Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Our family enjoys our Johnny’s experiences! Great service, yummy pizza and apps! Kids love the game room.

Amazing staff and some of the best pizza around

Great lunch special Calzone and drink under $10. It was huge, had to bring half of it home!

$9 for this salad. They used to be twice as big.

Great place to bring friends and have a great time.

Great pizza and the cheese cake was delicious!!

The toppings were good, but the crust was under cooked. The wings were good, but there was more garlic parmesan on the bottom of the container than on the wings. We will continue to search for a good pizza in the area.

Got my toppings wrong, crust was way overcooked and burnt on the bottom, and there were so many huge bubbles on my medium pizza 50% of the pizza was bubbles, felt more like i ate half a pizza cuz the crust wasn't really appetizing. Ordered via doordash, I'm good from now on though, I'm sure the staff are nice like everyone says but I won't be walking in there, to eat at least.

Food: 2

Great food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I always get salads from this location. I generally either get the Greek or Antipasto salad. The last several times I’ve ordered either one of them, they are basically just iceberg lettuce…missing most of the toppings that are supposed to be on them. If the toppings are there is a just a few of each on it. I just picked one up and it’s literally a joke for a $12 salad! Get better Johnny’s Hickory Flat.

Great food and service would come back

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Johnny's Pizza app won't show menu without creating an order. Ok. No problem, but you can't start an order outside business hours of the restaurant. I just want to look at the damn menu! If it's that big a secret, there are lots of other pizza joints. I'm done.

This is my go to place for a slice and caesar salad. Great family run neighborhood place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brought family here as I had an online coupon. They would not honor it and said they’ve been fighting for ‘years’ to remove these as they are not authorized so beware if you go here thinking you can use one of ‘their’ coupons.

Pizzas were delivered to our table quickly and was good so that’s the 2 stars.

Our server named ‘Just a Girl’ was more interested in talking to her friends than checking on how our food tasted, status of drinks, etc.

In future we will patronize other locations rather than this one.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Have always liked this pizza place since moving to Hickory Flat but the BBQ chicken pizza that we ordered this past Saturday evening was so bad it went into the trash. $24 for a pizza with chicken that tasted like it has been in the refrigerator for a week and reheated, hardly any onion and very little cheese. It’s like the person who made this pizza could not have cared less about the quality or customer satisfaction.

Food: 1

Service: 3