St. Simons Sweets LLC

229 Mallery St, St Simons Island
(912) 638-0150

Recent Reviews

Scott Tillett

Good selection, we didn't try the ice cream but the sweets were good, but felt it wasn't great value for what you get or the service. Disney world prices on most

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Clint Roberson

NOT ALLERGY FRIENDLY!! On March 28th, we asked for an ingredients list for the ice cream, and the staff could not provide one. So, we left and got ice cream somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Matthew Vidas

This is an old-fashioned candy shop with fresh fudge. And a nice screenshot, there. Are definitely some very cool flavors of both and a great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fudge

Janet Dixon

Absolutely love this candy shop! It is a unique store with all kinds of homemade candies & unique gifts. A kids (& also adults) paradise. They make their own ice cream and it is YUM…they will give you a sample taste to help you decide which flavor. They recently had some bad employees, (todays world ?‍♀️), that explains some of the reviews. Working hard to correct!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Jones

My family and I have been here numerous times and have enjoyed everything we ate.My favorites are the ice cream, divinity and pralines

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cheryl Gordon

They have the best ice cream !!!

Rometta Armstrong

The pralines are very mushy with an odd taste. The girl that rang us up at the exit door was texting on her phone the entire time while ringing us up and didn't even speak. Made us feel like our business was unwanted.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Surindra Phulnauth

Great spot for some local ice cream and other sweetsParking: Some spots available

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding Ice Cream

Melinda Rutherford

Ice cream was good, portion and price were good also. Small which was like a decent scoop was about $4.75. Enviroment wqs good. Has candy and ice cream. Carmel apples, fudge etc. Has a little gift shop also.We went in around 8:45pm and they closed late due to spring breakers. Which flooded the shop while we were there. About 20 of them and they were loud and took up most of the space. But this has nothing to do with the stores rating. Just throwing it out there that due to the location you might have to deal with some rude teens. I said excuse me to get out of the shop and got rolling eyes and laughing for being in the way...Overall, go check them out. It's a cute, clean shop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding Ice Cream

Hanay W.

Sea Salt Caramel: 10/10 Some of the best ice cream in town! I love that they rotate flavors and have delicious unique types over time. They have great customer service and a plethora of sweets to accompany the ice cream. highly recommend !

Janet W.

You know when you pass by a sweets shop and cannot resist going in, even though you just ate a huge lunch at Southern Soul BBQ with dessert. Well, I could not resis. I came, I saw, I conquered. Then I saw the grab bags for $4 and conquered some more. Then when I checked out with my pecan bar, Ooey gooey bar, and mega buckets, I realized I earned a free small nice cream. So I walked back and got my free peach cobbler ice cream which is handmade and oh, so good. Never mind that it is January. And it hands are cold. And my family won't help me eat it because we ate a peach cobbler for dessert at lunch. Oh well. One must persevere and enjoy ice cold ice cream when one is given a free ice cream, which was delicious. You should come here and leave happy.

SpammingSpam Spam

Ok so I used to work at this place, and I literally wouldn’t eat anything here, If the public saw how nasty the kitchen is and how the staff “clean” their pots and pans, and how unorganized the management is, y'all wouldn’t eat here too. The prices are ridiculous 5.04 for a small ice cream and even then the employees(which are mainly minors) are miserable and are denied breaks every 4 hours. It’s a tourist trap and I literally would stay far away from here!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alex Hostetler

Some of my favorite ice cream on the island! Tons of delicious and wonderful dessert options too! Feels like you’re stepping into another world when you come in here. Highly recommend checking it out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

James H.

Some of my favorite ice cream on the island! Tons of delicious and wonderful dessert options too! Feels like you're stepping into another world when you come in here. Highly recommend checking it out!

Beth H

Tried to pickup a treat to take home! Supposed to open at 10! At 10:15 still not open! Epic fail on not getting your your store ready before time to open!!!! Highly disappointed!

Load More