Great food at moderate prices. We had the chicken parmegian and several pasta dishes and everyone in our party enjoyed the entrees...no issues. The ambiance is nice and even though the place was relatively full, the noise level was low and we could have a nice conversation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Griner
Decent Italian food. A must in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lasaundra Robinson
What an awesome meal I truly enjoyed this was my first time sitting down to eat at this restaurant A friend brought some home about 4 years ago and I have never been able to get to this restaurant why I don't know so glad I decided to come and sit down and enjoy the meal that I had it was amazing the service was top-notch that young lady was so sweet she even mixed my alcoholic drink for me because I was so undecided so she made me something really special and I thank her for that the tiramisu was amazing I took that home had it the next day the one thing that I did want to try I forgot to try and that was the Caesar salad so that means I will be back for Caesar salad and something special this was a great treat. treat yourself love yourself enjoy yourselves 08/08/2025 I came here tonight for dinner and I didn't remember to order the Caesar salad what a terrible mistake that was the salad was not very good at all to me the croutons were soft as butter the lettuce was wilted and the flavor was not great I'm a firm believer and not sending your food back to the kitchen because we all know what happens.... my spaghetti carbonara was awesome along with the sweet tea I did not get dessert this time outside of the horrible Caesar salad my mail did satisfy me wasn't the best service either but I guess you can't win them all one out of three isn't bad
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandi Denyse
DO NOT LET THE MESSY PIC FOOL YOU! My food had a rough trip home but OMG! I usually complain about Columbus not having any good food but I think I have found my new favorite spot. This eggplant Parmesan was sooooooooooo good! It was hot and fresh, the sauce the cheese THE EGGPLANT! So delicious and I will be back again.
Can’t wait to try some of the other dishes, especially the seafood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachelle Knight
OMG🤢🤢🤢I literally just walked out!! Been Craving Italian and searching in Columbus for just that! Found this little spot! Went there was greeted and seated promptly! Ordered a water and a Raspberry prosecco cocktail, and Fried Zucchini. Everything delivered promptly and looked great! Grab the salt and pepper and OUT CRAWLS A FREAKIN ROACH!!!! Right across the table!!! I just grabbed my purse and left! Told waitress and she just apologized!!! ABSOLUTLY UNACCEOTABLE!🤮🤮🤮🤮 Don’t waste your time!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
AAV AAV
Oh my goodness. The atmosphere, music, our waiter, coffee, and food was absolutely satisfying. I ordered the Ham panini. Husband ordered Alfredo, yum! Shrimp was so fresh. Waiter offered garlic bread while we waited, it was delicious. I’m a happy camper! Recommend 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Margarita Rivera
Not a good experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Robert Gettys
Excellent Italian cuisine at a moderate price. One of my go-to restaurants whenever I'm in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Wilcox
We had a really great experience tonight for our first time here! Our waitress was named Deborah and we loved her. She made sure that we were comfortable, checked in on us frequently, and was truly just so sweet and kind. We also really enjoyed the food that we got and felt like the portions were great. We are planning to go back and we’re happy that we heard of it and went to try it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina Allen
The average age of the clientele is 75+. Food was bland the canoli is not ricotta it's cream cheese and powdered sugar the shell is overcooked and it's generic hershes syrup on it ... The waitress couldn't make a drink to save her life and struggled to plopen a bottle of wine she had no idea what went where. The 18% auto gratuity is waaaaaayyyyy more than the waitress deserved. Honestly olive garden is better sadly. I say all of this this as someone with Italian heritage and who's lived in Italy. Oh oh oh and the lobster ravioli had no lobster in it or the sauce.
We got food poison. We'll I didn't, but my family did. We did get our money back, but unfortunately I won't be returning to Cafe Amici
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Lexus Demers
The loveliest little hole in the wall Italian spot in Columbus!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta Originale
Justin Fussell
Tried to dine at Caffe Amici last night at 830pm. Posted hours on the door, on the sidewalk, and online for closing were 930pm. We were told that the kitchen had last call already. No apologies. No questions. Nothing. The server walked away after informing me they were closed an hour early. Previous experiences at Caffe Amici have always been consistent and the food has always been superior. This interaction will certainly challenge my positive view of this restaurant. A simple apology that they’ve closed early would have been sufficient to make up for the disappointment.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Joanne Rainey
Caffe Amici is an authentic Italian restaurant! We ordered the chicken Alfredo, Francese, Toscano, and lasagna. Each dish was absolutely amazing! The service was top-notch! I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a real authentic Italian experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Nunya Bidnezz
We came for the day after Valentine's Day, and they were still running the Valentine's Special; which we definitely appreciated as we had to work on the day of. I had the Baked Oscar, and my Wife had the Chilean Sea Bass. We thought that the Oscar was a fish dish, and were perplexed that they might run 2 fish dishes and a pasta dish for the special.
Neither of us had had or heard of Baked Oscar before, and were pleasantly surprised when a Filet topped with lump crab meat, a bernaise sauce, mushrooms, and cooked to PERFECTION came instead of another type of fish dish. Looking it up, it's a Filet Mignon dish, named for a king of sweden or some such. Either way, the fella had dern giod taste, and the dish is also known as Steak Oscar sometimes.
Hilarious pleasant surprise and delicious food aside, the atmosphere here is pleasant, homey, and has the feel of upscale, without the actual upcharged price tag of paying to maintain the overpriced decor. :-D
The server was on point, didn't come too often did not ignore us either; a good balance on a very busy night, late in the evening.
Great food, great service, really nice atmosphere. WILL COME BACK!!! :-)
Great food at moderate prices. We had the chicken parmegian and several pasta dishes and everyone in our party enjoyed the entrees...no issues. The ambiance is nice and even though the place was relatively full, the noise level was low and we could have a nice conversation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent Italian food. A must in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What an awesome meal I truly enjoyed this was my first time sitting down to eat at this restaurant A friend brought some home about 4 years ago and I have never been able to get to this restaurant why I don't know so glad I decided to come and sit down and enjoy the meal that I had it was amazing the service was top-notch that young lady was so sweet she even mixed my alcoholic drink for me because I was so undecided so she made me something really special and I thank her for that the tiramisu was amazing I took that home had it the next day the one thing that I did want to try I forgot to try and that was the Caesar salad so that means I will be back for Caesar salad and something special this was a great treat. treat yourself love yourself enjoy yourselves
08/08/2025 I came here tonight for dinner and I didn't remember to order the Caesar salad what a terrible mistake that was the salad was not very good at all to me the croutons were soft as butter the lettuce was wilted and the flavor was not great I'm a firm believer and not sending your food back to the kitchen because we all know what happens.... my spaghetti carbonara was awesome along with the sweet tea I did not get dessert this time outside of the horrible Caesar salad my mail did satisfy me wasn't the best service either but I guess you can't win them all one out of three isn't bad
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DO NOT LET THE MESSY PIC FOOL YOU! My food had a rough trip home but OMG! I usually complain about Columbus not having any good food but I think I have found my new favorite spot. This eggplant Parmesan was sooooooooooo good! It was hot and fresh, the sauce the cheese THE EGGPLANT! So delicious and I will be back again.
Can’t wait to try some of the other dishes, especially the seafood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
OMG🤢🤢🤢I literally just walked out!!
Been Craving Italian and searching in Columbus for just that! Found this little spot! Went there was greeted and seated promptly! Ordered a water and a Raspberry prosecco cocktail, and Fried Zucchini. Everything delivered promptly and looked great! Grab the salt and pepper and OUT CRAWLS A FREAKIN ROACH!!!! Right across the table!!! I just grabbed my purse and left! Told waitress and she just apologized!!! ABSOLUTLY UNACCEOTABLE!🤮🤮🤮🤮
Don’t waste your time!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Oh my goodness. The atmosphere, music, our waiter, coffee, and food was absolutely satisfying. I ordered the Ham panini. Husband ordered Alfredo, yum! Shrimp was so fresh. Waiter offered garlic bread while we waited, it was delicious. I’m a happy camper! Recommend 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not a good experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Excellent Italian cuisine at a moderate price. One of my go-to restaurants whenever I'm in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a really great experience tonight for our first time here! Our waitress was named Deborah and we loved her. She made sure that we were comfortable, checked in on us frequently, and was truly just so sweet and kind. We also really enjoyed the food that we got and felt like the portions were great. We are planning to go back and we’re happy that we heard of it and went to try it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The average age of the clientele is 75+. Food was bland the canoli is not ricotta it's cream cheese and powdered sugar the shell is overcooked and it's generic hershes syrup on it ... The waitress couldn't make a drink to save her life and struggled to plopen a bottle of wine she had no idea what went where. The 18% auto gratuity is waaaaaayyyyy more than the waitress deserved. Honestly olive garden is better sadly. I say all of this this as someone with Italian heritage and who's lived in Italy. Oh oh oh and the lobster ravioli had no lobster in it or the sauce.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We got food poison. We'll I didn't, but my family did. We did get our money back, but unfortunately I won't be returning to Cafe Amici
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
The loveliest little hole in the wall Italian spot in Columbus!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta Originale
Tried to dine at Caffe Amici last night at 830pm. Posted hours on the door, on the sidewalk, and online for closing were 930pm. We were told that the kitchen had last call already. No apologies. No questions. Nothing. The server walked away after informing me they were closed an hour early. Previous experiences at Caffe Amici have always been consistent and the food has always been superior. This interaction will certainly challenge my positive view of this restaurant. A simple apology that they’ve closed early would have been sufficient to make up for the disappointment.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Caffe Amici is an authentic Italian restaurant! We ordered the chicken Alfredo, Francese, Toscano, and lasagna. Each dish was absolutely amazing! The service was top-notch! I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a real authentic Italian experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came for the day after Valentine's Day, and they were still running the Valentine's Special; which we definitely appreciated as we had to work on the day of. I had the Baked Oscar, and my Wife had the Chilean Sea Bass. We thought that the Oscar was a fish dish, and were perplexed that they might run 2 fish dishes and a pasta dish for the special.
Neither of us had had or heard of Baked Oscar before, and were pleasantly surprised when a Filet topped with lump crab meat, a bernaise sauce, mushrooms, and cooked to PERFECTION came instead of another type of fish dish. Looking it up, it's a Filet Mignon dish, named for a king of sweden or some such. Either way, the fella had dern giod taste, and the dish is also known as Steak Oscar sometimes.
Hilarious pleasant surprise and delicious food aside, the atmosphere here is pleasant, homey, and has the feel of upscale, without the actual upcharged price tag of paying to maintain the overpriced decor. :-D
The server was on point, didn't come too often did not ignore us either; a good balance on a very busy night, late in the evening.
Great food, great service, really nice atmosphere. WILL COME BACK!!! :-)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad
Loading...