I love everything! My special favorite is Tom’s Fave pizza. The garlic knots are great and one of these days I’ll have the Veal Parmesan dinner which a pal of mine swears by.
Yudith Hernandez
Delivery tooked about 2 hours. They said because the storm the electricity went off but we have to wait too long for two medium pizzas.
D V
Very convenient location, excellent food, great staff, excellent beer choices !!!
A Z
This is the closest to old style pizzeria pizza I've found in over a decade in Florida. If you're a pizza aficionado, you really NEED to try this place (it's my new #1 and I'm a pizza snob) What's really noticable? The sauce (or gravy depending of the party of Italy you're from) is NOT from a can or a supplier (I've rated the 2 major suppliers also). One of the things that happens when you make sauce is that the acidity spikes, the easiest and cheapest way to cut acidity is with sugar (that's why all the chains have overly sweet sauce which is fine for children who don't know better). This is NOT the case here, they know at least one of the old traditional ways. You'll even find actual pieces of tomato in the sauce (as it should be)! And yes,I did poke my nose into the kitchen! Why only 4 stars? While the dough is tasty and crisp and thin but it's not perfect. It's a darn sight better than anything you'll probably find for over 100 miles! Honestly I suspect the oven temp is off, might be a bit high. I know this may sound strange but I felt there was too much cheese (yes, it is indeed possible and I love cheese).
Is it worth going? Yes! To the exclusion of every other pizzeria I've found so far in Nassau and Duval county. I will be back to try some of their other dishes.
Also worth noting is they've got high quality ovens (no conveyers here!)
Chad Ver Pault
In town visiting my mom again, surprise mother's Day visit....🤫 While she was working I grabbed lunch...I got the on-point cheesy meatball stuffed mushrooms, a Green Point Coffee beer, and a 10 in Margerita pizza with pepperoni n sausage added...(Recommended by guy sitting next to me .). The pizza was nothing short of spectacular combo of fresh, savory, and spicy n and the perfect amount of fresh tomatoes.... Besides the food the atmosphere is relaxing even when busy...service is impeccable and even got a few ideas for places to take my mother for a fancy dinner... Check it out n make sure you ask about the specials...they are very creative and you can tell the chef cooks with passion!!!
T rmequip
Good food good service
Steve Berdan
Great pizza and stuffed mushrooms
Cason Van Zant
Melissa was fantastic and the food was AMAZING!!! Highly recommend!
Amy Borders
Best pizza on the island. Great drinks and food.
Stacey M
We love Coastal Pizza. The pizza, salads, wings, and pasta dishes are incredible! Staff is friendly and beer is cold😊!
Visiting a friend and our host picked up two pies for dinner tonight. I ordered the mushrooms, jalapeños, & Bell Peppers. Great crispy crust and plenty of toppings. The girls had half mushroom and half pepperoni. Truly great 🍕!!!
Liz
Love Coastal Pizza! Wonderful pizza and salads! Friendly staff. Highly recommend
E M
This is the best pizza that I have found on the island. Thin crisp crust, flavorful sauce and toppings. This place is always busy - for good reason.
Maureen McManus
Initially enjoyed this place; but on the last two occasions we have had bad experiences. Veggies on pizza were crispy and raw…..same goes for the eggplant parmesan entree. Meatballs were cold, too. They refused to take any entrees off our bill & gave us free dessert instead. We won’t be back.
C Boek
I came in recently and placed an order to go, enjoying a moment at the bar with a cold beer as I waited. The owner, Tom, who was working behind the bar, graciously took my order, even offering to cut up my kids’ pizza into manageable slices for their tiny hands. I then watched, slightly amused, as another customer, seated a couple of stools down, began complaining about how long her order was taking. Now, I don’t want to assume anyone else’s level of personal happiness, and god knows we all have good days and bad days, but some folks were just born with a perpetual rain cloud over their heads, and this lady, well she fit the bill, looking like she probably hadn’t smiled since the fall of the Berlin Wall or maybe since her late husband’s death was ruled an “accident” by the coroner. Any way, Tom immediately stopped what he was doing, raced back to the kitchen, and then, moments later hand delivered her hot pizza, kindly explaining that it had really only been 20 minutes since she had placed her order and that all of the items were made from scratch, so, you know, that takes a little time. Crises averted, or, so it seemed, but, wouldn’t you know it, not even five minutes had passed before this curmudgeon of a patron began complaining yet again, only this time, it was about her pizza being “too cheesy.” Now, imagine being the type of person who complains about the amount of cheese on your pizza. To me, that’s like complaining that water is too wet or that the seggs is too good. Any way, in light of this woman’s second and very vocal complaint, Tom briefly paused, took a moment to compose himself, and then, like a patron saint, offered to pay for the woman’s meal. Now, it’s not often that you get to witness firsthand an act of humility like that in a public sphere and it nearly brought me to tears. Frankly, we could all learn something from this situation, especially in this politically-charged day and age. I mean, of all the things that Tom could’ve said, my man chose to take the higher road. And to top it off, he only asked one thing of the woman in return…that she never step foot in the restaurant again. 10/10 experience, I will be coming back. Pizza’s great, too!
I love everything! My special favorite is Tom’s Fave pizza. The garlic knots are great and one of these days I’ll have the Veal Parmesan dinner which a pal of mine swears by.
Delivery tooked about 2 hours. They said because the storm the electricity went off but we have to wait too long for two medium pizzas.
Very convenient location, excellent food, great staff, excellent beer choices !!!
This is the closest to old style pizzeria pizza I've found in over a decade in Florida.
If you're a pizza aficionado, you really NEED to try this place (it's my new #1 and I'm a pizza snob)
What's really noticable?
The sauce (or gravy depending of the party
of Italy you're from) is NOT from a can or a supplier (I've rated the 2 major suppliers also). One of the things that happens when you make sauce is that the acidity spikes, the easiest and cheapest way to cut acidity is with sugar (that's why all the chains have overly sweet sauce which is fine for children who don't know better). This is NOT the case here, they know at least one of the old traditional ways. You'll even find actual pieces of tomato in the sauce (as it should be)! And yes,I did poke my nose into the kitchen!
Why only 4 stars? While the dough is tasty and crisp and thin but it's not perfect. It's a darn sight better than anything you'll probably find for over 100 miles! Honestly I suspect the oven temp is off, might be a bit high.
I know this may sound strange but I felt there was too much cheese (yes, it is indeed possible and I love cheese).
Is it worth going? Yes! To the exclusion of every other pizzeria I've found so far in Nassau and Duval county. I will be back to try some of their other dishes.
Also worth noting is they've got high quality ovens (no conveyers here!)
In town visiting my mom again, surprise mother's Day visit....🤫 While she was working I grabbed lunch...I got the on-point cheesy meatball stuffed mushrooms, a Green Point Coffee beer, and a 10 in Margerita pizza with pepperoni n sausage added...(Recommended by guy sitting next to me .).
The pizza was nothing short of spectacular combo of fresh, savory, and spicy n and the perfect amount of fresh tomatoes....
Besides the food the atmosphere is relaxing even when busy...service is impeccable and even got a few ideas for places to take my mother for a fancy dinner...
Check it out n make sure you ask about the specials...they are very creative and you can tell the chef cooks with passion!!!
Good food good service
Great pizza and stuffed mushrooms
Melissa was fantastic and the food was AMAZING!!! Highly recommend!
Best pizza on the island. Great drinks and food.
We love Coastal Pizza. The pizza, salads, wings, and pasta dishes are incredible! Staff is friendly and beer is cold😊!
Restaurantji Recommends
Visiting a friend and our host picked up two pies for dinner tonight. I ordered the mushrooms, jalapeños, & Bell Peppers. Great crispy crust and plenty of toppings. The girls had half mushroom and half pepperoni. Truly great 🍕!!!
Love Coastal Pizza! Wonderful pizza and salads! Friendly staff. Highly recommend
This is the best pizza that I have found on the island. Thin crisp crust, flavorful sauce and toppings. This place is always busy - for good reason.
Initially enjoyed this place; but on the last two occasions we have had bad experiences. Veggies on pizza were crispy and raw…..same goes for the eggplant parmesan entree. Meatballs were cold, too. They refused to take any entrees off our bill & gave us free dessert instead. We won’t be back.
I came in recently and placed an order to go, enjoying a moment at the bar with a cold beer as I waited. The owner, Tom, who was working behind the bar, graciously took my order, even offering to cut up my kids’ pizza into manageable slices for their tiny hands. I then watched, slightly amused, as another customer, seated a couple of stools down, began complaining about how long her order was taking. Now, I don’t want to assume anyone else’s level of personal happiness, and god knows we all have good days and bad days, but some folks were just born with a perpetual rain cloud over their heads, and this lady, well she fit the bill, looking like she probably hadn’t smiled since the fall of the Berlin Wall or maybe since her late husband’s death was ruled an “accident” by the coroner. Any way, Tom immediately stopped what he was doing, raced back to the kitchen, and then, moments later hand delivered her hot pizza, kindly explaining that it had really only been 20 minutes since she had placed her order and that all of the items were made from scratch, so, you know, that takes a little time. Crises averted, or, so it seemed, but, wouldn’t you know it, not even five minutes had passed before this curmudgeon of a patron began complaining yet again, only this time, it was about her pizza being “too cheesy.” Now, imagine being the type of person who complains about the amount of cheese on your pizza. To me, that’s like complaining that water is too wet or that the seggs is too good. Any way, in light of this woman’s second and very vocal complaint, Tom briefly paused, took a moment to compose himself, and then, like a patron saint, offered to pay for the woman’s meal. Now, it’s not often that you get to witness firsthand an act of humility like that in a public sphere and it nearly brought me to tears. Frankly, we could all learn something from this situation, especially in this politically-charged day and age. I mean, of all the things that Tom could’ve said, my man chose to take the higher road. And to top it off, he only asked one thing of the woman in return…that she never step foot in the restaurant again. 10/10 experience, I will be coming back. Pizza’s great, too!
Loading...