Absolutely a favorite! Congratulations to the entire team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gabe Studivent
When I tell you this is the best seafood restaurant that I have eat in years, it taste so good I wish I lived in that City because I will eat there a lot if y'all want some of the best tasting sauce and fresh seafood this is the place to go it is worth the drive and they cook their food to order it be fresh hot and ready they have friendly staff and the owner is very nice if I had the rate them 10 out of 10 I will give them 100 lol it's just that good for real y'all
Cocoa Everett
The food is always fresh & made to order! The customer service is efficient. I would recommend the fried crabs w/the garlic butter sauce.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Connie Freeman
This place is so, so good! Carry out only, yet amazing food and prices. Today we got 2 fish sandwiches, side of potatoes and cost was only $13.50. Wow! We could select from Flounder or Tilapia, we chose Flounder and it was so delicious! We will go as often as possible when they are open.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thalassa Edwards
Flounder n fries was tasty, hot and served timely. My husband had the snow crab boil plate yummy! Customer service was excellent, very friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Fish Sandwich, Crab Legs, Garlic Crab, Snow Crabs, Fish Dinner, Fried Crab, Snow Crabs w Shrimps & Sides
Devin Hall
This was some of the best seafood I’ve had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dream54045022944
The steaks are awesome. Service is excellent. Try their Tiramisu Cake it is the best in the world. An easy place to get to with ample no hassle free parking. The hospitality compliments the food they serve with prices that that are reasonable in today's market. Moreover, you will leave there with enough food to carry you into the next day. Pound for pound, dollar for dollar, they are a tough act for any restaurant to follow.
Brian T
It was my bday aug22and another young ladies bday also we hugged and had never met before and Artie's was great the food was spectacular and the staff was great Brian was our waiter we share the same name. We had a blast definitely will be going back. Brian Thompson
Pixy L
If you are looking for the best of the best in quiet, courteous, and delicious experience, not only your taste buds, but your body and mind will thank you for dining at Artie's Steak and Seafood. We came here, basically, for a snack after several hours of weekend recreation at the nearby Orchard Beach. We are definitely not locals to the City Island and surrounding areas, so initially, we did not know where we'd go for lunch, and at first, slowly drifted the streets of City Island (in a car, thankfully :)) in search of just such a place. Finally, we saw a cute blue canopy at the corner, and decided то drop anchor there. Inside, we were greeted by an amazingly friendly staff, that even turned off air conditioning (just for us!) in the room where we decided to stay. As far as food is concerned? One word: AMAZING !!! You have to come here to experience it yourself. It will not bite your wallet, but it most definitely will gratify your taste buds. We highly recommend this restaurant to any- and everyone.
I was looking for something new and my friend recommended this restaurant. I ordered the wing combo. Food and service were absolutely amazing. I do recommend Mrs. Artie’s Seafood!!! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doryce S
I am only giving a 3 star rating because the service was good. I ordered the Seabass over crab and corn salad. The Seabass was good but it was served on top of a very cold (refrigerated) corn and Lima bean salad. The very cold salad (which has mostly Lima beans with the corn, not crab) completely ruined the dish; it should have been made room temperature at the very least before serving with a piece of hot fish. Jambalaya was just ok. Three of us ordered Manhattan clam chowder, and though there was some clam in the soup, it was not a chowder. It was a vegetable soup with a little bit of clam flavor, and a small amount of clams thrown in. We ordered the steakhouse chocolate cake for dessert and it was a commercial piece of chocolate cake, the type that you would get in a diner. In general, the fish alone was prepared well, but everything else was just ok.
virgilla g
I'm very disappointed. This place was highly recommended by a local. Unfortunately, the fried food was overcooked. The dark brown scallops, clams shrimp and fish were hard and left a bad taste in my mouth. The corn on the cob was tasty but not hot. The only saving grace was the French fries. I tried my best but couldn't eat it. The server took it back and brought me a new plate that looked good, was cooked properly but wasn't very tasty. The server apologized but the owner or manager never came to the table.. I won't be going back.
Rick_Tri
Artie's is the best restaurant in City Island. Reservations recommended. They accomodate large groups (ten) to celebrate brother in laws birthday. Food is excellent.
Rick T
Artie's is the best restaurant in City Island. Reservations recommended. They accomodate large groups (ten) to celebrate brother in laws birthday. Food is excellent.
best food ever after long day fishing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely a favorite! Congratulations to the entire team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
When I tell you this is the best seafood restaurant that I have eat in years, it taste so good I wish I lived in that City because I will eat there a lot if y'all want some of the best tasting sauce and fresh seafood this is the place to go it is worth the drive and they cook their food to order it be fresh hot and ready they have friendly staff and the owner is very nice if I had the rate them 10 out of 10 I will give them 100 lol it's just that good for real y'all
The food is always fresh & made to order! The customer service is efficient. I would recommend the fried crabs w/the garlic butter sauce.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is so, so good! Carry out only, yet amazing food and prices. Today we got 2 fish sandwiches, side of potatoes and cost was only $13.50. Wow!
We could select from Flounder or Tilapia, we chose Flounder and it was so delicious! We will go as often as possible when they are open.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Flounder n fries was tasty, hot and served timely. My husband had the snow crab boil plate yummy! Customer service was excellent, very friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Fish Sandwich, Crab Legs, Garlic Crab, Snow Crabs, Fish Dinner, Fried Crab, Snow Crabs w Shrimps & Sides
This was some of the best seafood I’ve had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The steaks are awesome. Service is excellent. Try their Tiramisu Cake it is the best in the world. An easy place to get to with ample no hassle free parking. The hospitality compliments the food they serve with prices that that are reasonable in today's market. Moreover, you will leave there with enough food to carry you into the next day. Pound for pound, dollar for dollar, they are a tough act for any restaurant to follow.
It was my bday aug22and another young ladies bday also we hugged and had never met before and Artie's was great the food was spectacular and the staff was great Brian was our waiter we share the same name. We had a blast definitely will be going back. Brian Thompson
If you are looking for the best of the best in quiet, courteous, and delicious experience, not only your taste buds, but your body and mind will thank you for dining at Artie's Steak and Seafood. We came here, basically, for a snack after several hours of weekend recreation at the nearby Orchard Beach. We are definitely not locals to the City Island and surrounding areas, so initially, we did not know where we'd go for lunch, and at first, slowly drifted the streets of City Island (in a car, thankfully :)) in search of just such a place. Finally, we saw a cute blue canopy at the corner, and decided то drop anchor there. Inside, we were greeted by an amazingly friendly staff, that even turned off air conditioning (just for us!) in the room where we decided to stay. As far as food is concerned? One word: AMAZING !!! You have to come here to experience it yourself. It will not bite your wallet, but it most definitely will gratify your taste buds. We highly recommend this restaurant to any- and everyone.
Restaurantji Recommends
I was looking for something new and my friend recommended this restaurant. I ordered the wing combo. Food and service were absolutely amazing. I do recommend Mrs. Artie’s Seafood!!! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am only giving a 3 star rating because the service was good. I ordered the Seabass over crab and corn salad. The Seabass was good but it was served on top of a very cold (refrigerated) corn and Lima bean salad. The very cold salad (which has mostly Lima beans with the corn, not crab) completely ruined the dish; it should have been made room temperature at the very least before serving with a piece of hot fish. Jambalaya was just ok. Three of us ordered Manhattan clam chowder, and though there was some clam in the soup, it was not a chowder. It was a vegetable soup with a little bit of clam flavor, and a small amount of clams thrown in. We ordered the steakhouse chocolate cake for dessert and it was a commercial piece of chocolate cake, the type that you would get in a diner. In general, the fish alone was prepared well, but everything else was just ok.
I'm very disappointed. This place was highly recommended by a local. Unfortunately, the fried food was overcooked. The dark brown scallops, clams shrimp and fish were hard and left a bad taste in my mouth. The corn on the cob was tasty but not hot. The only saving grace was the French fries. I tried my best but couldn't eat it. The server took it back and brought me a new plate that looked good, was cooked properly but wasn't very tasty. The server apologized but the owner or manager never came to the table.. I won't be going back.
Artie's is the best restaurant in City Island. Reservations recommended. They accomodate large groups (ten) to celebrate brother in laws birthday. Food is excellent.
Artie's is the best restaurant in City Island. Reservations recommended. They accomodate large groups (ten) to celebrate brother in laws birthday. Food is excellent.
Loading...