Great food, great service! Vincent the owner spent a good deal of time talking with us and making us feel comfortable. We will definitely return!
Malik
Wow, wow, and wow. What a night to remember! Best place to celebrate the lady's birthday. The food was immaculate and our server Mary Katherine was excellent and made great suggestions for our first time. From the starter to dessert, everything we had was exceptional! It was also good to be able to speak to the owner Vincent and learn more about how the restaurant came to be. Go here, we promise you'll enjoy it! Sorry for no pictures, everything was getting hammered as soon as it was placed down!
Linda
I always expect to pay top dollar for a high quality meal. The meal i had was sub standard at best. Crab meat was TASTELESS, probably frozen, and my $136.00 steak, while perfectly cooked, had little if any seasoning. Very bland. The oysters were the size of nickles, not much to them. My martini was very good, but my friend had two house cocktails that were f-o-u-l. In short, a disheartening and expensive dining experience. If Cotton Calf continues to provide such mediocre food for the price of a king's ransom, i have little doubt their doors will permanently close as the truth of their restaurant becomes clear. Speaking of 'clear,' stear clear of this place and go somewhere else.
Beverly
Great atmosphere and service. I had the hanger steak at the recommmendation of the waiter and it was excellent. Our favorite restaurant in the area- no need to travel to Atlanta for an excellent steak.
Michael Magree
Always great steaks, lobster Mac and cheese!! Friendly staff that make sure you are happy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jules K-B
We had not been here in a while and we were not disappointed with this dinner. The specials were absolutely delicious and my filet was perfect. I was also given a hefty amount of crab as my garnish! Our server was on point and made our experience nicer. I will say the Kobe ribeye was a tad overpriced but it did melt in your mouth. We will not wait so long to come back next time.
Opentable Diner
I've been here multiple times. Some how, it gets better every time. I would give this place a Michelin Star if it were up to me. Can't say enough good things about it. If you're trying to decide where to get dinner, Cotton Calf is the answer.
Edward Drachenberg Jr. (Mewtwo000)
Fantastic food and service with plenty of gluten free options!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Intermediate Handyman
Food was freaking delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marie
Usually Cotton Calf is amazing but last night was horrible. You could tell the server was stretched too thin and struggling to keep up. At one point we waited 30 minutes for another round of drinks. My steak was overcooked for the first time ever but I couldn't send it back with how much our server was struggling.
We have eaten here a handful of times now and each experience has been wonderful. The food is always excellent, the service is good (would be great but there always very busy so drink refills can lag), and it's a great place to go for a nice meal.
Steven
As always it did not disappoint. Everything was excellent. Steak was done perfect. Look forward to going back soon
Dan Dick
2 people and $500 later… would absolutely go back… even though the price is high, the food was superb and the service was excellent. Small and somewhat intimate atmosphere with a white table cloth setting, lets you know your experience will be worth it. The fair selection was perfectly matched with the selection of wines. If you are in the area of Braselton, this is a must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pam Rhodes
This restaurant will never get another dime of my money!!! We have eaten here several times a year for special occasions since they opened. I made reservations on my birthday earlier this month and asked if they served Diet Coke because the last time I was told they were switching to Coke Zero. I was told they do not, so I asked if I could bring my own, to which they said I could. When we sat down at the restaurant and I pulled out the 20 oz (average individual size) sealed Diet Coke, the waitress pitched a fit and said there was absolutely no outside drinks allowed. She went and got the manager who came over with an irate, raised voice and said “I don’t know who told you that, but they were wrong!”. We were all but asked to leave, but that’s what we did. I have never experienced such rude customer service in my life, much less from a supposed “upscale” restaurant. They’ll lose all of our future business and I’ll make sure to tell all of our family and friends. Their food is overpriced anyway. Ridiculous!!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Kaitlin Tewksbury
Food was really good, except creamed corn-it tasted like queso. Also bathroom door jams, hard to get out of. Service was great
Great food, great service! Vincent the owner spent a good deal of time talking with us and making us feel comfortable. We will definitely return!
Wow, wow, and wow. What a night to remember! Best place to celebrate the lady's birthday. The food was immaculate and our server Mary Katherine was excellent and made great suggestions for our first time. From the starter to dessert, everything we had was exceptional! It was also good to be able to speak to the owner Vincent and learn more about how the restaurant came to be. Go here, we promise you'll enjoy it! Sorry for no pictures, everything was getting hammered as soon as it was placed down!
I always expect to pay top dollar for a high quality meal. The meal i had was sub standard at best. Crab meat was TASTELESS, probably frozen, and my $136.00 steak, while perfectly cooked, had little if any seasoning. Very bland. The oysters were the size of nickles, not much to them. My martini was very good, but my friend had two house cocktails that were f-o-u-l. In short, a disheartening and expensive dining experience. If Cotton Calf continues to provide such mediocre food for the price of a king's ransom, i have little doubt their doors will permanently close as the truth of their restaurant becomes clear. Speaking of 'clear,' stear clear of this place and go somewhere else.
Great atmosphere and service. I had the hanger steak at the recommmendation of the waiter and it was excellent. Our favorite restaurant in the area- no need to travel to Atlanta for an excellent steak.
Always great steaks, lobster Mac and cheese!!
Friendly staff that make sure you are happy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had not been here in a while and we were not disappointed with this dinner. The specials were absolutely delicious and my filet was perfect. I was also given a hefty amount of crab as my garnish! Our server was on point and made our experience nicer. I will say the Kobe ribeye was a tad overpriced but it did melt in your mouth. We will not wait so long to come back next time.
I've been here multiple times. Some how, it gets better every time. I would give this place a Michelin Star if it were up to me. Can't say enough good things about it. If you're trying to decide where to get dinner, Cotton Calf is the answer.
Fantastic food and service with plenty of gluten free options!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was freaking delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Usually Cotton Calf is amazing but last night was horrible. You could tell the server was stretched too thin and struggling to keep up. At one point we waited 30 minutes for another round of drinks. My steak was overcooked for the first time ever but I couldn't send it back with how much our server was struggling.
Restaurantji Recommends
We have eaten here a handful of times now and each experience has been wonderful. The food is always excellent, the service is good (would be great but there always very busy so drink refills can lag), and it's a great place to go for a nice meal.
As always it did not disappoint. Everything was excellent. Steak was done perfect. Look forward to going back soon
2 people and $500 later… would absolutely go back… even though the price is high, the food was superb and the service was excellent. Small and somewhat intimate atmosphere with a white table cloth setting, lets you know your experience will be worth it. The fair selection was perfectly matched with the selection of wines. If you are in the area of Braselton, this is a must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This restaurant will never get another dime of my money!!! We have eaten here several times a year for special occasions since they opened. I made reservations on my birthday earlier this month and asked if they served Diet Coke because the last time I was told they were switching to Coke Zero. I was told they do not, so I asked if I could bring my own, to which they said I could. When we sat down at the restaurant and I pulled out the 20 oz (average individual size) sealed Diet Coke, the waitress pitched a fit and said there was absolutely no outside drinks allowed. She went and got the manager who came over with an irate, raised voice and said “I don’t know who told you that, but they were wrong!”. We were all but asked to leave, but that’s what we did. I have never experienced such rude customer service in my life, much less from a supposed “upscale” restaurant. They’ll lose all of our future business and I’ll make sure to tell all of our family and friends. Their food is overpriced anyway. Ridiculous!!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Food was really good, except creamed corn-it tasted like queso. Also bathroom door jams, hard to get out of. Service was great
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...