Johnny's New York Style Pizza

1899 Newnan Crossing Blvd, Newnan
(770) 252-3495

Recent Reviews

Patrick Garcia

Waited a HOUR for my online order :( You guys need to do better!Downgraded from 2 stars to 1 because the "owner" never reached out. I guess the response to negative experiences and reviews are not genuine.

Sean Williams

In my opinion, BBQ chicken pizza should not have pizza sauce and BBQ sauce. The 2 drastically contrast one another. No other pizzeria puts pizza sauce on there version of BBQ chicken pizza. It was my birthday dinner and kinda ruined my evening. I guess I should haves asked more questions??? ??‍♂️

Mark Starr

Ordered a large pizza to go,after waiting thirty minutes went to pickup and was told to wait.turns out after waiting another twenty minutes it was ready the whole time but the cook and the waitress couldn't stop talking long enough to hand us our pizza. When we got it it was soggy,all the ingredients were dumped in the middle.Never eating here again.

Gadsden O.

Expensive and disgusting. Bought a 15 dollar calzone and the "fresh basil" inside was sour and rotten. Not to mention extremely salty. Most of the calzone was just dough, barely any ingredients except for the rotten basil and when you actually did manage to get a pepperoni or piece of onion or pepper, they were tasteless. Don't waste your time, very low quality ingredients. To be honest I feel like I just got robbed. This was the worst calzone I think I have ever had in my life, and judging by the other reviews on here, I'm certainly not the first one to feel this way.

Jared Hunt

Thin crust Italian Special was severally under cooked. (See photo) Zero crunch. Doesn’t taste like New York pizza, but it’s edible.

Afra Williams

Sooooo I THINK this place is Johnny Bruscos..... I Googled this place because the Pizza place I googled before when I got inside I didn't like the way the pizza looked plus you're forced to buy the whole pie and i was traveling. When I got there it looks like the Johnny Bruscos by my house which is why I chose it however the pizza was different. It was much better! The people I was with wanted different types and we all agreed our different slices were better than what we've had at home. The vibe was friendly, the waitress was very kind and there were a few kiddos walking around. I would have felt very comfortable if I had had my son in tow. (I don't do stuffy "no kids allowed" type places anymore) I got the feeling everyone knew each other and I liked it, it didn't make me feel like a tourist, which i was. It seemed a little out of the way as far as googling food joints from the highway but i also don't know the area and this may be a good location for them. Anyway, if you happen to find your self near by this pizza place, go for it!Kid-friendliness: Loved the atmosphere for the kiddos. I didn't check out the menu options tho.

Frances Bell

Pepperoni Pizza was tasty. The garlic knots are to die for. My cheese pizza was so good! I took some home and even got coupons on my togo box for next time. Service was outstanding.

Lorna Mosbacher

Great pizza. The four cheese is phenomenal. Ordered garlic knots as well.Crust is so good.Lots of televisions for sports. Outdoor seating too.

Redd Savage

Well the steak and cheese sub was dry and barely any cheese the pizza was under cook, didn't believe you could do that to pizza. The salad is the only thing that I liked out of there. They get a 4 out of 10

Johnny Rayment

average pizza, pizza taste thrown together, not reccommeneded if your looking for a good taste, it taste alike dominos and such. not that bad, but not the best. good pricing though.

Aaron Huddlestun

Quite possibly the worst pizza I’ve ever had. We ordered a large pepperoni with extra cheese. It’s been an hour and I still can’t get that taste out of my mouth. Salt just over powered everything.

Aaron H.

Quite possibly the worst pizza I've ever had. We ordered a large pepperoni with extra cheese. It was well cooked but it was entirely too salty. Salt just overpowered everything. My wife couldn't finish a slice. My teenage daughters didn't want another slice. I tried a second slice but I just couldn't. It was horrible. We ended up throwing the rest away. That was a first. I know this sounds over the top, but I legitimately don't know that I will ever crave pizza again. Thanks for that.

Julia M.

This was honestly some of the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. I would eat a Dignorno before ordering this again...

Rita Gale Fredrickson

Great food and friendly service here always.

Heather Bryan

Great food every time and I love the people that work there!! Always friendly and make you feel welcome

Load More