Johnny's New York Style Pizza

A Regrettably Delightful Experience

We had the misfortune of being served by the bartender at Johnny’s Pizza, and let me tell you—her service was nothing short of atrociously wonderful. Every drink was made with a precision that bordered on offensive. The way she remembered our orders and anticipated our needs? Frankly, disrespectful to every other establishment that lets you suffer in peace.

Her attitude? Warm. Her timing? Impeccable. Her smile? Distractingly charming. It was, quite honestly, a masterclass in bartending—completely ruining our expectations for future nights out.

We came for pizza, we stayed for the drinks, and now we’re burdened with the memory of service so good, it’s going to haunt us.

Regretfully grateful. 10/10 would suffer her excellence again. We will return for Delaney

Always great food, staff , and prices

We met friends here which was great because the patio area has a space for kids to play. Service was great and staff was friendly.

Our go to place. Very good food, nice variety. Service always great. Family atmosphere.

I was there last and a young lady named Jaidyn server my pizza(she fed it to me). I was so happy and the music bingo was so fun!!! The service was hands down better than anywhere Ive ever been, nowhere else has fed me my food.

I have ordered many times from the dawsonville location, excellent! This location? What a disappointment. Late and ice cold, definitely NOT NY STYLE either, doughy and thick crust

We love coming to Johnny's for good food, great service, and fantastic experiences. The food is hot and fresh, the facility is clean, and everyone is so nice!

Great little pizza place. Cool decor and music. Will definitely go back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Syracuse Stuffer

Was an ok place, another chain restaurant for me. Service was good, food not do much. Crust was over cooked and hard, while the pizza itself was thin dough and floppy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Great White Pizza was awesome. XL is huge. The club sub was great. The kids meals are good as well. Everyone enjoyed their food, only three slices of pizza were taken home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent service. Late lunch - 1:30...with a meeting. Our server was attentive but not interruptive. Totally enjoyed my pepperoni slices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I just got a Dr pepper while I stopped in really fast but the service I did ask for was amazing and the atmosphere is amazing as well.. what I asked for they said okay and were very friendly ty..I am going to stop back in once I find time to eat there I love ny style pizza..it's my favorite of all pizza types..ty Johnny's for being very friendly..

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Our first time at this place and we will be back soon. We loved it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza

We ordered a calzone. It was a quarter of the size it normally is and tasted horrible.

Food: 2

So this happened today on my way home from work. I had not been to a Johnny’s pizza in a long time. I went in and ordered a Stromboli to go. They told me it would be 20 minutes so I went back out to my car to continue working on my computer. After 20 minutes, I went in and picked up my food. When I got home today, I cut into my Stromboli and the dough on the inside of the Stromboli is raw. Yeah, not a good taste. I also ordered the bruschett, and it was little pieces of buttered bread with the tomatoes, cold cuts in a little 6oz plastic cup with a lid, and in a container with some dark thick vinergery sauce. So what, I am supposed to bake it myself? LOL!
Now I moved down here from Philadelphia so I know what a really good Stromboli and Bruchetta taste like. Johnny’s pizza have fallen way below The mark. I don’t like leaving negative reviews however I don’t like eating raw dough either.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3