Johnny's New York Style Pizza

230 Glynn St N, Fayetteville
(770) 461-4225

Recent Reviews

Sort by
emma wilson

I dined in earlier this week with my family and the food was spectacular! Calzones and appetizers were amazing, and the customer service we received from Bella was out of this world! She was so sweet and knowledgeable, she knows the menu well and answered all of our questions with ease. They have a good selection of draft beers as well. Will be returning. Thanks Johnnys & Bella!

Food Person

This place always gives me a weird vibe, and my pizza tasted like a cheeseburger with some taco ingredients.

Yolanda Morris

I think this is the best in this area It reminds me of NYC pizza. And they offer military discount, thx Johnny's.

LaQuita Parks

Always love this place. Never disappoints.

Jack

Great pizza! Choose over other local options!

Bob Nicksic

Take out pizza was made incorrectly, which was caught by the server. They offered to remake it, which I accepted, but they significantly overcooked it, which I didn't discover until I got home. They did comp me an order of fries.

Green Spree

Our experience with the Calzone was a little too salty this time. I have never tasted so much salt or garlic salt on our Calzones. Must be different Chef tonight. May 30, 2025

Calen Farmer

Best pizza in Fayetteville!! Great staff as well!! Can't wait to go back

dvezia

Good but not enough cheese!

lisa scott

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Im Python

Great service, and amazing food everything came out on time and was perfectly made!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Slice of Pizza, Cauliflower Crust

Maui 1

Great Pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Taren Symone

Food is always fresh and service is 10/10! I love the lunch specials and the selection of wine they have. This is my go-to spot every day of the week.

Sweet Proverbs

Longest time I had to wait for a dine in pizza. They do not serve all customers the same.

Luke Fryer

Pizza was Great. Staff was cheerful and the Service was even better. We will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Loading...