Tokyo Bay Japanese Restaurant

Delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

great AYCE value especially for the area!! and very tasty sushi and hibachi. not buffet style, which makes everything much simpler. good option for sushi AYCE if you have a group where not everyone can eat seafood. best to come with a large group because they will charge you extra if you don't finish everything you order.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Very good sushi and all you can eat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A Pleasant Surprise at Tokyo Bay – Worth the Revisit!

It had been a few years since I last visited Tokyo Bay—I stopped going around the time they shifted from buffet-style to table ordering during COVID. Back then, the all-you-can-eat buffet was fantastic (despite some guests lacking table manners). I’d also heard rumors of ownership changes and struggles, so I stayed away.

Fast forward to last Saturday: my husband and I were running errands near Holcomb Bridge and decided to give it another shot—and we’re so glad we did!

We were pleasantly surprised by the updated menu. The pricing is competitive with other local spots, and the sushi was fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. It’s still all-you-can-eat, but now you order from your table—and the service was excellent. As you’ll see from the photos, the portions were unexpectedly large.

My husband, who can usually put away a serious amount of sushi, actually struggled to finish. And it wasn’t just the sushi—the miso soup, wontons, crab rangoon, and ginger salad were some of the best we’ve had in a while.

The atmosphere hasn’t changed much, but if you care more about quality and value, this place is absolutely worth a visit.

💡 Pro tip: Go for the lunch deal—just $19 per person!

And here’s something I really appreciated: to discourage food waste, they now have a policy where leftover food results in an extra charge that’s donated to a food bank. Brilliant idea—and a great way to promote mindful dining.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best Japanese food ever made in Atlanta!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Today's take-out experience was kind of bad. The possibility to write a comment for an online order seems pretty useless if no one reads the text. Ordering something especially without sauce and you receive the dish fully soaked in it. Cannot recommend.

The fried rice was okay, so one more star.

Food: 1

Service: 1

i used to love this place and visit every week but today was a totally different experience, food delay, restaurant had a really bad smell and service was horrible. After we payed one of the workers came outside looking for us to sign and put tip even tho we did indeed put 0 because we were not served at all, it was the craziest thing i’ve ever seen in my life.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Food is perfect every time. Some of the best food I have ever had. They just don’t use A/C. It’s almost as hot inside as it it outside. But if they would turn the A/C on it’s a 5/5

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

After being here a few times it is apparent they have a strategy of bringing out your first few items right away then delaying the next set of items. Yesterday we ordered two sheets within 10 minutes of each other at about 6:45 & 6:55 respectively, and received one order at 7:14 and the next at 8:10. Waiting close to an hour and a half for an order of 4 rolls.

The food actually was great outside of when we found a tiny roach in the miso soup, and the cucumber tasting like a chemical and ruining our appetite on 3 of the rolls. It is just tough to rate it higher than 2 stars when that happens and it ruins your guests appetites.

This is not our servers fault any of this happened, she was nice. She informed us management took 20% off our bill, which is nice to cover the tip.

The primary reason I wrote this this morning is because I want to call out the way the restaurant uses the technique of bringing out one order of filling food then waiting an hour to bring out the next round at an ayce to limit how much you can really eat. It was a real let down on that account.

I hope next time it is quicker service and no sour cucumbers, really want to see this place do well being a big fan of ayce.

Food service and price are all excellent. Couldn't recommend more highly

It was atoss btwn this place or sushi kingdom for lunch. I have been to sushi kingdom so thought I'd give this place a try. Atmosphere was decent. Service was ok but a bit slow. It took about 20 mins to get my sushi order and they charge $1-2 for each leftover pc. I only had an hr for lunch so i was late returning. The cucumber in my rolls tasted sour so the server agreed not to charge me for the leftover pcs. It was ok overall but I probably will not return.

I'm a sushi snob and let me tell you they serve fresh sushi! Its all you can eat you make an order and then they make it for you. Just make sure to finish the sushi or you're going to have to pay for each sushi that you haven't finished. You can also order different dishes that is not all you can eat. If you come in a certain time you get the best deal for your money on all you can eat. The service is great too! You won't be disappointed if you give it a try.

I wish I could give this place a score higher than 5 star. Went for my college aged son’s birthday and they went out of their way to make the lunch special for him. Food was great too. I love coming to this restaurant.

Our group of friends went in on a Sunday after working out. The food presentation was good, hot items were freshly prepared/fried. The service could be a little better since they're not many people but I understand this is like a family-run restaurant. They have a lot of varieties but we didn't order a lot since we don't want to waste food. May I suggest you to give customers an option to order a half of any specialty roll vs. a full roll? So we can try more items. Please keep the quality and we will be back soon.

Place did not smell like a restaurant, food tasteless, service poor. Will not be back.