Four score and perhaps but a handful of minutes ago, I stepped into an establishment known as Your Pie Pizza, led under the fine stewardship of a gentleman named Seth. What I found there was not merely the making of pizza, but the manifestation of liberty itself — the liberty to create one's own pie, forged by one's own choosing, and topped according to the dictates of one's conscience and appetite.
The dough was tender, the sauce rich with zest, and the ingredients laid before me like a bounty prepared for a king. I assembled my custom pie with great deliberation, and it was prepared with swiftness and great care by a staff whose demeanor reflected both efficiency and good will.
Yet it is not solely the food that compels me to speak in earnest praise. Nay, it is the leadership of Manager Seth — a man of character and warmth — who greeted all who entered not as mere customers, but as neighbors, as friends. In his conduct, one sees the kind of leadership that uplifts both team and patron alike.
In sum, I must declare: if ever a man hungers for nourishment both of the body and the spirit, let him make his way to Your Pie Pizza, and there he shall find it
Yến Hải
We really enjoyed our dinner here. Wonderful welcome from Seth. A lot of effort has gone into this space and you can tell there is a lot of passion in the restaurant. Thank you for the great service and we’ll definitely come back!
Phani Gokaraju
Pizza was burnt at the bottom, ordered honey drizzle and it was not done
Alex Bond
We went here for dinner and the food and service was excellent! The quality of the pizza for only $10 is unmatched in the area. It was fire oven cooked perfectly and was made very well. I will definitely be back for more in the future! Will and Seth were both very nice and even answered our questions about things to do in the area. The only comment I would have would be about the TikTok streams playing on the TV’s, seemed like sports on most of the TV’s would make more sense. Overall awesome experience that I would recommend!
Adriana Lombardo
Very impressed with the quality of food here. I was instantly welcomed by Will and Seth. Their attention to detail was impressive. We ordered the BBQ Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza and the Chicken Caprese Sandwich- I’d get them over and over again it was so good! Also, added beer to our order and that was so good! I love their local beer options. I’m also so impressed with the quality of the food, everything tasted so fresh. The only thing I’d change was playing sports on the TVS - besides that…. It was perfect!
Al Fernandez
Typically I don’t write reviews however I also go to Your Pie for lunch every week. The Woodstock and Canton locations are great. However, this location in Milton should get their stuff together. The pizza I order the bottom was burned. I had to get up and ask if they had put all the ingredients that I asked for on my pizza. I could not see them. They had no ice tea and Apparently they don’t brew tea at all here.
Never again will I be visiting this location and if I were you I would stay away from coming to this unit.
Dennis Denson
New upgrades in restaurant, food is very good. Service is good. Good crew working in there.
Edwin Cruz
Great food, good customer service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Tiger Tay
We absolutely love Your Pie Pizza! I am taking 1 star away from this location because of the mold we saw on the drink/ice dispenser. Everything else seemed clean other than that. The food is delicious and staff is friendly. Until the drink machine is thoroughly clean I may just be getting a drink elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Brownie, Build Your Own Pizza
Martin Gable
Amazing pizza, great beers, fantastic staff! Edit, not so much anymore
Excellent place hidden away at the intersection of Bethany bend and highway 9 close to Publix. Excellent food quality and quick service. We had the veggie Pizza and Cheese sticks. Loved it. Will definitely go again. And the price is reasonable!!! The place is a bit old and could do with an upgrade. Tables and benches are reasonably comfortable. Walls could liven up the ambience with some paint or pictures.
Parking: There are 20-30 parking spots in front and hundreds more behind Pie Pizza. Absolutely easy at any time of the day
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Vegan, Build Your Own Pizza
Lisa Cleland
Great place for takeout pizza made just the way you like it! Consistent quality of ingredients and service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
jonathan mckinley
Stephanie was amazing she was so sweet definitely coming back !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Build Your Own Pizza
Ricardo Rivera
this place is so terrible like i walked in when it was empty and they still couldn’t even make a pizza right or good my pizza looks like it got stepped on lmao i would not recommend this to anyone you better off eating mcdonald's cause these are straight garbage
Four score and perhaps but a handful of minutes ago, I stepped into an establishment known as Your Pie Pizza, led under the fine stewardship of a gentleman named Seth. What I found there was not merely the making of pizza, but the manifestation of liberty itself — the liberty to create one's own pie, forged by one's own choosing, and topped according to the dictates of one's conscience and appetite.
The dough was tender, the sauce rich with zest, and the ingredients laid before me like a bounty prepared for a king. I assembled my custom pie with great deliberation, and it was prepared with swiftness and great care by a staff whose demeanor reflected both efficiency and good will.
Yet it is not solely the food that compels me to speak in earnest praise. Nay, it is the leadership of Manager Seth — a man of character and warmth — who greeted all who entered not as mere customers, but as neighbors, as friends. In his conduct, one sees the kind of leadership that uplifts both team and patron alike.
In sum, I must declare: if ever a man hungers for nourishment both of the body and the spirit, let him make his way to Your Pie Pizza, and there he shall find it
We really enjoyed our dinner here. Wonderful welcome from Seth. A lot of effort has gone into this space and you can tell there is a lot of passion in the restaurant. Thank you for the great service and we’ll definitely come back!
Pizza was burnt at the bottom, ordered honey drizzle and it was not done
We went here for dinner and the food and service was excellent! The quality of the pizza for only $10 is unmatched in the area. It was fire oven cooked perfectly and was made very well. I will definitely be back for more in the future! Will and Seth were both very nice and even answered our questions about things to do in the area. The only comment I would have would be about the TikTok streams playing on the TV’s, seemed like sports on most of the TV’s would make more sense. Overall awesome experience that I would recommend!
Very impressed with the quality of food here. I was instantly welcomed by Will and Seth. Their attention to detail was impressive. We ordered the BBQ Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza and the Chicken Caprese Sandwich- I’d get them over and over again it was so good! Also, added beer to our order and that was so good! I love their local beer options. I’m also so impressed with the quality of the food, everything tasted so fresh. The only thing I’d change was playing sports on the TVS - besides that…. It was perfect!
Typically I don’t write reviews however I also go to Your Pie for lunch every week. The Woodstock and Canton locations are great. However, this location in Milton should get their stuff together. The pizza I order the bottom was burned. I had to get up and ask if they had put all the ingredients that I asked for on my pizza. I could not see them. They had no ice tea and Apparently they don’t brew tea at all here.
Never again will I be visiting this location and if I were you I would stay away from coming to this unit.
New upgrades in restaurant, food is very good. Service is good. Good crew working in there.
Great food, good customer service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
We absolutely love Your Pie Pizza! I am taking 1 star away from this location because of the mold we saw on the drink/ice dispenser. Everything else seemed clean other than that. The food is delicious and staff is friendly. Until the drink machine is thoroughly clean I may just be getting a drink elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Brownie, Build Your Own Pizza
Amazing pizza, great beers, fantastic staff!
Edit, not so much anymore
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent place hidden away at the intersection of Bethany bend and highway 9 close to Publix. Excellent food quality and quick service. We had the veggie Pizza and Cheese sticks. Loved it. Will definitely go again. And the price is reasonable!!!
The place is a bit old and could do with an upgrade. Tables and benches are reasonably comfortable. Walls could liven up the ambience with some paint or pictures.
Parking: There are 20-30 parking spots in front and hundreds more behind Pie Pizza. Absolutely easy at any time of the day
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Vegan, Build Your Own Pizza
Great place for takeout pizza made just the way you like it! Consistent quality of ingredients and service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Stephanie was amazing she was so sweet definitely coming back !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Build Your Own Pizza
this place is so terrible like i walked in when it was empty and they still couldn’t even make a pizza right or good my pizza looks like it got stepped on lmao i would not recommend this to anyone you better off eating mcdonald's cause these are straight garbage
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Always good pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Pizza, Craft Beer, Cauliflower Crust
Loading...