Some of the best fudge I've ever had. I took one bite and I almost immediately went back inside to purchase more.
Yea, it's a bit pricey but it's just amazing fudge and chocolate and candy and all the sweets. 10/10.
Edwin DeMars
I love this place and so do my kids! A much needed upgrade from what we had before
Thomas Hanners
I’m posting this publicly because my private feedback to the store was ignored.
We stopped into Jekyll Island Sweets one evening while visiting Jekyll Island for the Christmas lights. After finishing a holiday tour in one of the classic motor cars with family, we stayed behind briefly to grab a few sweets before closing.
We ordered a small, straightforward purchase, totaling $53 after a $5 tip: • 2 Snowman Nutter Butters • 1 Giant Buckeye • 2 Reindeer Rods • 0.25 lb chocolate fudge (pre-cut square) • 2 Ribbon Candy (3 oz) • 1 Mini Buckeyes bag
Despite the small order and the fact that we were polite and efficient, the customer service was shockingly bad.
From the start, the employee rolled her eyes when I began ordering. She cut me off and said, “No, just walk over here with me.” With every single item, she sighed, huffed, rolled her eyes, and asked “Anything else?” with increasing irritation—as if ordering candy in a candy store was an unreasonable burden.
The worst moment came when I asked for one piece of chocolate fudge. Since the fudge was already pre-cut, I didn’t know your internal terminology. Instead of simply clarifying, I was met with a sarcastic “One square or what?”
Yes—one square. One piece. One item. That shouldn’t be a problem.
The sweets themselves were very good. Unfortunately, the customer service completely ruined the experience.
What’s most disappointing is that I already submitted this feedback through your receipt-based survey system and invited management to contact me. No one ever did. That tells me this behavior is either accepted or ignored.
I love Jekyll Island and visit often. Sadly, I will never return to this store—not even to stand under the awning to get out of the rain.
Great candy doesn’t excuse treating paying customers like they’re in the way.
Kent Prescott
We were warmly greeted by the college girl who was staffing the shop as we entered the door before she shared her insights plus samples of their delightful homemade ice creams. I ordered the banana and the salted caramel, and my wife ordered the banana and the sweet bourbon pecan. Splendid!
John Sims
Great place with lots of sweets to choose from. Great and friendly service!
Trevor Sullivan
Go here for ice cream, not another ice cream chain on the island that will not name…
Adam Ackerman
Everything you need for all you sugar lovers.
Ryan James
Fantastic baked goods. The kids loved it.
Courtney Protz-Sanders
This is a great little shop in a historic building. We had such a fun time picking out many, many different sweets to try. The giant buckeyes are the best I’ve ever had. The fudge is fantastic. Great place for gifts too.
Abigail Casanova
Their ice cream is SO good!! And their peanut butter and chocolate fudge is also really good
Some of the best fudge I've ever had. I took one bite and I almost immediately went back inside to purchase more.
Yea, it's a bit pricey but it's just amazing fudge and chocolate and candy and all the sweets. 10/10.
I love this place and so do my kids! A much needed upgrade from what we had before
I’m posting this publicly because my private feedback to the store was ignored.
We stopped into Jekyll Island Sweets one evening while visiting Jekyll Island for the Christmas lights. After finishing a holiday tour in one of the classic motor cars with family, we stayed behind briefly to grab a few sweets before closing.
We ordered a small, straightforward purchase, totaling $53 after a $5 tip:
• 2 Snowman Nutter Butters
• 1 Giant Buckeye
• 2 Reindeer Rods
• 0.25 lb chocolate fudge (pre-cut square)
• 2 Ribbon Candy (3 oz)
• 1 Mini Buckeyes bag
Despite the small order and the fact that we were polite and efficient, the customer service was shockingly bad.
From the start, the employee rolled her eyes when I began ordering. She cut me off and said, “No, just walk over here with me.” With every single item, she sighed, huffed, rolled her eyes, and asked “Anything else?” with increasing irritation—as if ordering candy in a candy store was an unreasonable burden.
The worst moment came when I asked for one piece of chocolate fudge. Since the fudge was already pre-cut, I didn’t know your internal terminology. Instead of simply clarifying, I was met with a sarcastic “One square or what?”
Yes—one square. One piece. One item. That shouldn’t be a problem.
The sweets themselves were very good. Unfortunately, the customer service completely ruined the experience.
What’s most disappointing is that I already submitted this feedback through your receipt-based survey system and invited management to contact me. No one ever did. That tells me this behavior is either accepted or ignored.
I love Jekyll Island and visit often. Sadly, I will never return to this store—not even to stand under the awning to get out of the rain.
Great candy doesn’t excuse treating paying customers like they’re in the way.
We were warmly greeted by the college girl who was staffing the shop as we entered the door before she shared her insights plus samples of their delightful homemade ice creams. I ordered the banana and the salted caramel, and my wife ordered the banana and the sweet bourbon pecan. Splendid!
Great place with lots of sweets to choose from. Great and friendly service!
Go here for ice cream, not another ice cream chain on the island that will not name…
Everything you need for all you sugar lovers.
Fantastic baked goods. The kids loved it.
This is a great little shop in a historic building. We had such a fun time picking out many, many different sweets to try. The giant buckeyes are the best I’ve ever had. The fudge is fantastic. Great place for gifts too.
Their ice cream is SO good!! And their peanut butter and chocolate fudge is also really good
Restaurantji Recommends
Loading...