I Love NY Pizza & Wings

DO NOT ORDER FROM A SITE CALLED SLICE!! I mistakenly ordered from the wrong address since they do not show you the address, this store stole 28 dollars of my order and the customer help was absolutely no help whatsoever. They will steal your money with not even a scent of guilt.

Great little pizza shop. Had a 12 inch pepperoni and mushroom and spinach pizza. It was really good. Pizza dough is fresh and the pizza is made right in front of you. I'd definitely go back for the pizza.

I must have come on an off day. This location is set up mostly for take out. There are a few small tables to dine in. No slices served on the weekend. They weren’t rude but definitely not “extremely friendly”. Mediocre at best. Ordered a pizza that was ready within 15 minutes but served to us nuclear scalding hot. Better than cold I guess. Allow at least 10-15 to let cool off before even attempting to hold or put in your mouth. Stupid payment system asks you to leave a tip before you even know if the food/service is any good. Pizza was okay. Very thin & not quite as expected or like other locations of this local chain. Tiny drink cups & We were graced with one fork/knife for Stromboli which was also okay & scalding hot but not great or extraordinary in any way. Much better experiences at Johnnys & Many other choices out there. Also the price was a little high for the small portion sizes. Workers didn’t even say thank you or seem to give two sh!ts about customer service. 4/26/25.

Great service and food. Will definitely return and order again!

Average pizza-one time it was good the second time it was doughy and the toppings on the meat pizza were spread unevenly and the pepperoni barely had any pepperonis on it-

Love the pizza. Perfect crust and quality ingredients make it my go to pizza place!

Delicious wings and true NY style pizza!

Food is pretty good, toppings on a deluxe order are wayyy under done. To top it all of i was sold 2 lunch specials 2 slices w a drink for 7.95 and was told sorry, when I said hey what about our drinks? The machine is not working. Was told I didn't need a discount.. the food is sub par and the service was terrible. Guys on his phone and headphones on the whole time all my toppings came in a pile not spread out at all and we're under done.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

We are regulars now before a Friday night football game. Both the gluten-free and free regular pizza are great. We have recommended the pizza to friends, and they all agree that it is really good pizza. We have also ordered the garlic knots and salad & they are good. The family that owns it are the sweetest. The employees are like family & they all work together really well & care about your experience whether you eat there or takeout. Go check them out.

Dietary restrictions: Great gluten free pizza crust

Kid-friendliness: Families with any aged kids are welcome.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

The hype is real

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Small family business with great calzones and pizzas. They are always so nice and hospitable to all their guests. Best small business in Hickory flat

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing experience! Best part being our cashier Omer. He was polite, patient, suggested the lunch special when he saw we were struggling to decide and happily answered any questions we had. He then went and cooked our food and it looked like he was the only one working which he did not let effect his service as more guest walked in.The dining area was extremely clean and the food was well priced and quickly finished.Best garlic knots I've ever had and the calzone was delicious. My fiance and I both were not fans of the chicken we added to the pizza , it was not nasty, but did not work on the White Pesto Pizza. For us that just means I'm excited to go back and try a different kind of pizza !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: CYO Calzone, Garlic Knots

Clean, fast and quiet good. We tried the gyro and thought they were great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always top notch pizza and wings!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Ordered online for pickup today around lunchtime. They offered lunch deals, and this gyro and fries were $8.99. On the menu I originally read, it didn't list fries along with it. When I opened my box I was surprised. The gyro is a great size, packed with lettuce, tomato, red onion, feta, tzatziki and you choice or lamb or chicken. The lamb was seasoned well, juicy and super tender. The pita was soft and warm. Definitely worth the price. I did order an extra side of sauce. Will be back again to try the lunch calzone. Definitely try it out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5