That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA

You want authentic Italian NY style pizza, forget about going anywhere but That's Italian. You won't be disappointed by anything on this menu. My husband's family is from NY originally from Sicily.... this place is the real deal. The negative reviewers on this place should be locked up for misunderstanding what good food tastes like. Smh.

You looking for the best pie in town? You want fresh crust, perfectly cooked with fresh ingredients? You want fresh cannoli that crumbs apart (like it's supposed to)? You want fried apps that tastes like the ingredients AND the oil are from today? You want great selection and fast service? I can't reiterate enough that THIS IS THE PLACE YOU ARE LOOKING FOR!!!!

If you want something different than pie, try the Caprese Chicken Sandwich. All my curves do the happy dance for that delightful song.

Tonight we tried the zucchini blossoms and the truffle fries. You can't see the fingers but the chef's kiss is happening all over our dinner table tonight.

Thanks for keeping it 💯 every time! Also, maybe next time I'll take some pictures to add to the review but man the smells in my car on that 10 minute drive get my body screaming at me to go faster and when I get home I can't get it on the plates fast enough for my finger's liking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

<3 Amazing Calzone! Omggggeeeeee
Was pricey..... I ordered 1 LG pizza and a Pepperoni Calzone. It totaled $38.71
Still great tho. Better than any chain in my opinion.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

These guys are the best in town

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

PSA to support your local spots! I was doing some work in the area today and decided to stop in today to grab a slice of pizza for a late lunch. I ended getting their lunch special, 2 slices and a drink for under 10 bucks! This is my far the best pizza I’ve had since leaving the Chicago area! A hidden gem! Definitely recommend checking them out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Italian food around Ft. Stewart and a favorite of many soldiers and veterans. It's been here forever and it's always the place I go for a real calzone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Typical quick fix Italian food. Nothing special. Nothing bad to say either. Decent portions. My only complaint is they only serve drinks in cans.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

This is such a gem that is nestled away off the main road. Really, really good food and great service. Enjoyed it immensely and look forward to going back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Picked up pizza. Good

Food: 5

Pizza wasn’t that bad, but the price was insane. 2 large pizza’s, pepperoni and a margarita, and 2 orders of rice balls was $71… and the large pizzas are the size of frozen pizza.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Went in and ordered about $60 worth of food. We patiently waited almost an hour before going inside to continue waiting. We waited so long that both the register lady and the guy who bags the food were both like, it’s almost ready. We still said ok and continued waiting. 5 different groups had walked in during our wait and still received their food before we did. We ordered chicken pasta, pizza, salad and garlic knots. First we kept saying maybe the pasta was what was taking long. Then I noticed 2 tables that walked in after we did had received their pastas. As I’m waiting at the counter I hear the bagger tell the owner who’s making the food, that we’ve been waiting. The owner says, “it’ll be 20 more minutes and if they don’t wanna wait they can go somewhere else.” So when I heard him say that, we instantly requested a refund. When asked who he is the guys says well that’s the owner. You don’t treat customers that way. But the sad part is, this is not the first time we’ve encountered them being nasty because the bagger is normally the nasty one. But surprisingly he was actually nice this evening and I actually told my husband he was nicer and he agreed. But that’s the end of us going back. Y’all need attitude adjustments around there.

Update: about a month later and we still haven’t received our refund and yall have been closed so we can’t even speak to anyone.

Service: 1

True Italian food, run by a Brooklyn native

Incredible and flavorful pizza! First time I have eaten here and won’t be the last. We need more locally owned places like this in Hinesville.

The food is ok, what really caught my attention is how management treat their employees. How embarrassing. I wouldn’t work there. Rude angry people.

We had a double pepperoni pizza. It was very good, though the pepperoni tasted different than we're used to. They have table toppers that have a QR code with their menu. After you figure out what you want, you go to the counter to order. Then they bring it to your table. There were about 6 booths and 4 high top tables. Including tip, the bill was $23.

I ordered lasagna and spaghetti and meat-sauce prior to the store closing. First I had issues with the young lady taking my orders. Even though i ordered the same thing every time there was miscommunication. I took the food home and I didn’t even know what I was looking at. I attached what I received and what it looks like on the menu. When returned to restaurant when they opened in the morning. I was greeted very rudely by this older gentleman and one of the workers in the back. I’ve been going to the restaurant since I got stationed here in 2017 had this is not the first time I’ve had bad food.