Great American Cookies
840 Glynn St S #368, Fayetteville
(770) 731-2800
Limited Time Only
Pumpkin Spice Cookie
A fall favorite with pumpkin, brown sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, and white chocolate chips topped with powdered sugar.
Caramel Churro Cookie
NEW fall cookie with a delightful combination of caramel and cinnamon sugar crunch.
Pumpkin Spice Latte Ice Cream
Our classic Pumpkin Spice Latte Ice Cream is made fresh with pumpkin, coffee, and cinnamon flavors.
Pumpkin Spice Latte Shake
Pumpkin Spice Latte Ice Cream mixed with caramel, fudge, and chocolate chips.
Everyday Occasions
Happy Birthday!
Available in 16" round Original Chocolate Chip only. Message will appear as shown. For more Cookie Cake design options available for delivery, please visit www.greatamericancookies.com
I Love You
Available in 16" round Original Chocolate Chip only. Message will appear as shown. For more Cookie Cake design options available for delivery, please visit www.greatamericancookies.com
Thanks!
Available in 16" round Original Chocolate Chip only. Message will appear as shown. For more Cookie Cake design options available for delivery, please visit www.greatamericancookies.com
Get Well Soon
Available in 16" round Original Chocolate Chip only. Message will appear as shown. For more Cookie Cake design options available for delivery, please visit www.greatamericancookies.com
Congrats!
Available in 16" round Original Chocolate Chip only. Message will appear as shown. For more Cookie Cake design options available for delivery, please visit www.greatamericancookies.com
We'll Miss You
Available in 16" round Original Chocolate Chip only. Message will appear as shown. For more Cookie Cake design options available for delivery, please visit www.greatamericancookies.com
Birthday
Princess Crown - B1028
Birthday BBall - B1039
1st Birthday - B1025
Butterflies - B1006
Princess Cake- B1019
Balloons - B1030
Forever 29 - B1038
Dude, You're OLD - B1041
Guitar - B1026
Island - B1013
Dinosaur - B1005
Painter Birthday- B1032
Sports
Football Field - S3504
Score Basketball - S3509
Go Team Helmet - S3506
Goal! - S3505
Football Fever! - S3503
Great Season - S3502
Work Occasions
Boss Latte - O4050
Happy Boss's Day Pennant - O4051
Happy Boss's Day - O4027
Happy Boss's Day Ribbon - O4046
Best Boss Ever - O4047
Happy Nurse's Day - O4022
You're The Best! - O4011
Halloween
Happy Halloween Cat Ghost Candy Corn - HF2574
Have a Creepy Halloween - HF2575
Ice Cream
ICE CREAM CUPS
Our small batch Ice Cream, made fresh in-store daily. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
HAND-PACKED PINTS
Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
HAND-PACKED QUARTS
Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
Classic Favorites
ROCKY ROAD
Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Mini Marshmallows & Mixed Nuts.
COOKIE DOUGH SURPRISE
Birthday Cake Ice Cream, Cookie Dough, Oreo® Cookie Pieces & Fudge Topping.
CHOCOLATE CARAMEL BUTTER PECAN
Butter Pecan Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, Pecans & Caramel Topping.
COTTON CANDY CARNIVAL
Cotton Candy Ice Cream, Mini M&M's®, Mini Marshmallows & Mallo Creme.
COOKIES & CREAM
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Oreo® Cookie Pieces & Mallo Creme.
STRAWBERRY CARAMEL CHEESECAKE
Cheesecake Ice Cream, Strawberries, Graham Crackers & Caramel Topping.
Ice Cream Cakes
SPRINKLE
There's gold at the bottom of this rainbow and it's mouthwatering yellow cake with Vanilla Ice Cream. Then, it's covered with rainbow sprinkles for a party on every plate.
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE
How could this classic get any more delicious? We've added Birthday Cake Ice Cream, Vanilla Ice Cream and strawberry puree to a yellow cake base, and then topped it with vanilla frosting and fresh strawberries. Trust us, it's shortcake they'll be talking about for a long time.
CLASSIC COOKIES N' CREAM
Move over cookies and milk - this scrumptious chocolate cake has Sweet Cream® Ice Cream and Oreo® cookie mix-ins topped with even more Oreo® cookies. It's a cookie-tastic classic.
Cookies & Brownies (GAC) Silver/Revel
Cookie Cake by the Slice
A slice of our signature Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake topped with your choice of chocolate or vanilla icing.
Regular Cookies
Double Doozies®
The Double Doozie® is made with our delectable icing sandwiched between your favorite cookies.
Brownies
Shakes
CREATE YOUR OWN SHAKE
Create your own Ice Cream Shake. Choose your favorite Ice Cream and Mix-Ins like fruit, candy bars, fudge, cookies, nuts, and more.
COOKIE SHAKE
Create your own Ice Cream Cookie Shake. Choose your favorite Ice Cream and your favorite Cookie and blend to perfection!
COOKIES & CREAM SHAKE
Hershey's® chocolate swirl, Oreo® cookie pieces, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and crushed Oreo® cookies.
SNICKERS SHAKE
Caramel swirl, Snickers®, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream, Hershey's® chocolate syrup, and crushed Snickers ® bar.
COTTON CANDY SHAKE
Marshmallow cream swirl and Blue Cotton Candy Ice Cream topped with whip cream and mini M&M's®.
STRAWBERRY SHAKE
Marshmallow cream swirl and Strawberry Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and garnished with a strawberry.
COFFEE SHAKE
Hershey's® chocolate swirl, Sweet Cream Ice Cream and coffee mixture topped with whipped cream and Hershey's® chocolate syrup.
Sundaes
Strawberry Cheesecake Brownie Sundae
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE SUNDAE
Sweet Cream Ice Cream, yellow cake pieces, and strawberry syrup, topped with whipped cream and fresh strawberries.
FUDGE BROWNIE SUNDAE
Vanilla Ice Cream with fudge brownie pieces and fudge, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
BANANA SPLIT SUNDAE
Traditional Banana split served with Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry Ice Cream with hot fudge, caramel, and marshmallow cream; topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
COOKIE SUNDAE
Delicious layers of Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Original Chocolate Chip Cookie, garnished with Fudge Sauce and Whipped Cream.
CLASSIC SUNDAE
Vanilla ice cream with choice of fudge or caramel, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
Take and Decorate Kits
Create Your Own Kit
Get creative. Then eat it. Our Take & Decorate Kits provide a fun, icing-filled blank Cookie canvas of creativity from birthday parties to rainy day activities. Kit includes 6 or 12 cut-out cookies, made from our Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake, icing, and decorating candies for you to take home and let the magic begin. *decorating candies and icing colors vary by location.
Create Your Own Cake Kit
Get creative. Then eat it. Our Take & Decorate Cookie Cake Kits provide a fun, icing-filled blank Cookie Cake canvas of creativity from birthday parties to rainy day activities. Kit includes one Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake, icing, and decorating candies for you to take home and let the magic begin. *decorating candies and icing colors vary by location.
Special Occasion & Thank You
Brighten Your Day! Rainbow - O4017
Thanks A Latte - O4040
Yellow Ribbon - O4010
Get Well Flowers - O4005
Prom? - O4024
Baby
Welcome Baby - O4004
Beverages (GAC/MSC) Silver/Revel
Bottled Beverages
Thanksgiving & Fall
Thankful and Grateful - HF2656
Turkey Happy Thanksgiving - HF2654
Happy Fall Pumpkins - HF2561
Let's Kickoff the Season Football - S3510
School & Grad
Back To The Books - S3402
Back to School - S3404
We Love Elementary - S3405
Summer & Patriotic
US Flag - HS2502
Photos
+48 photos
+47 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This store was fantastic!!! I ordered a cookie cake from the Peachtree city location, and it turned out HORRIBLE!! PTC would not do anything about it nor refund me, so I called the Fayetteville store in a panic to get the right cookie cake next day, and they were able to fit me in! The manager, Azim, was great to deal with and made sure that everything was taken care of! I highly recommend!
August 2024
Their cookies are delicious. My favorite is the original chocolate chip but I also love when they sell cookie scraps. Cookie scraps are the leftover cuttings from the cookie cakes. Only reason for not giving it 5 stars is because of the price.
September 2023
The customer service, the ice cream, and the cookies are always Excellent at this location. I love the fact that place is always spotless with an inviting smell. Cleanliness is so important during in the wake of Covid. My go to ice cream spot!
July 2021
You May Also Like
Marble Slab Creamery - 840 Glynn St S #368
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Juice Bar & Smoothies
My Lifestyle Smoothie - 840 Glynn St S #354
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Zaxby's Chicken Fingers & Buffalo Wings - 130 Hwy 92
![]()
Chicken, Fast Food, Chicken Wings, Salad