Soo good! It was our first time. I got the Oreo Mudpie and it was delicious. I love the concept of mixing Italian ice and ice cream.I look forward to going back and getting different flavors and varieties. The girl who served us was so sweet and kind and patient to help me sample flavors.I definitely recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clara Lee
Standard ice cream options, nothing exceptional. Provides the standard choices.
Jessica T
I really really wanted to go here because I’m from New York and I really miss Italian icy’s and we were in the area for my daughters birthday weekend but I couldn’t find it. They had no signs we went to the right location but we had no idea where they were. They had no signs to advertise which building to go in. They had no signs to say hey we’re here it was night time so it wasn’t like we could really see much so we ended up just leaving.
Ms. K
What a cute little place to grab a treat! Its located downtown, pretty much the sweet spot of Columbus. I ordered a small S’more’s cup with chocolate ice, cookie butter, ice cream swirl, and Biscoff cookie butter crumbles. I’ve never had anything similar to this sort of ice cream/shaved ice desserts and it really works! The flavors were really different and the Biscoff cookie crumbles were my favorite part! I recently moved and there’s actually a location here as well! Highly recommend!
NOS Nero
It's such a shame. I've spent hundreds at this location and tip every single time, but they won't see another dime from me. I asked for a sample today for the first time ever after years of patronage. The dude reacted like I had asked him for the shirt off his back and told me they are not allowed to, which is a bold faced lie. Employees always have had an attitude as if they're working for free, but I never expected service that poor.
savana snow
Perfect treat! Especially for a hott summer day!
angiecole
My granddaughter got food poisoning and had to be rushed to the emergency room after eating the strawberry shortcake cake gelati. The doctor said they get a lot of food poisoning victims from this establishment. Not sure how the city allows them to stay in business.
Kimberly Pendergrass
We walked the river front and were hot so we went to Jeremiah's to cool off and get some Italian Ice. It was very good. It a neat place that it's located in. We were from out of town and enjoyed sitting at a table talking and cooling off. If we'd know about the different restaurants we'd probably waited to eat lunch till we got there. There are several different kinds of restaurants in the building. We'll be back to try some!!
Casper The Friendly Ghost Writer
Really really good soft serve ice cream. Not a fan personally of Italian ice, but prices are fair and if it is your jam, it is well made.
Crystal Mims
It was very good and the customer service was awesome. So many flavors to choose from. Go ahead and try it.
definitely will come again!!! employees are absolutely top tier and welcoming!! orane and cream sicle was delicious!!
alma moore
Super delicious. Their ice cream is so rich and creamy. The Italian ice is cold, sweet and packed with flavor. My favorite combo was the lemon and mango flavor.
Mrs. Lester
So delicious! The best dessert and very friendly employees.
vanessuh
After whitewater rafting we had lunch in the food hall followed by some icecream here. It was an excellent choice for dessert, able to be enjoyed outdoors on some rocking chairs. I personally love cookies and cream and asked for extra crumbles, YUM!
Soo good! It was our first time. I got the Oreo Mudpie and it was delicious. I love the concept of mixing Italian ice and ice cream.I look forward to going back and getting different flavors and varieties. The girl who served us was so sweet and kind and patient to help me sample flavors.I definitely recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Standard ice cream options, nothing exceptional. Provides the standard choices.
I really really wanted to go here because I’m from New York and I really miss Italian icy’s and we were in the area for my daughters birthday weekend but I couldn’t find it. They had no signs we went to the right location but we had no idea where they were. They had no signs to advertise which building to go in. They had no signs to say hey we’re here it was night time so it wasn’t like we could really see much so we ended up just leaving.
What a cute little place to grab a treat! Its located downtown, pretty much the sweet spot of Columbus. I ordered a small S’more’s cup with chocolate ice, cookie butter, ice cream swirl, and Biscoff cookie butter crumbles. I’ve never had anything similar to this sort of ice cream/shaved ice desserts and it really works! The flavors were really different and the Biscoff cookie crumbles were my favorite part! I recently moved and there’s actually a location here as well! Highly recommend!
It's such a shame. I've spent hundreds at this location and tip every single time, but they won't see another dime from me. I asked for a sample today for the first time ever after years of patronage. The dude reacted like I had asked him for the shirt off his back and told me they are not allowed to, which is a bold faced lie. Employees always have had an attitude as if they're working for free, but I never expected service that poor.
Perfect treat! Especially for a hott summer day!
My granddaughter got food poisoning and had to be rushed to the emergency room after eating the strawberry shortcake cake gelati. The doctor said they get a lot of food poisoning victims from this establishment. Not sure how the city allows them to stay in business.
We walked the river front and were hot so we went to Jeremiah's to cool off and get some Italian Ice. It was very good. It a neat place that it's located in. We were from out of town and enjoyed sitting at a table talking and cooling off. If we'd know about the different restaurants we'd probably waited to eat lunch till we got there. There are several different kinds of restaurants in the building. We'll be back to try some!!
Really really good soft serve ice cream. Not a fan personally of Italian ice, but prices are fair and if it is your jam, it is well made.
It was very good and the customer service was awesome. So many flavors to choose from. Go ahead and try it.
Restaurantji Recommends
definitely will come again!!! employees are absolutely top tier and welcoming!! orane and cream sicle was delicious!!
Super delicious. Their ice cream is so rich and creamy. The Italian ice is cold, sweet and packed with flavor. My favorite combo was the lemon and mango flavor.
So delicious! The best dessert and very friendly employees.
After whitewater rafting we had lunch in the food hall followed by some icecream here. It was an excellent choice for dessert, able to be enjoyed outdoors on some rocking chairs. I personally love cookies and cream and asked for extra crumbles, YUM!
Great flavors of ice cream. Worth a try once.