and delicious cake that blended the ideas we had to a T. Dan was very kind and answered any questions I had leading up to us picking up our order and the process was super easy. I will be recommending Scotchies to my friends and may have already dropped some birthday cake hints around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake

Matthew Rush

We will 100% be returning to Scotchie’s for all our cakes from now on. Dan was so accommodating and he and his team rocked the design we wanted! Our Son was blown away. What is more important though is how good the cake was. After all, that is the best part!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

MickeysBeachBungalow

Dan Scotchie helped me surprise my daughter with a wedding cake for her elopement with very little notice. We ordered a vanilla signature cake with strawberry filling and white rosettes, and it was sooooo beautiful and delicious. We all raved about it - so moist and flavorful. My daughter's face lit up when she saw it! Dan also provided a gluten-free strawberry cupcake for me, and it was the best gluten-free cake I've ever eaten. Thank you Dan and Scotchie's Bakery for a truly delicious cake and great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelli Kennedy

First experience with Scotchies and will say it wont be the last. From ordering to enjoying is 5 stars. Everyone was asking where was this amazing cake from!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake

Tyler Tanenbaum

The BEST CAKES around. Service is provided by a local owner, they care and it shows. The flavors! Oh the flavors!! You won’t be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Christina Samper

I do not normally write reviews, but I had to due to the exceptional service. Dan took my call around 11 a.m. on a Friday morning and was able to have a cake ready for me same day by 3 p.m. I sent him a photo of my vision, and the team executed it beautifully. I will definitely come back here for future occasions!!! The cake is beautiful, and I can't wait to share it with my family.

Larry Rinker

I was pleasantly surprised with my experience ordering a birthday cake for my wife from Scotchie’s. Friendly and attentive ownership and staff. The cake was marvelous. Can’t wait to order another one!

Maggie F

I must give credit to where it’s due. I had been looking for the right place for a Gluten Free cake for our son’s 13th Birthday, who has Celiac. For all my Celiac moms out there… you and I both know the side effects as it relates to cross contamination, etc. I visited Scotchie’s Cake in person a week prior to when I needed the cake and the owner, Dan, was so welcoming. He was very attentive to my allergen concerns and re-assured me over and over that they understood that this was not a “gluten-friendly” cake but ? Gluten Free and they were well versed in all necessary precautions that needed to be taken. After consulting with another local bakery, which I was not too impressed with….I decided to give Scotchie’s Custom Cakes a try. I found the design of the cake online, forwarded a pic to Dan, and placed my order.When I arrived to pick up the cake… I was impressed on how beautifulit had turned out. It was then well boxed with an attached cake cutter to go with it as well. I knew the ultimate test would occur later on that evening and into the next day.Fast forward to birthday dinner….Our son felt so special that he could dive right into his cake with no questions s asked… although he did ask a few times, “Wait, this cake is gluten free? No way!”The cake was moist and absolutely delicious. There was no weird aftertaste, no gritty falling apart type ordeal… I mean, literally one couldn’t tell it was a gluten free cake if you didn’t mention it.Furthermore, 24hrs later, he had no complaints of malaise, stomach pain, no NADA. He had a fun-filled 13th Birthday with THE BEST GLUTEN FREE CAKE EVER!Scotchie’s Custom Cakes passed our Celiac test… hands down! ☺️???Dan….Praying for continued blessings on your business. Your dedication and passion in doing what you love did not go unnoticed.Thanks again to the entire team!Disclaimer: The photo I’ve attached shows the cake that was executed by Scotchie’s Custom Cakes... However, as for the the topper accessories, I purchased them from Amazon and placed those on there myself to add a little personal touch to it. Next time… I’ll let Dan do it for sure…lol.

Aerielle Maxwell

Dan and his team were incredible! I requested a specific cake and they were able to recreate it and it was perfection and it was absolutely delicious! Highly recommend Scotchies I will be using them from now on!

Claire Crossman

Beautiful Mamma Mia inspired cake and it was gluten free! All of our guests loved it. Thank you!

Load More