Calzone was awful. Overdone crust. Garlic bread was mushy and underbaked..Stromboli undercooked..not going back. Seems like someone just threw it together..awful. Wound up throwing most of it out..
Samantha Frost
Honestly, this was a pretty terrible experience. My pizza was extremely undercooked to the point some of the dough wasn’t cooked through. I think even if it was cooked well it still would have been pretty gross. The cheese tasted like it was 90% provolone and I still can’t figure out how to describe the after taste of the crust. The only reason this isn’t a 1 star is because our waitress was very kind although the staff seemed miserable as they worked.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ron Golden
Great service and great pizza every day. Love it
C. Allen B.
There were 6 of us. 1 order came out, then 5 minutes later 2 more, then 5 minutes more, 2 more and then the last 2 ordered wings which came out 20 minutes later and were way overdone. The staff did comp the cost of the wings but when they were told that we had a customer satisfaction issue they were very standoffish and seemed scared to speak to us about the problem, stumbling over their words and slowly walking backwards while talking. And put the blame on the poor "new people"
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Jeff Jahn
Amazing place and pizza! This is our go to about once a week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Norman Fant
$85 to order. included 2 large salads at abt. $11 per. skimpy and lacked ingredients. I asked if a large was enough to share. Certainly not like MPC's .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
James Murphy
Definitely should not be called New York pizza.
Food: 2
A. Grasso
No fault of the server but, service was very slow. Food cook time was very long. Ordered build your own calzones and they were awful. Ordered extra ricotta. Could not see nor taste the ricotta at all. Calzones were flat, very runny with grease. Marinara was watery. Buffalo cheese dip was like milly. Came with brushetta toast instead of pita chips, as other Johnny's do. Food was bland.Almost $$50, for two people, for bad food.Again, none of these things were the fault of the server.Will not return.Parking: Adequate.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tim Nagy
The food is good, but the service is pretty inattentive.
Marcus Johnson
Came in on the 11/21/23 place was full and packed ,definitely saw the staff on full throttle! Ordered my usual Johnnys deluxe well for the first time the Canadian bacon was forgotten. I raised it to my servers attention(Samantha) and the server went and had a new one put in for me to get it handled and the owner came over and apologized and it was an overall great experience. Big shout out to the server Samantha and the owner Stacie.
Have visited often in the past but not moving forward. Visited the evening of 11/10 and had to interrupt two waitresses assembling take out boxes to clean the only open table for me. Then waited ten minutes for the same two waitresses to get done making boxes, then they went and waited on two groups who came in after me. Owner you need to check your helps initiative!
Service: 1
Ee Family
This is our go-to for really good pizza. The staff is very nice and they make sure you are happy before you leave. And the pizza is awesome. Perfect crust, perfect amount of toppings. I suggest pepperoni, meatballs, and sliced tomatoes. Great for couples' night, family or just hang out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Craft
Friendly staff, excellent pizza ? ? Reasonable price for the quality ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny
Rhonda Staley-Rung
Don’t ever go to this so called Pizza Place…Not a Pizzarestaurant..So called a daughter of the family owned restaurant Samantha..you will never get your food order correctly..When we picked it up, pizza was cold…. !It was a meat lovers with no meat!When we asked to rectify the problem which was over a Greek salad they did not have a driver to come out to bring this to us …(the missing Greek dinner Salad which we had to go with the meat lovers pizza do you want us to come back 10 miles to come pick the dinner salad up because I didn’t have a driver)…What!There is No! Satisfying the customer and no dinner for them as well (I know just a missing Greek salad, which we paid for.)She offered us a credit for the salad..Samantha, the owners daughter…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jodi James
The family is looking at better food choices, but who doesn't want a slice of pizza on vacation. My husband found Johnny's on line.My hubby suggested the sharing a cauliflower crust pizza, rather than individual slices. We went with a traditional pepperoni and cheese.Who knew! It was solid, crisp on the edges. Really tasty and satisfying. The sauce and cheese were high quality and delicious.We also learned some turkey pepperoni is better than original pepperoni!Fabulous meal - shared a large salad and great pizza. Will definitely be back.Dietary restrictions: This place offers low carb, glutton free crust options.
Calzone was awful. Overdone crust. Garlic bread was mushy and underbaked..Stromboli undercooked..not going back. Seems like someone just threw it together..awful. Wound up throwing most of it out..
Honestly, this was a pretty terrible experience. My pizza was extremely undercooked to the point some of the dough wasn’t cooked through. I think even if it was cooked well it still would have been pretty gross. The cheese tasted like it was 90% provolone and I still can’t figure out how to describe the after taste of the crust. The only reason this isn’t a 1 star is because our waitress was very kind although the staff seemed miserable as they worked.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great service and great pizza every day. Love it
There were 6 of us. 1 order came out, then 5 minutes later 2 more, then 5 minutes more, 2 more and then the last 2 ordered wings which came out 20 minutes later and were way overdone. The staff did comp the cost of the wings but when they were told that we had a customer satisfaction issue they were very standoffish and seemed scared to speak to us about the problem, stumbling over their words and slowly walking backwards while talking. And put the blame on the poor "new people"
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Amazing place and pizza! This is our go to about once a week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
$85 to order. included 2 large salads at abt. $11 per. skimpy and lacked ingredients. I asked if a large was enough to share. Certainly not like MPC's .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Definitely should not be called New York pizza.
Food: 2
No fault of the server but, service was very slow. Food cook time was very long. Ordered build your own calzones and they were awful. Ordered extra ricotta. Could not see nor taste the ricotta at all. Calzones were flat, very runny with grease. Marinara was watery. Buffalo cheese dip was like milly. Came with brushetta toast instead of pita chips, as other Johnny's do. Food was bland.Almost $$50, for two people, for bad food.Again, none of these things were the fault of the server.Will not return.Parking: Adequate.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food is good, but the service is pretty inattentive.
Came in on the 11/21/23 place was full and packed ,definitely saw the staff on full throttle! Ordered my usual Johnnys deluxe well for the first time the Canadian bacon was forgotten. I raised it to my servers attention(Samantha) and the server went and had a new one put in for me to get it handled and the owner came over and apologized and it was an overall great experience. Big shout out to the server Samantha and the owner Stacie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Have visited often in the past but not moving forward. Visited the evening of 11/10 and had to interrupt two waitresses assembling take out boxes to clean the only open table for me. Then waited ten minutes for the same two waitresses to get done making boxes, then they went and waited on two groups who came in after me. Owner you need to check your helps initiative!
Service: 1
This is our go-to for really good pizza. The staff is very nice and they make sure you are happy before you leave. And the pizza is awesome. Perfect crust, perfect amount of toppings. I suggest pepperoni, meatballs, and sliced tomatoes. Great for couples' night, family or just hang out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly staff, excellent pizza ? ? Reasonable price for the quality ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Johnny
Don’t ever go to this so called Pizza Place…Not a Pizzarestaurant..So called a daughter of the family owned restaurant Samantha..you will never get your food order correctly..When we picked it up, pizza was cold…. !It was a meat lovers with no meat!When we asked to rectify the problem which was over a Greek salad they did not have a driver to come out to bring this to us …(the missing Greek dinner Salad which we had to go with the meat lovers pizza do you want us to come back 10 miles to come pick the dinner salad up because I didn’t have a driver)…What!There is No! Satisfying the customer and no dinner for them as well (I know just a missing Greek salad, which we paid for.)She offered us a credit for the salad..Samantha, the owners daughter…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The family is looking at better food choices, but who doesn't want a slice of pizza on vacation. My husband found Johnny's on line.My hubby suggested the sharing a cauliflower crust pizza, rather than individual slices. We went with a traditional pepperoni and cheese.Who knew! It was solid, crisp on the edges. Really tasty and satisfying. The sauce and cheese were high quality and delicious.We also learned some turkey pepperoni is better than original pepperoni!Fabulous meal - shared a large salad and great pizza. Will definitely be back.Dietary restrictions: This place offers low carb, glutton free crust options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5