Smallcakes Cupcakery

I asked for a very simple “Happy Birthday” cake for my dear husband. I will let my pictures do the talking, as I couldn’t be more disappointed. The first picture is what I initially picked up and I turned around so fast hoping they could do something to fix the cake. I asked for them to at least fix the writing to be larger and make the cake look happy… even an exclamation mark would have added something! The writing is beyond unprofessional and for a $47 cake, quite pathetic. The second and third pictures are what I then went and “re” picked up later. I could cry, it’s the saddest Birthday cake I’ve ever seen. The only saving grace is that it did taste yummy. We got a strawberry cake with lemon filling and cream cheese frosting. Unfortunately the cake is not what I would have liked to pay for. The only explanation I got in reference to the decor was “oh she’s learning” and sadly had to be my husband’s cake she’s “learning” on. Cupcakes are great but do not order any custom cake.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Great cupcakes for reasonable price and nice options. Staff is also very friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

On October 17, 2024 I got married and Smallcakes made my wedding cake and it was wonderful!! It was beautiful, delicious and made to order!! (gluten free and no nuts due to family allergies!) Thank you Ashley for the amazing job you did creating my cake!! Even now after the wedding my guests continue to ask me where I got it and I am delighted to recommend you and the Smallcakes team!! From placing the order, to working with me on the design and style, to delivering it that day, I couldn't have been more pleased! Thank you again for everything!! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Mary Miller

Food: 5

Service: 5

Visiting the island and wanted a birthday cake for our granddaughter who was turning 22. I showed the girl the picture and she assured me she could do it. Well, what I picked up was nothing like the picture. Was very disappointed with the way it looked and cake was very dense. Not only that, but the writing was suppose to be on the board. She said she wasn’t very good at writing, so she wrote Happy Birthday on the box the cake came in. Will NOT be returning.

We spotted this bakery as we were driving past yesterday, and I think I just had the best cupcake of my life! I forget the name, but it was chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, with vanilla cream inside and a vanilla squiggle on top. So moist and rich and flavorful! What an amazing surprise!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very cute place. Excellent cupcakes and wide selection. Get the mini-cupcake variety pack!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered birthday cupcakes, 3 of each kind listed in Review to celebrate our grandsons 20th birthday, they were amazing and he loved them. We are snowbirds, here for the winter and have been to the bakery several times to also pick up the mini cupcake sampler which was enjoyed by all our guests. The manager was terrific helping me decide on flavors and colors and each time so kind and helpful. We will return next year to indulge in the cupcakes for an extra special treat. Thank you for making the birthday cupcakes so special. Diane Monaco

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream, Hot Fudge Sundae, Red Velvet

Very cute place. Excellent cupcakes and wide selection. Get the mini-cupcake variety pack!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very cute place. Excellent cupcakes and wide selection. Get the mini-cupcake variety pack!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quite big for smallcakes, but they were good

Best Cupcakes on the planet & super cool store

We are vacationing on the Island and we wanted some sweet treats so we decided to get some cupcakes. We got wedding cake, key lime, cannoli, Oreo and snickers. The cupcakes that we ate so far were delicious.

Absolutely delicious!!!! We tried 6 different flavors and they all were great!

We ordered 3 dozen cupcakes and a small cake for our wedding. We also requested delivery and wow!! The whole process was so easy, smooth, and convenient for our special day. The customer service of this place is superb!! And all of our treats were beautiful iced and delicious!!

Always very friendly when I come in to pick up a delivery order. One time I accidentally messed up a customer's order and the store was nice enough to replace it for me free of charge!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5