3443 Macon Rd, Columbus
I had to try this out after seeing someone mention it on Facebook. Food was pretty good but drinks was strong as hell. Half a cup was enough for me. Lol
I cannot begin to express how amazing this place is!! Food is PHENOMENAL and the customer service is out of this world! I got the Cajun Pasta this visit and this dish in general is my ultimate favorite. But here, this was the best I’ve ever had! Not overly spicy and seasoned to perfection. I come here with my Dad when he comes for a visit from Pittsburgh. We love it!!
Very friendly staff make you feel like family. Would recommend any day of the week. Very good food and service.
This place was very surprising to find in Columbus! I have yet to find too many places that I want to return to in here but my daughter and I absolutely fell in love. The pizza was fantastic, service was great, vibe was amazing and I cannot wait to go back!
The food was phenomenal and our waitress was nice and knowledgeable. However, we were seated and a lady came to take our drink order. We were seated in the first long table by the front doors and couldn’t see the back wall where the beer specials are. My husband asked about the beer specials and I kid you not she replied “they’re on the back wall” which we can’t see. So I said you really want us to get and walk back there to look and she replied “yeah because I don’t know wha
We brought a group of 30 people to Mr. Pizza tonight and had a fantastic experience! I called a few days before, and Willie (the General Manager) let us know that he would have tables set aside for us. We ordered several of the Family Specials and the food was delicious! Best pizza I've had in a long time. Thanks to Mary for the incredible service! We will definitely be back.
My boyfriend and I were seared immediately after walking in. Waited 20+ minutes and no one even came to our table or got our drinks. Another table (A 6 top) was seated maybe 5 minutes after us, without their party complete, and the entire party arrived and had drinks before we gave up on the waiting game. Can’t say we’ll be back ??♀️ The pizza looked delicious, if you’re ever able to get service.
Loved this Place and the Staff was super friendly and made us feel like we were locals !!!! We had the pizza and it was delicious and the ingredients you could tell were top quality, and cooked to perfection Will highly recommend and will be back
I took my five grandchildren to this restaurant and there was a nice variety for them to choose from. One had the spaghetti, one the panini style grilled cheese and fries, shrimp Alfredo for one, another opted for the chicken Alfredo, and the last one chose a personal size pepperoni pizza. They were ALL happy with their choices. I had the chicken Alfredo and Caesar salad and was not unhappy. Although the Alfredo sauce was over penne pasta, it was still enjoyable taste-wise, visually, texturally, and there was the right consistency and amount of sauce. It could have used a tiny bit more flavor, but this could be because of my considering what I love about my own homemade sauce. I really like their buttery toasted bread which accompanied the meals. We also ordered their version of a thin meat lover's pizza, and it was also very good. Our server, Ms. Mary, was attentive and very friendly. I have no reservations at this time in recommending them.
This is our fav pizza place in Columbus and the surrounding area. It also has great appetizers and a happy hour menu with beer specials that no where can compare. The staff is super friendly and the owner/manager is always walking around checking in on how everything was and I'm sure if there were any problems he would fix them but our food is always superb. We bring family and friends that visit here and they agree too and it's our perfect dinner and movie night at home take out also. 100% recommend. You won't be disappointed. Last week I went there twice in one day!
We will definitely return to Mr. Pizza. We saw a commercial on the local channel 3. My granddaughter loves pizza so I told her we’d try a new pizza. The waitress was very welcoming. I was ordering takeout. The waitress made menu suggestions. The pizza was delicious. We really enjoyed the freshness of the pizza ingredients. Simply delicious. We will definitely be a returning customer. A little pricey but well worth it. So so Good...
Great place to get really good pizza.
Ok, here's the deal. Was in here a couple weeks ago. Was craving pizza and it was happy hour. Started with a cold and tasty and priced right draft. Had a salad to get started - pretty good start, fabulous dressing and cold and crisp greens. Ordered a large pizza, figuring after the beer and salad would take some home. Bingo! That pie was huge and we could not manage eating half. Now for the good part - absolutely the best leftover pizza I have ever had. As in the restaurant, the crust was divine and the sauce was slap your tongue on the top of your mouth impeccable. Going back soon, positive I'll order more than I can eat Part II - Back I for lunch today. Destiny was our waitress and she did an excellent job. We had the lunch specials that included a side salad. The salads were big. My Caesar was superb, her house was great with the Italian dressing. She had the Brick Italian sandwich that was loaded with meats and cheese and topped with ample portions of tomatoes, lettuce and red onions. It came with fabulous fries - crispy and flavorful. My lasagna was really good and came with a wonderful garlic bread. The draft Peroni made for a spectacular meal.
Pizza is good, thin crust with a little crunch, not too saucy. Clean relaxing atmosphere. Management is great!!! They went above expectations to make our group satisfied. We'd go back!!
I'm quite the pizza enthusiast and love to check out new spots. Some of the shows that I like to watch are the Pizza Show on Youtube and David Portnoy's Pizza reviews! I browsed through Yelp and saw this establishment and decided to order a 16" cheese pizza to go as I believe a plain slice will show whether or not it's a quality pie. I picked up the pizza and left in a hurry to eat the pie with a friend who was just as excited as I was. The pizza had a good crust, but not much crunch. It was a little more greasy than it should have been but that's ok. It had a distinct, tangy sauce which was not too sweet. Overall it was a decent pie. Here's the disappointing part. The pizza came in a box the same size as Papa John's Extra Large boxes but the pizza was way too small to be a 16" pizza. I'm only referencing Papa John's for size and not taste. It's $14 for a plain cheese pie. It's not breaking the bank but it's not exactly cheap. The pie came out to be around 14" which might not seem like a lot until you do the math, which I'll spare you the details. What's the deal? I'd love to come here again and leave a quality review but it's not worth it if I'm going to get a 14" pie for the price of a 16". I posted a picture of 16" Papa John's pie for reference. The 2 boxes are the same size.
The garden pizza and mozzarella sticks were fabulous. Not authentic Italian by any means, but if you are looking for some good ole American style pizza- this is the best place in Columbus to come. The veggies were finely chopped, the crust was good, and there was a perfect amount of cheese! Service was friendly.
Absolutely delicious! Had a great dinner. Thought it was incredible. The cooks were awesome . Mary did a great job. I will be back. My wife and I loved it will and we will be back soon!!!!!
Had a wonderful time eating at this place! Great service by Mary and delicious food by the chefs. Definitely eating here again!
The pizza was amazing. I had the margarita pizza loved it. When our group of 11 went there were only 2 servers so a tad bit slow but we didn't mind to much. Other than that everyone loved it!
I will definitely be returning. The food was amazing and the service was outstanding. Audrey was a great waitress and a good listener. She was so positive and welcoming the whole time. She really made my day. You can tell that she really loves her job because she went above and beyond.
Joel is such a wonderful server! If you're ever in the area stop by and ask for him! He was so kind to my friend and I depsite us taking awhile to order. It was our first time at My Pizza and we were delighted to say we'll be back. Awesome food and great atmosphere :)
Great pizza and calm atmosphere. Not too busy, even at 6pm on a Friday. Service was prompt, waitress was professional and patient. Myself and three others were greeted by a kind gentleman upon arrival. First stop for food since arriving to Georgia and I can't complain about anything about this place. Keep it up!
Best pizza ever! We were in town for family day and ate here twice it was so good! Perfect family restaurant!
This place is great. From atmosphere, to food, to drinks, to staff. I've been here a few times now and it's always a 5/5 star experience. And that's honestly because of people like Audrey at the bar. She always has the best smile and attitude. You can get a drink anywhere, but not everyone makes you feel at home like she does. I'll be back again for sure.
Mary was an outstanding waitress and came back to check on us multiple times. I’ve eaten here religiously since they have opened and they never fail to make outstanding food. I would highly recommend coming to eat here!
Surprisingly affordable for the level of excellence they provide. Their lunchtime specials are great. The wings are amazing. The pizza is fantastic. If I continue, I'll run out of big words before running out of good things to say.
Just okay. Pizza crust tasted weird, don't know how to describe it. Wings were good and big, needed more sauce. Management was nice and checked up on us.
All you can eat pizza and spaghetti as part of a private event. yummy. Ran out of hungry and brought leftovers home.
Awesome staff great food. My job had a meeting and about 15 co workers came out and the food and service was awesome. Plenty of different types of beers to drink. I highly recommend this location.
The pizza, the Alfredo, and the chocolate cake were delicious! The atmosphere is super cute too. The manager walked over a few times to check that we were doing and good and was very friendly and polite. I’d recommend asking for the server Joel because he rocked! We’ll be back!
Amazing staff and food. Everyone was so polite and helpful! The owner came over to talk and laugh with us more than once! 10/10 recommendation! Also very supportive and appreciative of my brother whose in the army.
First time and was satisfied with service and food. Personal pizza and salad was a good value combination. Choices were regular or thin crust. Had the regular crust and it was very good. Only down side was the menu only had personal pan size pizzas for pizza choices. Definitely worth another visit to check out other menu items.
First time in Georgia visiting from California. Our son is in the Army and he said he was dying to have pizza. We wanted to take him to a nice pizza place with good food and they did not disappoint. The pizza was delicious and the service was excellent! Such nice friendly staff and they made us feel at home and even thanked my son for his services! The place is also very clean and modern. If your in town I definitely would recommend. We will be back for graduation next month :)
Excellent food at a great price. The service is exceptional and friendly. I went to place a to go order and it was ready in about 10 minutes. Great place for pizza. An added bonus is that Willie from Deorio's works there and has several recipes that he brought over. I highly recommend eating here.
This place has awesome pizza. Prices are a little high but worth it for the quality of food that you get. I will definitely go back.
We've lived here for ten months and this was our first time visiting here. I don't know what I was thinking because this place was awesome!!! Very reasonable prices, the staff was very friendly and on point. Pizza was done perfectly as well as seasoned perfectly, nice crisp. zucchini salad was super good, (my three yr old ordered that, haha) She also got the spaghetti and meatballs, which did not disappoint!
The service here is great. Love that the owner engages with the customers. He really cares about the guest experience. The pizza is very good. Can't wait to go back!
Throughout our travels we have never come across a place like this. The food was excellent, the spirits were great and most of all, the STAFF is freakin AWESOME! We will always come back when we are here.
I am only going to give this place four stars. I do not like that the way the taps are set up. I would have to get up and walk around to see what other drafts they have on tap. The food is not bad 12 inch is decent no grease I like that. Spot on I will come back just make easier to drink beer.
The restaurant is stylish and extremely clean! The servers are enthusiastic and accommodating and it’s very open with an amazing bar area!
3443 Macon Rd, Columbus, GA 31907