Johnny's New York Style Pizza

True New Yorker here born and raised, tried this place tonight and unfortunately, Nothing about this place says New York. The dough was too thick, the sauce was chunky and the knots were tiny. Oh and the marinara had clumps of cheese in it … What the heck is going on? It almost reminded me of a frozen Red Barron pizza. Not good. First thing I noticed upon entering was there is no display cabinet to see all the pizza options like you see in every single pizzeria in New York and even New Jersey. I should have known it wasn’t gonna be good when it’s called Johnnys NY style pizza and subs! In NY it’s called a hero not a sub!! There were customers dining in but the place was eerily quiet. Definitely didn’t get the NY pizzeria vibes at all. The only half positive I have was that the staff members were friendly, though not interactive. Needless to say, I was very disappointed and will not be back to this location nor would I recommend it to anyone looking for NY style pizza. This place ain’t it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Great food and great service. Our family loves going to grab a bite to eat here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Seemingly no matter what time you walk in , how full/empty it is , or how many servers are working if you get your food in under 45 minutes it’s would be a miracle

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Homies n vibes don't allow the naysayers to persuade you to miss out IM FROM NEW YORK so I'll tell you as politely as I can how awesome my food always is PULL UP YO.

Ordered two large Johnny Deluxe and sub to go $79 ! Got them home , barely warm, toppings missing and piled in the middle of pizza. Only positive was the crust had good flavor. I doubt they would have served this if had been an inside order to someones table. Been years since we been to this location because its not that close. Won't be back.

Just left Buffalo Wild Wings across the street bc of bad service before we were even seated . Came over here and was not let down ! Service was quick and the great white pizza was awesome!!!!

Didn't get soda on a pick up order. I live too far away to go back

Food is good as always but don’t ask for a minute to look at what you want because you will be forgotten and have to wait for 30 minutes before someone finally acknowledges you and comes back.

I been coming here for lunch for about 6 months maybe like twice a month. I have given chance after chance because I honestly love pizza and it’s near my job. I have had to send me pizza back a couple times & I have NEVER felt welcome it’s more like tolerated. I can 2nd the other when she said non whites aren’t welcome there. The only reason I’m posting now is because this is what my pizza looked like when it came out but the table beside pizza looked fresh & good. I asked my waitress for a fresh slice… she took it back & showed the cook & said something (I couldn’t hear her) but I did hear the cook say out loud OF COURSE SHE CAN. The 2 slice was fresh but it’s clear they don’t want my business so I won’t be returning. And yes I wouldn’t recommend this restaurant to non white people.

Really enjoyed the salad and pizza. Service was outstanding

Margarita pizza was cold and completely burned and black on top . Very disappointing especially for the price

Food: 1

Such good pizza and food! We got pizza, their cauliflower crust, wings, salad and their garlic cheese bread. All are so delicious! Definitely a great pizza place. They also have a bar and sell by the slice

Dietary restrictions: Gf pizza offered

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Bread, Johnny's Deluxe, Johnny's New York Style Pizza, Greek Salad

Came in today. My Wife and I have been coming here since about 2015 or so. Has always been the best pizza around to us. Service is always excellent. The pizza today was not what I have wecome to expect. Flavor is a little off. I asked for extra sauce on my pizza and I got hardly any sauce if any at all. Did not put the pepperoni on my pizza as I asked And the waitress was very good as always and took it back to get the pepperoni put on. The barbecue chicken pizza barely had any sauce. That was the to go home orders. The Pizza was still good just not the same as it once was. Don't know what happened. Quality, Flavor, Consistency means a lot. My Wife had Chicken Alfredo and that is one of her favs and she asked me to taste it and it was way off. Something is definitely different from what we have been use to. I had Chicken Parmesan and it was Good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

The worst experience I've ever had at any Johnny's pizza!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great pizza!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza