Cindyrella Cakes

Cindy knows her business. She helped me and another customer simultaneously, she didn’t miss a beat. I ordered 50 cupcakes for my husbands milestone.

The cake part was sooo moist & flavorful but the icing was too sweet, well at least for me; thus the 4 stars.

My husband’s cupcake cake was beautiful, exactly what I asked for.

Of all the bakeries I tried before coming back to Cindyrella’s, hers was the only one that offered delivery.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

The cake was perfect. My husband enjoyed it and it looked just like the image on the website. I placed the order 2 days before I needed it and it was ready a couple of hours earlier. I'd definitely order here again.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cindyrella Cakes is absolutely amazing! I loved her flavors of cake. She has many flavors. We came upon this place just by chance as we were just looking at the venue downstairs for an event. We had been looking for cakes for this event and didn’t really like the options we had, but once we tried her cupcakes, we were sold. Not only did we order cupcakes from her, but also a cake. She matched the design we wanted exactly and did I mention, the cupcakes and cakes taste so good! I believe we had a lemon flavored cupcake, biscoff cookie cupcake, a wedding bliss cupcake, and a red velvet cake. We had so many people asking who made them and where they were located! She most definitely has a returning customer from me and my family! Absolutely great service, great communication, and great product! :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I can’t speak to her custom cake designs, but as far as taste, I’ve been underwhelmed. I’ve tried the rum cake, the red velvet cupcake, the cookies and cream cupcake, and the cookie sandwich, all on different days. The cakes/cupcakes don’t have much flavor…I was especially disappointed in the red velvet cupcake. And the cookie sandwich was extremely sweet. I had high hopes for this place since I have a terrible sweet tooth and I live close by…but it was a miss.

Ordered a cake for my boyfriend’s birthday and this was the best cake I’ve tasted in Atlanta. He’s hard to please and he devoured the cake. Moist and the flavor was out of this world, we finished the cake in a day. The details were also on point. I sent Cindyrella a pinterest picture and she got every detail down to the T but made it better. Will be using her again for my mom & daughter. Now my boyfriend wants to use her for my birthday. 10/10 recommend! I only have a video so excuse the picture quality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thanks Cindy for making my son's first birthday party and his cake a big hit!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Cindyrella cakes have done it again. The cake was decorated so pretty and tasted delicious. My son really loved the cookies and the different designs. Thanks Cindy for your attention to detail and providing excellent work.

Cupcakes are delicious! 😋

I can not not brag enough about the treatment we received here. We had my daughter's birthday party and it exceeded my expectation. From the planning phase to inceptions she was a true joy to work with. I was thankful that we did not go with another vendor and found Cindy and her team. On top of the great service and atmosphere cakes were AMAZING. I highly recommend this place for your next event or just stop by and pick up a treat.

Awesome little place

Hands Down, the best, most moist, creamy, Love Baked cake that I've ever had. I ordered a Caramel Pecan Rum Cake for my Queen's BDay and she lost her mind 1st taste. The bakery is local, clean and with great customer service. 10 owt of 10!!!!

My daughter asked me to find someone who could make her cake. It was in my opinion a cake with so much detail and was worried of the outcome. I sent Cindy a picture. She said no problem. As if i sent her a picture of a plain cake. When I tell you.. she sent me a final pic of my daughter’s cake. I was wondering why she sent me the picture I sent her initially. It wasnt until I noticed my daughter’s name on it, that I noticed it was hers!!! Cindy NAILED IT!!!! My daughter cried it was so perfect. She will definitely have my business!!!!!

Cindy was very helpful, responsive and professional. She made a beautiful custom cake for a baby shower with only one week's notice. I sent her a picture of a cake from pinterest and she nailed it exactly as the picture. The cake was delicious and moist. Everyone at the baby showered wanted her contact info. I would definitely use her again!!

Cake ordered was delicious and designed to our satisfaction. Our order was ready on time.

Cindyrella Cake is the Best. Period!! Cindy made my husband a vanilla pound cake for his birthday and it was out of this World. The cake was large and gone by the next day. I highly recommend Cindyrella Cake to another who wants their event to be the talk of the town. I will be back soon for more cakes.