A gem in Columbus. Healthy options, great ingredients, top notch service!
Meghan Sanchez
Jane is the BEST. Ask for the pear martini (not on the menu, but best drink EVER) you won't be disappointed! Their seasonal veggies are also my fav, love the sun dried tomatoes in them.
Ian Vink
Excellent meal! Would recommend
Graham Cline
Mason is a fantastic bartender. Jamie is a wonderful manager. The food was phenomenal. It was our first time being there and we will definitely be back. Wonderful experience all around. Thank you!
Megan Costanza
I would have enjoyed another glass of wine, however, barely finishing my meal the check was presented. I could have definitely been upsold wine, maybe even desert to just enjoy and relax. Missed opportunity. On my part to relax and theirs on business sales. Server was gracious, atmosphere is great, a little loud if looking for calm atmosphere such as MaBellas.
Daniel Austin
Had a great experience. The drinks were made strong and brought quickly. The raw oysters tasted fresh and started the meal off right. We had the special (redfish w/ corn puree, Brussels) and the crab cakes and everything tasted amazing. Finished it off with a banana cheesecake which was a great finale. Overall a good experience, paying the downtown tax but I’d say a meal here is worth it - almost on par with Mabella’s.
Gregory Flewellen
Service was slow
Anthony Guerrera
One of the best steaks I've ever tasted. Cooked perfect and seasoned well with still having a great natural steak flavor
Jamie Stovall
We have always loveddddd Salt Cellar but this time felt completely different. The menu changed (maybe that’s not recent but definitely different than the last time we visited), the same pasta we always order was subpar, and the service felt like we were being rushed out. Our specific server was incredibly rude when we asked to just enjoy a drink and app instead of immediately ordering (hence we know the food comes out fast so we didn’t want to rush our dinner with family in town). It was an off putting experience compared to our normal trips there! Would definitely make me rethink visiting again, specially when hosting people in town.
Scott Fitzgerald
One of the best ribeyes I have ever had at a restaurant.
My husband brought me here for our wedding anniversary 2 months ago and we've already been back twice. I ordered the Filet Medallions and they were cooked to perfection. I cleaned the plate. I was recommended the Banana Pudding Cheesecake and it was the best cheesecake I've ever had in my entire life...and I've had a lot of cheesecake. It keeps us coming back so I hope they never take it off the menu. The wait staff was efficient and friendly. We've sat at the bar a few times and all the bartenders are very knowledgeable and friendly as well. I would recommend Salt Cellar to anyone who wants to go out for a great meal, or just drinks and a dessert. We will back.
Ty Fodor
The ribeye was very good
Brianna Vastine
Atmosphere is good. Food was bland, several things like the mashed potatoes had no seasoning, and my scallops were undercooked. Service was subpar with us consistently waiting for an exorbitant amount of time. Would not recommend. For the price point I expected way more.
arthur taylor
Saltcellar was awesome but Jamie, the manager, made all the difference. Service is everything for me and her and the staff nailed it! On top of it the oysters and salmon hit the spot.
Patricia Hugle
I was invited with a friend...we were served appetizers and a beverage....wonderful food...got to look at the menu...reasonably priced..nice atmosphere
A gem in Columbus. Healthy options, great ingredients, top notch service!
Jane is the BEST. Ask for the pear martini (not on the menu, but best drink EVER) you won't be disappointed! Their seasonal veggies are also my fav, love the sun dried tomatoes in them.
Excellent meal! Would recommend
Mason is a fantastic bartender. Jamie is a wonderful manager. The food was phenomenal. It was our first time being there and we will definitely be back. Wonderful experience all around. Thank you!
I would have enjoyed another glass of wine, however, barely finishing my meal the check was presented. I could have definitely been upsold wine, maybe even desert to just enjoy and relax. Missed opportunity. On my part to relax and theirs on business sales. Server was gracious, atmosphere is great, a little loud if looking for calm atmosphere such as MaBellas.
Had a great experience. The drinks were made strong and brought quickly. The raw oysters tasted fresh and started the meal off right. We had the special (redfish w/ corn puree, Brussels) and the crab cakes and everything tasted amazing. Finished it off with a banana cheesecake which was a great finale. Overall a good experience, paying the downtown tax but I’d say a meal here is worth it - almost on par with Mabella’s.
Service was slow
One of the best steaks I've ever tasted. Cooked perfect and seasoned well with still having a great natural steak flavor
We have always loveddddd Salt Cellar but this time felt completely different. The menu changed (maybe that’s not recent but definitely different than the last time we visited), the same pasta we always order was subpar, and the service felt like we were being rushed out. Our specific server was incredibly rude when we asked to just enjoy a drink and app instead of immediately ordering (hence we know the food comes out fast so we didn’t want to rush our dinner with family in town). It was an off putting experience compared to our normal trips there! Would definitely make me rethink visiting again, specially when hosting people in town.
One of the best ribeyes I have ever had at a restaurant.
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband brought me here for our wedding anniversary 2 months ago and we've already been back twice. I ordered the Filet Medallions and they were cooked to perfection. I cleaned the plate. I was recommended the Banana Pudding Cheesecake and it was the best cheesecake I've ever had in my entire life...and I've had a lot of cheesecake. It keeps us coming back so I hope they never take it off the menu. The wait staff was efficient and friendly. We've sat at the bar a few times and all the bartenders are very knowledgeable and friendly as well. I would recommend Salt Cellar to anyone who wants to go out for a great meal, or just drinks and a dessert. We will back.
The ribeye was very good
Atmosphere is good. Food was bland, several things like the mashed potatoes had no seasoning, and my scallops were undercooked. Service was subpar with us consistently waiting for an exorbitant amount of time. Would not recommend. For the price point I expected way more.
Saltcellar was awesome but Jamie, the manager, made all the difference. Service is everything for me and her and the staff nailed it! On top of it the oysters and salmon hit the spot.
I was invited with a friend...we were served appetizers and a beverage....wonderful food...got to look at the menu...reasonably priced..nice atmosphere
Loading...