C&S Seafood and Oyster Bar, Brookhaven

I have been going to this location for 6+ months every week/ weekend and have never had a bad experience. The food is always consistent and the drinks are magical. And let me tell you, what a staff! Gage and Alex the two managers are absolutely fantastic and so accommodating. The bartenders.. next level. Clean bar, great hosts, great drinks. Shout out to LOUIS for being always amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is my first time at this location, but I’ve been to another location and I was expecting it to be an elegant and lovely service like I’ve received previously, but to my surprise it was not! Service was Pretty bad I mean literally I asked the white or Hispanic male bartender three times for a water and He never brought it! I had to ask the female Bartender Which was fourth time requesting water And thankfully, she brought it. I needed the water pretty bad and I was sitting for a pretty decent amount of time suffering because the male Bartender refused to water… he was too busy hollering At some females but that was on the third request. The male Bartender Was not attentive at all And I just feel like I did not Need to be there so after taking a bite of my salty oysters I decided to just go ahead and take everything to go when I got home. I noticed that Three of oyster only had cheese Melted on top there were no oysters inside so I pretty much wasted my time and money. I will not be coming back here again!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

The sweet potato cheesecake is so delightful and delicious. Oysters were amazing. Our waiter Theo was so pleasant. Brookhaven for the win .. again!

During my recent visit to C&S Brookhaven, I had an exceptional fine dining experience. The ambiance was warm and inviting, setting the stage for a memorable meal.

I started with the Tuna Tartar, which was fresh and flavorful, perfectly balanced with subtle seasoning.

The highlight of the evening was the Chargrilled Oysters, served with garlic butter and parmesan cheese. They were perfectly cooked with a smoky, savory flavor and a slight char that enhanced their briny essence.

Service by Theo was impeccable—attentive and knowledgeable without being intrusive. His recommendations and warm demeanor elevated the evening. To add, the manager was very polite and personable which added to the welcoming atmosphere and overall positive experience.

Overall, I left satisfied and eager for my next visit, highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The chargrilled oysters are the best in Atlanta and might even be in Georgia! I recommend happy hour for the oysters. Mo was our server and he was GREAT energy.

Parking: Valet is available for $6. There is a parking garage if you want to self-park!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chargrilled Oysters

Justin was amazing! Answered every question to a T! Had a great vibe, making our experience even better! The food was amazing and very well plated! Will go back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went in early for Happy Hour oysters to be followed by an entree. We were seated immediately without a reservation, which we had gambled on since it was a Tuesday. Once we sat down, we sat and waited and waited… until a busman finally asked if our waiter had been by. We eventually were given water and bread service- by the same busman. By the way, a note about the bread: there are slices of white sesame seed bread and oddly, thin raisin bread slices accompanied by sweetened butter. Not sure why that was chosen to accompany a seafood oriented menu.
When our waiter did appear, we each ordered the Happy Hour dozen oysters, which were good, but not as crisp as cold water oysters usually are- they were from Louisiana, and had significant amounts of shell inclusions, and they had not fully been severed from their shells, which posed a bit of of a problem, as oddly, we were given small spoons instead of small forks. We’ve never encountered that before, but we perservered and enjoyed them. We followed those by sharing an order of Char-grilled oysters, which were very good, although we had to ask twice for small forks with which to actually eat them.
After 18 oysters each, we were fairly surfeited, but actually had gone to C and S to order one specific entree: Swordfish au Poivre with creamed spinach, colossal onion rings, and peppercorn sauce. Our waiter and the chefs were more than gracious in letting us split an entree, and we each had a lovely portion of one of the most inventive and delicious treatments of a meaty fish we have ever eaten. We highly recommend this entree.
Had there not been so many odd lapses in attention during our meal, this review would probably have been an unequivocal 5. But we have eaten at other branches of this local seafood stalwart with impeccable service before, and never experienced these sorts of service issues. The room is beautiful, the menu is interesting, bits of service and of presentation seemed oddly lacking.
.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Great experience ?
Amazing seafood ...excellent service by Rachel.

The only thing I could say is about the waiting for drinks ... but totally recommend ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Every time I visit C & S Brookhaven the service is impeccable! Food.. amazingggg!! I usually get the Raw & Chargrilled Oysters. Highly recommend 10/10. Everyone treats you like family, personally attending to you. You will not regret visiting ;)

Excellent food & customer service. The grilled oysters with lobster were exceptional. The keylime pie was superb.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oysters Rockefeller, Branzino Blackened, Chargrilled Oysters, Fried Brussels Sprouts, Key Lime Pie

Krystal, Luis & Mo are the best!!! Their customer service is always on %100, they're super sweet and never miss. They are all truly gems.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I stopped by for happy hour and was blown away by the amazing service from Krystal, Louis, Moe, and Kel! The drinks were top-notch, and their friendly, welcoming attitudes made the experience even better. I’ve been coming here since they first opened, and every visit has been fantastic. Highly recommend this spot if you're looking for great drinks and an even better dinner

Stopped in for a quick bite today. Ordered salmon. Asked for it to come out well done. It came out half cooked. Bartender took it to management they talked over food. Bartender was a Hispanic female. Then the cooks put the same salmon on the grill and sent it out smh horrible. Me and the bartender I asked her for lemon. She goes in to try to get a limit with her hand and then proceed to drop it in my water. I’m gonna stick to the Cumberland location.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great food, service and ambience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jumbo Shrimp

Had a wonderful anniversary dinner here. We love C&S and go often, but this time was particularly special. The food was wonderful as always, but our experience was made even better by our very kind waiter, Theo. He exemplified professionalism and kindness and truly made our anniversary so wonderful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oysters Rockefeller, Fried Calamari Rings