St. Simons Sweets LLC

Tons of sweet treats to choose from; the Cookie Monster ice cream was delicious!

I was there September 4, 2025. I don't have a problem with their Ice Cream or sweets. They are fine. Not great mind you, but you can get better locally or online. I understand this is a tourist town and it's going to be higher price, but 21.00 a pound for fudge??? Then they add a service fee (no prior notice) and a credit card fee (again no prior notice) then tax. The credit card asks for a tip as well. REALLY?????? it's outrageous. When she gave me four pieces of fudge, she just packed it up, didn't show me that it came out to be 2 1/2 lbs. I had to take her word for it. I didn't see the receipt until I left the store. I had to ask her for a bag, because she wasn't going to give me one. She was rude and not very professional. I willl NEVER go there again. I love St. Simon and all the establishments, but will never visit this place again. It's a rip off. Ticket # 132 8:32 pm September 4th. 23.33 for the fudge, 3.50% service fee and 3.00% credit card fee.

Wonderful, tasty ice-cream! Their serving is generous. Kids loved the Cookie Monster and Cookies and Cream flavors. It’s a fun place to go and check out all their amazing sweets. Love that it’s local!

! We got delicious ice cream. We have eaten ice cream around the island and this is probably the best!

Great ice cream! Lots of candy!! Kids dream store & some adults too!

wonderful spot for amazing ice cream with so many flavors! tons of cute candy and gifts that will make your mouth water!! we love it here

I loved the chocolate brownie, which I was super happy until I tried my boyfriend's banana pudding ice cream then I got super jealous!!! Must stop in!!!

Lots of choices to satisfy your sweet tooth. A large variety of fudge, ice cream, baked goods and candy to choose from. Bathroom to use as well. It is an interesting little shop that I will definitely revisit!

Fantastic sweets shop. They have many great treats like fudge, chocolate covered items, and ice cream. They also have pre-bagged candy and some trinkets in the back. This is a great institution that has been on St. Simons for a long time and hopefully for many more years to come.

Ice cream was actually enjoyable, but every worker we encountered was so irritable and rude. Two girls at the counter needed an attitude check.

This place is a must go to! Its so cute I had to take a picture of the bathroom! Make sure you stop by for all your home made favorites including festive rice Krispy treats, candied and chocolate apples, and even candy scented candles!

Loved the peach cobbler ice cream... and then I had the blueberry cobbler. What! Delicious! Great job!

Really enjoyed the store, had chocolates but heard the ice cream is outstanding and could tell, always a line. 5 🌟 $$

Worn out atmosphere.

We have been getting ice cream from St. Simon’s Sweets for years and this week we had the best service ever!! Shout out to Ja’ques. (I am sure I’ve misspelled his name. Sorry dude) He has the best smile and super friendly. He kept his cool even when they were super busy. Oh and the ice cream is delish. And don’t forget to stop at the candy counter!! The fudge is yummy and they have lots of flavors.