Johnny's New York Style Pizza
4108 Hamilton Mill Rd Suite 280, Buford
(470) 238-8322
Customers' Favorites
2 Slices with 1 Regular Topping Each Lunch Special
Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Canadian Bacon & Pineapple
2 Slices 2 Toppings Pizza
Extra Crispy Hot Wings
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Traditional Stromboli
Steak & Cheese Pizza
A Fantastic Calzone
Hawaiian Luau Pizza
Menu
Photos
+75 photos
+74 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
It has been so nice to have a Johnny’s near the house because the Pizza and Wings at the Sugarloaf location has been a wonderful Friday Night luxury. The new spot opened about 2 years ago but struggled with quality. But I must say, as of 2025, it is the Pizza spot in the Gwinnett; yes better than Mellow Mushroom in Suwanee. The service and quality food have improved over the last 2 years whereas it is our game day spot for Pizza. The addition of bourbon tasting has made the...
Man I have nothing but good stuff to say about this place. The pizza is amazing, and the staff are too. I had an issue one night with a pizza and Megan, one of the managers, went so far out of her way to make it right that it’s something you don’t really find anymore these days. Shout out to her, for real. 10/10 would highly recommend this specific Johnnys location. They have my return business until I either move or they do!
Have visited many Johnnys in the Atlanta area. Since moving up to this part of the metro, visited this location many times and have enjoyed every visit.
Definitely gets the top rating of all we’ve been to, quality of food, speed of service and even known enough to have our soda choices brought by default without asking!
Magon is just great and very customer focused although with other servers we’ve had.
Pizza, salads...
Definitely gets the top rating of all we’ve been to, quality of food, speed of service and even known enough to have our soda choices brought by default without asking!
Magon is just great and very customer focused although with other servers we’ve had.
Pizza, salads...
You May Also Like
Frontera Mexican Kitchen - 4108 Hamilton Mill Rd
![]()
Mexican, Seafood, Burgers
Wendy's - 4100 S Bogan Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers