The only pizza I’ve found in the area to get excited about. Very similar to northeast. Smells great inside. Staff is awesome.
One drawback- message to owner: Open on Sundays please! I’ve tried to get pizza on Sunday from here dozens of times just to remind myself it’s closed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Russell Cope
Great tasting pizza and cheesesteaks! Fast friendly service and clean tables to eat at and enjoy the food and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sarah tee
As a NJ native and self proclaimed pizza connoisseur, this place is exceptionally good. I’ll never set foot in that mellow mushroom joint again in Pooler. The Brothers makes better pizza, faster, more authentic and for LESS. Their lunch special is unbeatable and filling. I love the folks who work there and I go almost everytime I’m in pooler. Sometimes I go just for the pizza (as a Hinesville resident, it’s worth it). Give them a try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hailey Page
Been here for a week and tried a different restaurant every night and this was by far the best we went to. The inside is adorable and very cozy, loved the music playing. The lady that took our order was so sweet and joked around with us. Everything we got was delicious and came out fast. I ordered a large pizza while my fiancé ordered a medium and we were very surprised when his pizza came out first and it was the size i was expecting for my large pizza. We obviously weren’t the only ones who liked their food as they had people in and out the door the entire time we were there. We were able to sit and eat there but takeout is also a fast option from what i saw while we were there. I recommend the white pizza with added spinach and chicken!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Willy
Great pizza and service, happy they have Pepsi now because pizza is better with Pepsi haha. Will be ordering again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crystal W
This is the best pizza I’ve had in our entire region. It is the closest match to authentic, Northern-style pizza in our area. I tried to take a picture that shows how it’s seasoned to perfection and insanely flavorful. High quality ingredients and freshly made. The food is AMAZING, the prices are great, but the customer service is always fantastic. There is always a beautiful smile and kind demeanor waiting at the counter. I have never left disappointed and I’ve been going there for many, many years. You have to give them a try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Parker
Too Good!
Robert Stinnette
Eat from here often. Usually get the large supreme pizza and the chicken wings, use to get fries but they started putting them in a container with a lid and they get soggy from the steam. Best pizza and wings in Pooler!
Geo S
Today we picked up a meatball parm sub, chicken parm sub and a Greek salad. The meatballs were extremely bland, the Greek salad was mostly lettuce (3/4 of the entire salad was lettuce). Not New York style as stated. Best you go to Terra Mia on 80, that's authentic N.Y. style Italian food, the very best Italian in the Pooler area.
Erratic Exposure
Official Brooklyn slices. Made me miss home real quick. We’ll be back for sure. Everything was on point.
Cashier was friendly and imformative. Food came out fast and was ok... average ingredients. Pizza had no seasoning. Sauce is bland and mildly sweet.
Zoe Perry
Love this place! Owner is such a hard worker, yet never grumpy and always welcoming. Their lemon pepper wings are the absolute best; you can actually see and taste the seasoning. I haven’t found any better in Chatham county.
Jacquelyn Anderson
🔥🔥🔥 best hidden gym definitely my new favorite spot. The Philly special and the Gyro beat any other in town!!
MD N
Food was really good. Could lower the music. So can hear each other when dinning in.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Traveling Biker
Hidden gem. The pizza is great. Nice crust, little to no flop. The dough used has its own unique sweetness. The lemon pepper wings are outstanding!!! Nice selection of soda. The garlic knots didn't have the flavor I thought they'd have, something was missing. The marinara sauce used for the knots was better used with the crust from my pizza. Definitely a spot to come back to.
The only pizza I’ve found in the area to get excited about. Very similar to northeast. Smells great inside. Staff is awesome.
One drawback- message to owner: Open on Sundays please! I’ve tried to get pizza on Sunday from here dozens of times just to remind myself it’s closed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great tasting pizza and cheesesteaks! Fast friendly service and clean tables to eat at and enjoy the food and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a NJ native and self proclaimed pizza connoisseur, this place is exceptionally good. I’ll never set foot in that mellow mushroom joint again in Pooler. The Brothers makes better pizza, faster, more authentic and for LESS. Their lunch special is unbeatable and filling. I love the folks who work there and I go almost everytime I’m in pooler. Sometimes I go just for the pizza (as a Hinesville resident, it’s worth it). Give them a try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been here for a week and tried a different restaurant every night and this was by far the best we went to. The inside is adorable and very cozy, loved the music playing. The lady that took our order was so sweet and joked around with us. Everything we got was delicious and came out fast. I ordered a large pizza while my fiancé ordered a medium and we were very surprised when his pizza came out first and it was the size i was expecting for my large pizza. We obviously weren’t the only ones who liked their food as they had people in and out the door the entire time we were there. We were able to sit and eat there but takeout is also a fast option from what i saw while we were there. I recommend the white pizza with added spinach and chicken!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and service, happy they have Pepsi now because pizza is better with Pepsi haha. Will be ordering again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the best pizza I’ve had in our entire region. It is the closest match to authentic, Northern-style pizza in our area. I tried to take a picture that shows how it’s seasoned to perfection and insanely flavorful. High quality ingredients and freshly made. The food is AMAZING, the prices are great, but the customer service is always fantastic. There is always a beautiful smile and kind demeanor waiting at the counter. I have never left disappointed and I’ve been going there for many, many years. You have to give them a try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Too Good!
Eat from here often. Usually get the large supreme pizza and the chicken wings, use to get fries but they started putting them in a container with a lid and they get soggy from the steam. Best pizza and wings in Pooler!
Today we picked up a meatball parm sub, chicken parm sub and a Greek salad. The meatballs were extremely bland, the Greek salad was mostly lettuce (3/4 of the entire salad was lettuce). Not New York style as stated. Best you go to Terra Mia on 80, that's authentic N.Y. style Italian food, the very best Italian in the Pooler area.
Official Brooklyn slices. Made me miss home real quick. We’ll be back for sure. Everything was on point.
Restaurantji Recommends
Cashier was friendly and imformative. Food came out fast and was ok... average ingredients. Pizza had no seasoning. Sauce is bland and mildly sweet.
Love this place! Owner is such a hard worker, yet never grumpy and always welcoming. Their lemon pepper wings are the absolute best; you can actually see and taste the seasoning. I haven’t found any better in Chatham county.
🔥🔥🔥 best hidden gym definitely my new favorite spot. The Philly special and the Gyro beat any other in town!!
Food was really good. Could lower the music. So can hear each other when dinning in.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Hidden gem. The pizza is great. Nice crust, little to no flop. The dough used has its own unique sweetness. The lemon pepper wings are outstanding!!! Nice selection of soda. The garlic knots didn't have the flavor I thought they'd have, something was missing. The marinara sauce used for the knots was better used with the crust from my pizza. Definitely a spot to come back to.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Wings
Loading...