Nancy's Chicago Pizzeria Roswell

Food was amazing! Service was amazing! Please come to Augusta!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We drove for 40 minutes to get to this place for their famous deep dish pizza around 2 weeks ago. We really like it.

I’ve been here many times over the last few years, but I am extremely disappointed in my experience last night.

First of all, we ordered garlic bread, which ended up forgotten and didn’t come out until after I brought it up when our entrees arrived. That’s okay, these things happen.

What really upset me is that my entree arrived incorrect, and was never fixed. I ordered a salad with bleu cheese dressing, but when my salad came out, it had a sweeter dressing that was a different color and thinner in texture. I’ve ordered this exact salad many times before and was confident that this was incorrect. I told my waitress— she went and talked to the kitchen staff, and came back insisting it was correct. I had other people at my table try it as well, who confirmed that I received the wrong dressing. When my waitress finally came back at the end of the night and asked if I wanted a box, I told her no, and that again, this was not what I ordered.

Mistakes happen, I get that. I’ve had my order messed up here before. But I’m very unhappy with how this mistake was handled. I left starving and having paid $20+ for a meal that I didn’t get to eat.

Small large pizza with expensive cost. Incorrectly cooked both pizzas. Ordered half extra cheese half pepperoni. Got a regular cheese. Ordered veggie no mushrooms. You guessed it. Mushrooms throughout. Not going back. Much better pizza in Roswell.

This is the WORST pizza I've ever had. Drove 30 min because I saw it on tik tok. DONT LET THE PICS FOOL YOU. I wouldn't eat it for free. Save yourself.

Food was good.The original stuffed pizza doesn't have enough other toppings it's mostly cheese and sauce. Still good though.

Best Chicago pizza in town. Deep dish is the best pizza in the world so that tells you all you need to know! You need to get in here and try this pizza if you haven’t already.

It was delish. Definitely brought the taste of Chicago style pizza to Atlanta.

Pizza was excellent and very friendly service! I'll definitely go again when back in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago-Style Pizza, Thin Create Your Own Pizza

We enjoyed our first taste of true deep dish pizza. Nothing special with the thin crust. My son absolutely loved the godmother sandwich.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food and service are fantastic! Brandon was spot on with recommendations! Highly recommend!

Visited on a Saturday night where the restaurant was quite busy. Service, staff, and food were all spot on. My favorite pizzeria.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was our first time. Amazing. We both ordered pasta and also a pizza for dinner tomorrow night. The bar was great. The bartender knows how to you make great drinks. I in had an amazing long island ice tea. The cannoli's were on target. Will be back. So glad we came.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Definitely worth trying, easily one of the best pizza place around the area!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago-Style Pizza

My wife brought me here for the first time for my birthday to get some Chicago-style deep dish.

They served a deep-dish pizza that was a towering masterpiece of rich flavors and textures, crafted with care and indulgence in mind. The foundation was a buttery, flaky crust—thick and sturdy but with a tender, almost biscuit-like texture. This crust was pressed up the sides of a deep, round pan to form a bowl, cradling all the delicious ingredients within.

Next came a generous layer of gooey, stretchy mozzarella cheese, perfectly melted and covering the crust edge to edge. The cheese served as a delicious barrier that kept the crust from getting soggy while creating a decadent base layer of creamy, melted goodness.

Above the cheese, a hearty helping of toppings was piled on—traditional favorites like Italian sausage (rich, fennel-spiced, and slightly crispy at the edges), pepperoni, fresh green peppers, onions, and mushrooms, which add just the right blend of savory and earthy notes. Each bite felt like a balanced burst of flavor with every topping bringing its character.

Finally, the sauce: a chunky, bright red tomato sauce layered on top. This sauce was thick and robust, made from vine-ripened tomatoes and seasoned with garlic, oregano, and a hint of basil. It is a sweet sauce which I'm usual not a fan of, but the acidity of the tomatoes helped balance out the sweetness with a tangy-ness that saved the sauce from being obnoxiously sweet and cloying. Also some flecks of grated Parmesan sprinkled on top added a final touch of sharp, nutty flavor to offset the sweetness.

When baked, this pizza emerges with a slightly caramelized crust edge, a bubbling top layer, and the intoxicating aroma of Italian herbs and garlic. The experience of slicing into it reveals the thick layers within, each forkful a satisfying mouthful of cheese pull, savory fillings, and rich tomato goodness.

Oh yeah, we'll be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

0 .,*
Nothing exciting start from de poor services from de guy and lady at the door podium, at least 5 staff in the room but nobody noticed, that the waitress was delayed until a skinny guy with glasses after approximately 10 minutes, came to remained me that the waitress still delayed, that she will be shortly and ask me for my drinks order, and I pushed to tell him my food order was only two pizza, and I don't want to wait anymore, shortly a lot of people after that was waiting on the line and you can tell that these staff, have not been training for a good or great customer services at all, they seem bored, honestly
I don't recommend this business until some improve have be done, asap I really recommend them, must have a cross training in all areas and be open to all of them to be multi task, show appreciation when someone appear at your business door...etc
Food was just OK, nothing different as I was hoping for.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1