Carmines Pizza Tavern

Solid menu with great prices! Wings were delicious. Waitress didn’t really knew the menu that much and totally forgot to bring the entree we ordered but we were full so when she got the check i didn’t say anything. However is worth noting that the main and one and only dish we ordered other than side salad and pirogies and wings and a slice of pizza was not brought. Service was good outside of that! I’d recommend the spot and would go back!

Calzone was massive. Super delicious. Sean was our server and did a great job. The rest of my family enjoyed there yummy pizza. I’ll definitely be back!!!

Changed owners food not up to previous owners grade portions smaller pizza just dough and sauce barely a hint of cheese meatballs the size if quarters food warm not hot one other customer inside and server never came back to check on us like was everything okay or did we want refills on drinks and the servers were two high school kids in shorts a hoodie and their hat on backwards looks like the end of carmine's as we knew it asked for manager there was none a waste of $35.00 much better places for Italian food in Alpharetta there wasn't an option for zero stars or I would have rated it zero been going there for7 years and that will end with last night

This is the third try going here with a group of friends. They had their three tries, no more. Flies in the dining room, wait staff who PUT THEIR FINGERS IN YOUR FOOD, slow service and worst of all, the food is very highly priced and the last time we were there, almost inedible. I ordered the Chicken Francese and it was basically boiled noodles with two frozen chicken patties on top. A friend took it home to give to her dog. I basically paid $20 for one garlic bread knot. Nope nope nope.

Lunch specials are a great option. They have recently remodeled and brought the look up a bit. Food has always been tastey and the drinks large! For dinner, try the stuffed shells.

I had two slices of the Park Avenue which was sun dried tomatoes (love ‘em), spinach and artichokes. Very tasty indeed. The slices were pretty large so I was starting to break a sweat when I finished the second slice. I thought that the pricing was reasonable. Two large slices and a drink cost me $8. I’ll try them again.

Great value, young wait staff but very pleasant and food good quality (salad always fresh). Great price point for Alpharetta area. A gem without waiting lines which makes it even more attractive. A calm environment in an overly busy area. Sit on the patio for the beat experience. People who prefer to be pampered might prefer another choice.

It was my worst experience at a restaurant in a long time. First off the restaurant was empty, we had two different waiters never knew which one to ask for. Our appetizer came out great but then it went down hill. We ordered a pizza and waited 20 minuets and then asked the manager when it was coming out and then come to find out he never put it in the system. Now about 25-30 minuets later our pizza finally came out and it was so greasy that's the only thing I tasted. I asked the person waiting on us why that was and she made excuses about the meat. Also the shakers for the Parmesan cheese where old and rusty on the inside and then when I asked the manager about it she made up excuses. At the end of the day I will never go back to this place. Also for such a big restaurant you would think it would be extremely busy but nope except for a couple people.

It is your basic "faster" Italian food. Not fast food, not "the best Italian food" I've ever had, just okay. The service was fine, again nothing special. Really nothing to bring us back again.

Carmine's is great! Their food selection is wide and has all different tastes. They have pastas, calzones, Stromboli's, and they are all delicious. All the waiters and waitresses are friendly as well.

Love this little Italian place! I had soup and salad, my daughter had pasta and her friend had pizza. Food was great, waitress nice and bill was a good price. We will come back again!

I had two slices of the Park Avenue which was sun dried tomatoes (love ‘em), spinach and artichokes. Very tasty indeed. The slices were pretty large so I was starting to break a sweat when I finished the second slice. I thought that the pricing was reasonable. Two large slices and a drink cost me $8. I'll try them again.

Brand new owners. Pizza is some of the best in the area. Whether you want a slice off pizza to a full pie they will satisfy. If your looking for something other than pizza though Carmines has it as well. They have pasta, subs, salads and so much more that makes this place great for the whole family. Don't forget to ask for Alicia!